• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

(Lack of) Religion in Eastern Europe

lpetrich

Contributor
Joined
Jul 27, 2000
Messages
25,148
Location
Eugene, OR
Gender
Male
Basic Beliefs
Atheist
With the fall of Communism in Eastern Europe, the Opium of the People has returned, but in some places much more than in other places.
Poland and Romania seem to have become religious, while the Czech Republic has been the opposite. Russia and Hungary seem to be in between.
 
Russia’s Communist Party turns to the Orthodox Church | Religion | Al Jazeera
More than 25 years after the Soviet collapse, the party vocally appeals to Orthodox Christianity, Russia’s dominant creed. The party’s sole post-Soviet chairman Gennady Zyuganov called Jesus “the first Communist” more than once.

“It is a holy duty of Communists and the Orthodox Church to unite,” Zuyganov wrote in 2012 in his party’s first lengthy document on religion, because both institutions shared “common goals and enemies”. The goals included censorship of “debauchery and violence” in mass media, eradication of Western liberalism and “its conception of human rights”, e-government and sexual education in schools.
Even if that means ignoring the history of Soviet Communists' persecutions of religious leaders and religious believers.
Jesus Christ was the world’s first Communist, Tamara Lavrischeva announced cheerfully.

“Jesus said, ‘Don’t collect earthly wealth, you won’t take it with you after death,'” the 78-year-old pensioner and Orthodox Christian told Al Jazeera as she trudged through the snow-covered streets of central Moscow with thousands of other Communists during the November 7 rally that commemorated the almost-centennial anniversary of the 1917 Bolshevik revolution.

“And Communists thought the same,” she added, her voice drowned by the crowd chanting Soviet-era songs under red banners with hammers and sickles and portraits of Soviet leaders Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin.

With a dismissive shrug and a condescending smile, Lavrischeva rejected the killings, imprisonment and persecution of millions of Orthodox Christian clerics and believers at the hand of Communists.
 
Russia’s resurgent love for Josef Stalin | History | Al Jazeera - "Millions were jailed or executed during the Great Purge, but the dictator is increasingly being remembered fondly."
Nikolai Svanidze’s paternal grandfather and namesake was a Communist official in Soviet Georgia – and a distant relative of Josef Stalin’s first wife.

But the kinship meant nothing to the Soviet dictator and his henchmen. Svanidze was arrested and beaten to death during an interrogation in 1937, at the height of what Russians call the Great Purge, when some 720,000 people died at the hands of Stalin’s secret police in less than 18 months.

Millions were jailed, executed, deported and displaced, including entire ethnic groups or social classes, during Stalin’s 1927-1953 rule, and millions more died of famines caused by his disastrous agriculture policies.

More than 60 years after Stalin’s own death, Svanidze’s grandson, a historian and television personality, witnesses the dictator’s return as an increasingly popular, and polarising, figure.

“I constantly see people who say ‘he purged my entire family, but I still respect him’,” Svanidze, whose documentaries on Russian history are among the few examples of television shows critical of Stalin, told Al Jazeera.

“It’s a Stockholm syndrome of some kind.”

During President Vladimir Putin’s rule, the choir of Stalin’s supporters has grown bigger, stronger and louder – while critics and scholars who document his totalitarian regime’s atrocities have lost access to Kremlin-controlled media and are now branded “foreign agents”.

Public figures, lawmakers, top officials and even clerics with Russia’s dominant Orthodox Church – that suffered countless losses at the hands of atheist communists – declare their support for Stalin along with tens of millions of ordinary Russians.
Joseph Stalin led the Soviet Union to victory against Nazi Germany, and he even went so far as to bring back the Russian Orthodox Church.

But World War II began with Germany and the Soviet Union agreeing to a nonaggression pact, and that let Germany conquer and attack much of Europe. Behind the scenes, however, Adolf Hitler complained that Joseph Stalin "demands more and more", that "he's a cold-blooded blackmailer." When Hitler declared war on the Soviet Union in June 1941, Stalin reportedly had a nervous breakdown.
 
Roughly 2/3 of Russia's 143 million people consider themselves followers of the Russian Orthodox Church. Though many of them are only nominally religious, the ROC nevertheless represents a big demographic bloc.
The Communist Party easily fields tens of thousands of supporters for rallies. Zyuganov has run for president four times, always coming second, and the party he has headed since 1993 holds almost a tenth of seats in the State Duma, Russia’s lower house of parliament, forming its second-largest fraction.

But in reality, the Communist Party is a colossus on feet of clay.

Its support has been waning for years; its loyalists are simply dying out. The age of an average party member is 56, and the number of members has fallen to about 155,000 – a trivial number in comparison with the 19.5 million Soviet Communists in 1989. The speeches of Zyuganov – balding, pudgy and famously uncharismatic – hardly attract millennials or middle-class urbanites, the main antagonists of the Kremlin.
It celebrates Stalin, and it recruited some notable people to its parliamentary-election ticket.
The most devout churchgoers are mostly elderly women, pensioners, in a certain sense the CP’s electoral base,” Denis Volkov of the Levada Centre, Russia’s last independent pollster, told Al Jazeera.

