II you are unable to think of a single hypothetical scenario to support your position that it may sometimes be appropriate for the state to take a person's organs by force, I think it is fair to say that you cannot provide an objective standard to serve as a test to decide when such forced "donations" should be allowed. And that your inability to think up a scenario is related to the fact that you find the idea abhorrent. Is that a fair assessment of your position?So tell us what your objective standard would be to decide that it is appropriate for the state to force a person to "donate" an organ? I have asked for it three times already.
And I responded, way back, that I have trouble thinking of any plausible scenarios.
I managed to come up with one, hugely implausible, scenario.
Interesting that you brought that up. You can't conceive of a single scenario where it is appropriate for a state to take a person's organs by force, but you appear to have no problem with the state mandating that a pregnant woman be forced to let the fetus use her organs for a period of many months against her expressed will.But all the baby killers keep changing the subject, changing the meanings of words, changing what I said to the exact opposite and quizzing me on why I said that.
By the way, nobody is misrepresenting anything here.
This was your initial response to the poll:
You appear to be saying that under certain circumstances, which are not defined in your post, the state can force a person to donate their organs to another person in need.TomC:
No.
Because you had nothing to do with her need for a kidney.
Tom
This is what you said when you were asked to clarify, just in case I had misunderstood:
So in your mind there may be circumstances where you think it would be appropriate to force someone to donate their kidney to the little girl?
TomC:
Correct.
It's a theoretical possibility.
You appear to be hesitant to defend your own statements, and resort to calling people names and accusing them of bad behavior to try to cover up your own gaffes and flaws in your logic. Cut out the passive aggressive shit and focus on what people are saying. You will be a better person for it.This thread is a great illustration of why I don't believe y'all any more than I believe YEC believers or TeaPartiers. Y'all can't stay on a subject, understand English, or use science to inform your moral code.
Tom