Tharmas
Veteran Member
Over on Freethought Blogs Mano SDingham has an interesting article on the importance of philosophy to science, and in particular, Einstein’s debt to Hume with regards Special Relativity.
Singham links to and quotes at length from an article by Matias Slavov to that effect. Although the insights of Special Relativity were very much “in the air” when Einstein was formulating his theory, he credits reading Hume’s theories of time as an important catalyst.
However, Singham adds some additional thoughts about Einstein’s genius. In contrast to Special Relativity, the concepts of General Relativity were not “in the air” before Einstein. Singham writes:
He ends his essay by speculating:
Altogether I found it an interesting read.
Singham links to and quotes at length from an article by Matias Slavov to that effect. Although the insights of Special Relativity were very much “in the air” when Einstein was formulating his theory, he credits reading Hume’s theories of time as an important catalyst.
However, Singham adds some additional thoughts about Einstein’s genius. In contrast to Special Relativity, the concepts of General Relativity were not “in the air” before Einstein. Singham writes:
But this is not the case for Einstein’s theory of general relativity. Of the three tests of general relativity (the gravitational red shift, the bending of light by gravitational fields, and the rate of precession of the perihelion of Mercury) only the last was known as a problem and it was not seen as an insurmountable one within classical physics. His insight as to what things might look like to someone falling freely in a gravitational field led to his formulation of the Equivalence Principle and later to his General Theory that explained the Mercury problem. This insight was not obvious.
He ends his essay by speculating:
How long might we have gone without realizing that a new theory was needed if Einstein did not have his insight? We now know that if GPS satellites do not make corrections due to the gravitational red shift, then after a day or two they will be off by about 6 miles! So that would definitely have told us that we had a problem. But would we have even reached the stage of putting satellites in space without the General Theory?
Altogether I found it an interesting read.