• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

A Christian Facebook Group Stole an Anti-Christian Band’s Art. (They Noticed.)

phands

Veteran Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2013
Messages
1,976
Location
New York, Manhattan, Upper West Side
Basic Beliefs
Hardcore Atheist
Ahhh....yet more true xtians getting caught being true xtians.....and they didn't even apologize....

A Facebook group called True Biblical Christians routinely posts inflammatory images in order to get a rise out of people who disagree with them. Earlier this month, they posted an image with the caption, “If evolution was real, the millions of years of raw meat would’ve given us predator teeth.” It included a picture of a monster of sorts.
Checkmate… I think?

There was just one problem with that image. (Okay, more than one, but stick with me here.) It’s actually the cover art for the album Monolith of Inhumanity by the band Cattle Decapitation

So… it was stolen art used for a completely different purpose than intended. Not only that, but the band is notably anti-Christian.


Axl Rosenberg of the site Metal Sucks explains:


… if you took three seconds to Google ‘Cattle Decapitation,’ you’d realize that the band is staunchly anti-Christian, as denoted by the lyrics to songs like “Not Suitable for Life” (which contains the phrase “God damn your religions”), “Unintelligent Design” (“Your ‘good book’ castrates instinct, a fairy tale glorified”), and “The Gardeners of Eden” (“God damned this world that is if ‘god’ exists/ God hates this world left his ‘son’ tied to a stick?”), sure, but also just by song titles like “Christ on Crack” and “Priest of Ass.” It just doesn’t really make any sense for this particular Facebook group to in any way associate themselves with this particular piece of art.


One person who noticed that connection right away was Travis Ryan, the lead vocalist for the band. And he let the group’s moderators have it:
image: http://wp.production.patheos.com/subdomain/sites/8/2018/08/CattleImageMusic2.png


Hi. I’m Travis. I’m the one who commissioned that art piece you stole for your dissemination of your little fairy tale. Its by the artist Wes Benscoter. It seems, per usual, you people cannot follow your own bible. Remember “THOU SHALL NOT STEAL?” You can’t even get that one right. You are garbage. Your religion is on the top of the garbage heap of organized world religions similar to that monolith there which represents the ills of humanity. That’s you. That’s your man-made nonsense. You are thieves. You are garbage. You will always be garbage. Remember that.


Daaaaaaaamn.


The entire post was then swiftly deleted along with all the comments. No apology was made.



Read more at http://friendlyatheist.patheos.com/2018/08/18/a-christian-facebook-group-stole-an-anti-christian-bands-art-they-noticed-2/
 
As a Christian I (like many) wouldn't have done it, but I'd like to apologise amyway so we can all get along (not that I should do, on those (as) individuals behalf) .

Hope that gives you just a little peace of mind.
:)
 
Why are you apologizing, Learner?

Do you think what they did was wrong?
Do you think what they did reflects on you as a Christain?
What would your apology be? My parents wouldn't let me apologize just with a rote statement, a pro forma placeholder. What is wrong here and why do you apologize?
 
An apology has to contain the implication that you promise to not do it again. Or it's not a sincere apology. That's why apologising for someone else is problematic
 
Yeah, and if offered up without sincerity, it is basically another instance of bearing false witness.
 
As a Christian I (like many) wouldn't have done it, but I'd like to apologise anyway so we can all get along (not that I should do, on those (as) individuals behalf) .

Hope that gives you just a little peace of mind.
:)

The last thing xtianity brings is peace of mind....and you cannot apologize for someone else. You might be apologizing for yourself, though, as you realize that xtianity is actually appalling.
 
WOW.
When did the atheosphere decide to get all precious and sanctimonious about memes?
That FB group has got nothing to apologise for.

"Memes are an interesting way in which people appropriate mass culture seemingly for their own ends - pictures taken from movie stills, stolen photographs, domestic cat pictures, or crude sketches, fixed to a slogan that is either cute, snarky, ironical, or emetically sentimental."
Meme Logic - Lenin's Tomb blog
http://www.leninology.co.uk/2012/10/meme-logic.html
 
That trashy animal decapitation band should be thanking the FB Christians for the free publicity.
...and phands should educate himself about fair use laws relating to internet memes and satire.
 
WOW.
When did the atheosphere decide to get all precious and sanctimonious about memes?
That FB group has got nothing to apologise for.

"Memes are an interesting way in which people appropriate mass culture seemingly for their own ends - pictures taken from movie stills, stolen photographs, domestic cat pictures, or crude sketches, fixed to a slogan that is either cute, snarky, ironical, or emetically sentimental."
Meme Logic - Lenin's Tomb blog
http://www.leninology.co.uk/2012/10/meme-logic.html

I have no problem with them stealing the meme. I think our current copyright laws are rediculous. I support this church on their actions. I don't think it's stealing.
 
I have no problem with them stealing the meme. I think our current copyright laws are rediculous. I support this church on their actions. I don't think it's stealing.
Except that the Christains did not ignore/violate copyright law as a matter of protest against legislation they hold to be ridiculous, did they?

Rather, members of a group that constantly parades their morals as being superior, because of their faith, broke and existing law to further their own agenda.

Sliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiightly different, there.
 
I have no problem with them stealing the meme. I think our current copyright laws are rediculous. I support this church on their actions. I don't think it's stealing.
Except that the Christains did not ignore/violate copyright law as a matter of protest against legislation they hold to be ridiculous, did they?

Rather, members of a group that constantly parades their morals as being superior, because of their faith, broke and existing law to further their own agenda.

Sliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiightly different, there.

That just highlights how stupid the current copyright law is. Copyright infringement is NOT stealing. It's a different type of crime. For something to be stolen you have to be denied access to it after the theft. Copyright infringement is a type of thought crime.

If these guys perched high atop their shiny white steed of righteousness have trouble grasping how it works, then it's a bigger problem than just right and wrong.

I'm still siding with the Christians.
 
I have no problem with them stealing the meme. I think our current copyright laws are rediculous. I support this church on their actions. I don't think it's stealing.
Except that the Christains did not ignore/violate copyright law as a matter of protest against legislation they hold to be ridiculous, did they?

Rather, members of a group that constantly parades their morals as being superior, because of their faith, broke and existing law to further their own agenda.

Sliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiightly different, there.

That just highlights how stupid the current copyright law is.
Not arguing with you about this law. Side with their action all you want.

It's just that the Christains try to flog a meme that they're the law abiding ones, it's the nonbelievers that want to tear down civilization. Ignoring laws, any laws, contradicts their promoted image.
 
Ok...

Apologies for the previous post.
which means what, exactly?

What are you apologizing for now?

What you did? What someone else did? What the Ammelites did to the Clemmishetes during the Besgring dunasty?

For shifting /derail the focus to "all about me" - my apology i.e. having regrets of previous post (that you (plural) trying to make sumink of it, having no advantage really to the OP).
 
Back
Top Bottom