The Church’s response to the party‘s overtures has been polite and positive.

“All political forces should be together when it comes to the values of faith, morals, culture and our nation’s unity,” Russian Patriarch Kirill was quoted by the Interfax news agency as saying in 2014 when he handed Zyuganov a medal of Glory and Honour, his Church’s top award, on his 70th birthday.

In February, Zyuganov congratulated Kirill on the five-year anniversary of his enthronement. “One of the most serious mistakes of my predecessors was that they fell out with the Church,” he told the patriarch.
Except that they did much worse. MUCH MUCH MUCH MUCH worse.
But these days, Communists even blame their own godlessness on the USSR’s collapse.

“Atheism destroyed the Soviet Union,” Vadim Potomsky, a Communist governor of the western Oryol region, reportedly said in mid-July.
What does he say about the Marxist Scriptures describing religion as the opium of the people?
“If Jesus Christ, Muhammad and Buddha had not been prophets, they would have been 100 percent Communists,” Zuyganov told the Kommersant daily in December 2015. The U-turn towards religion also reflects a tectonic transformation in the Communist Party‘s ideology.

Zyuganov still pledges to nationalise Russia’s oil and gas industry, restore a socialist welfare state, and stand up to the “rotting Western capitalism”.

But, instead of messianic strife for a worldwide “proletarian unity”, today’s Communist Party endorses nationalism and exploits a widespread nostalgia for the Soviet past.

It is “a party of imperialistic nostalgia and Russian nationalism, and there’s no imperialism or nationalism without Russian Orthodoxy,” Andrei Kolesnikov of the Moscow Carnegie Centre, a think-tank, told Al Jazeera.
A party of Russian national greatness, just like the Chinese Communist Party as the party of Chinese national greatness.
 
Some Communists in Russia Are Turning to Christ
What do Vladimir Lenin, founder of the officially atheist Soviet Union, and Jesus Christ have in common? Not much, one would think. Yet according to Gennady Zyuganov, the veteran leader of Russia's modern-day Communist Party, both men sought to "save humanity" with a message of "love, friendship, and brotherhood".

Speaking in Moscow in front of a crowd of red-flag-waving supporters on the 145th anniversary of Lenin's birth late last month, Zyuganov also declared that the Soviet Union was an attempt to establish "God's Kingdom on Earth".
More on this coexistence of godless materialists and drug addicts:
This fusion of Soviet and Christian beliefs works both ways. Online footage of a Russian Orthodox priest singing a popular Soviet-era song at a church service recently went viral in Russia, while religious icons with images of Stalin are a common sight at gatherings of the religious Right. An Orthodox Christian church has also recently been constructed on the territory of Russia's vast memorial complex to the over one million Soviet soldiers who died during the Battle of Stalingrad, ostensibly in defence of an atheist state.

Russian Orthodox Church officials also display ambiguous attitudes towards the Soviet era. "While there was no place for God in the Soviet system, Christian values were far more apparent under Communist rule than in the West, where material wealth has always been of utmost importance," says Vsevolod Chaplin, a spokesman for the Russian Orthodox Church. Chaplin has also described Stalin as a contradictory figure, with both "positive" and "negative" sides.

Jesus Christ was world's first COMMUNIST, Russian Marxist leader Zyuganov says, repeating claim holy savior was really a socialist — RT Russia & Former Soviet Union - "From casting out the moneylenders to feeding the masses and healing the poor for free, Jesus Christ's revolutionary zeal matches up with almost all of Communism's ideological values, one of Russia's top politicians has claimed. "

Jesus Was the First Communist, Russian Party Leader Says - The Moscow Times
“Put Jesus' Sermon on the Mount and the Moral Code of the Builder of Communism next to each other, and you will just gasp,” Gennady Zyuganov said Thursday in a radio interview with the Komsomolskaya Pravda tabloid.

He added that "the main slogan of communism — ‘He who does not work shall not eat’ — is written in the Apostle Paul's Second Epistle to the Thessalonians" found in the New Testament.

“We need to study the Bible,” Zyuganov concluded.
 
Siberia’s resurgent shamanism | Religion | Al Jazeera - "One of the world’s oldest spiritual belief systems has attracted new followers since the fall of the Soviet Union."
Despite being driven to the edges of society, shamanism – the belief in good and evil spirits and rituals to appease them – has experienced a resurgence in recent years. The word shamanism itself is believed to have originated from the language of the Evenks who inhabit Siberia’s eastern edge.

Further west near the Mongolian border, shamanism is often called Tengerism, a term that means “the honouring of spirits”.

In this region, as in most of the world, the practice was largely forced out by competing beliefs – in Siberia’s case through occasionally violent conflict with Tibetan Buddhism for centuries, followed by decades of state repression under the Soviet Union.

The collapse of the Soviet Union heralded a religious revival throughout Russia. Perhaps unexpectedly, Tengerism has achieved newfound popularity, not just in its traditional homeland, but also across Russia and beyond.
Give us that old-time religion, they might say.

