Ms. Schlussel's angry article may lack compassion, but it also raises a few good points. I have no idea how connected the ISM is to HAMAS but there is little doubt that Ms. Mueller had made up her mind about the "evils" of Israel long ago, and had a great deal of "solidarity" with the Palestinian cause (among many other serial causes, before and after).
Mueller was a naive idealist driven by raw emotions; an otherwise intelligent young woman consumed with the hubris of moral crusading,someone who needed to belong to something greater than herself. The press portrayed her as a professional, as an "aide worker" from Arizona, but in reality she was closer to being a cause addicted dilettante. Serious but unsophisticated, before she graduated from college she organized marches for Darfur and volunteered for America's Promise. In the "influential" college of Northern Arizona she was President of a group formed "to end mass atrocities"...(yada yada).
Graduating in 2009 and seeking new sources vent her altruistic indignation, she became one of the hundreds of other young Western "occupation tourists" who got a free ticket to trek to the West Bank to "protest" in solidarity with Palestinians (for a month or two). On arrival ISM gave her their standard two day training program before housing her. She wore her kaffiyah and got to be noisy - earning the honor of being detained by police for few hours. Later she stayed in the ISM protest tent and joined the weekly Friday protests, designed to provoke the IDF. She may have even experienced the thrill of cheering on the rock throwing Palestinians, and then running from the tear gas.
Intoxicated by the experience , she wrote: “Oppression greets us from all angles. