• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

Large planets - unable to coexist with each other?

lpetrich

Contributor
Joined
Jul 27, 2000
Messages
26,334
Location
Eugene, OR
Gender
Male
Basic Beliefs
Atheist
[1906.03266] Signatures of a planet-planet impacts phase in exoplanetary systems hosting giant planets
Exoplanetary systems host giant planets on substantially non-circular, close-in orbits. We propose that these eccentricities arise in a phase of giant impacts, analogous to the final stage of Solar System assembly that formed Earth's Moon. In this scenario, the planets scatter each other and collide, with corresponding mass growth as they merge. We numerically integrate an ensemble of systems with varying total planet mass, allowing for collisional growth, to show that (1) the high-eccentricity giants observed today may have formed preferentially in systems of higher initial total planet mass, and (2) the upper bound on the observed giant planet eccentricity distribution is consistent with planet-planet scattering. We predict that mergers will produce a population of high-mass giant planets between 1 and 5 au from their stars.
Meaning that large planets cannot coexist with each other very well, and I mean Jovian large, like Jupiter and Saturn.

The authors used stars' "metallicity" as a proxy for the amount of heavy elements in the stars' protoplanetary disks. "Heavy" being heavier than hydrogen and helium. Astrophysicists call all such heavy elements "metals". This is important because Jovian planets likely form from large icy or rocky planets, by collecting hydrogen and helium from the protoplanetary nebula.

Furthermore, one would expect planets to have circular and coplanar orbits. That is approximately the case for the Solar System, and the planets' orbits are also well-spaced. Planetoids like asteroids and TNO's and comets often have more eccentricity and inclination in their orbits.

But exoplanets have provided many surprises, like lots of warm and hot Jovian planets. It is hard for them to form when relatively close, so they must have spiraled in by interacting with the protoplanetary nebula. Another oddity is some of them having very eccentric orbits.

The authors found that higher metallicity tends to give higher eccentricities, and that the highest eccentricities are reached by Jupiter-mass planets at roughly 1 AU from their stars.

These results are fairly close to what one finds with simulations. These simulations included planets perturbing each others' orbits and colliding with each other. Larger planets perturb each other more, accounting for the high eccentriciies of the survivors. Higher metallicities mean more Jovian-planet nuclei, thus more Jovian planets.


From NASA Exoplanet Archive, the highest known eccentricity is form planet HD 20782 b : 0.950 +- 0.001

That planet orbits a star that is very much like the Sun. That star's distance is 36 parsecs or 117 light years, and its visual magnitude is around +7.4. One will need a telescope to see it. It is in constellation Fornax, the Furnace, with RA = 03h20m03.58s and Dec = -28d51m14.7s a sort of celestial longitude and latitude. It will be difficult to see from mid-northern latitudes, though much better from equatorial or mid-southern latitudes.

The planet's projected mass is 1.5 Jupiter masses, and its semimajor axis is 1.36 AU. Its closest and farthest distances are 0.068 and 2.65 AU. The planet's equilibrium temperatures at closest, major-axis, and farthest distances are 1134, 253, and 181 K, or 860, -20, and -92 C.

Its orbit period is 597.06 (Earth) days or 1.63 (Julian) years. But it is closer than twice its closest distance for only 4 days.
 
Back
Top Bottom