But some sects have not done well. Jehovah's Witnesses are being persecuted as "extremists".
Russia: Escalating Persecution of Jehovah’s Witnesses | Human Rights Watch
Law enforcement authorities across Russia have dramatically escalated the nationwide persecution of Jehovah’s Witnesses in the past 12 months, Human Rights Watch said today. One year after President Vladimir Putin said that the crackdown against them should be “looked into,” the numbers of house raids and people under criminal investigation have more than doubled, and 32 Jehovah’s Witnesses worshipers are behind bars for peacefully practicing their faith.

At least 313 people are facing charges, are on trial, or have been convicted of criminal “extremism” for engaging in Jehovah’s Witnesses’ activities, or are suspects in such cases. About two-thirds of them found out about their status as suspect or accused in 2019. Authorities have carried out at least 780 house raids since 2017 in more than 70 towns and cities across Russia, more than half of them in 2019. Courts convicted 18 people in 2019, nine of whom received prison sentences ranging from two to six years, for such activities as leading or participating in prayer meetings. Verdicts are expected in several cases later in January.
 
 Cathedral of Christ the Saviour
The current church is the second to stand on this site. The original church, built during the 19th century, took more than 40 years to build, and was the scene of the 1882 world premiere of the 1812 Overture composed by Tchaikovsky. It was destroyed in 1931 on the order of Soviet leader Joseph Stalin. The demolition was supposed to make way for a colossal Palace of the Soviets to house the country's legislature, the Supreme Soviet of the USSR. Construction started in 1937 but was halted in 1941 when Germany invaded the Soviet Union during World War II. Its steel frame was disassembled the following year, and the Palace was never built. Following the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the current church was rebuilt on the site between 1995 and 2000.

I also recall a news story from the 1990's about Russians being very interested in a very curious traveling exhibition: the head of a saint. Also of maintainers of Communist museums not having much of a clue as to why these museums don't get as many attendees as they once did.

Russia Reopens the Last Czar’s Palace, a Century After His Execution - The New York Times - "The last home of Nicholas II has been restored and opened to the public as a museum outside of St. Petersburg."
Nicholas II’s choice, on the eve of revolution, to abandon his troops and reunite with his family at Alexander Palace, divides many who study the time period.

To some, it is an indictment: He put his family above the interests of his country, over which he had absolute power.

But to many Russian Orthodox believers, Nicholas II’s acceptance of his fate was a show of humility. In 2000, the Russian Orthodox Church canonized him and his family as passion bearers, a category used to identify believers who endured suffering and death with Christ-like piety.
A martyr to the Godless Communists.
 
The Dogma Lives Loudly in Putin: Christian Russia vs. Secular USA | Stephen Ryan
Quoting Vladimir Putin:
The people in the West are actually ashamed of their religious affiliation and are indeed frightened to speak about them. Christian holidays and celebrations are abolished or neutrally renamed as if they were ashamed of those Christian holidays. With this method one hides away the deeper moral value of theses celebrations. And those countries try to force this model onto other countries, globally. I am deeply convinced that this is a direct way to the degradation and primitivization of culture. This leads to a deeper demographic and moral crisis in the West.

Putin has not only talked the talk of defending Christianity; he has backed up his talk with military intervention. Russia has repeatedly made the assertion that his country’s move into Syria to support the embattled government was, in part, motivated to protect Christians sects who were victims of genocide at the hands of ISIS.
It was unsourced, but I found some of that text in some books at books.google.com
In contrast, the Russian government is funding the restoration of Orthodox churches with public dollars. Russian Orthodox bishops are regularly seen at military installations conducting religious ceremonies, chanting prayers, carrying icons of the Virgin Mary, and madly tossing holy water everywhere. At a ceremony at the opening of a new Russian Orthodox cathedral, Putin said, “It is impossible to imagine Russia without Christianity.” The Christian renewal taking place in Russia is a real event with incalculable geopolitical consequences, so it is imperative that USA policymakers understand Russia’s total commitment to defending its culture, a culture that begins with Russians’ belief that Christianity is the foundation of their country.
But it's mainly the Russian Orthodox Church.
 
It's not just Jehovah's Witnesses who are being persecuted.

RUSSIA Persecution of non-orthodox groups continues as police interrupt Baptist service - 2019

"The Evangelical Baptist community in Verkhnebakanskiy (Novorossiysk) is registered with the government, but does not have a place of worship of its own, so its members meet in private homes. According to police, all Baptist, Adventist, Pentecostal sects etc. are guilty of “breaking the spiritual unity of the Russian people "and should be banned."

"The authorities of Novorossiysk have confirmed the ban on gathering to pray in homes, a measure that is increasingly being applied with extreme rigour throughout Russia against various Protestant communities."

Christians Fleeing Persecution in Russia Can Stay in Germa...... | News & Reporting | Christianity Today - "Faced with mounting threats and anti-missionary laws, Baptists win asylum appeal despite supposed constitutional protections in their home country."
 
Back
Top Bottom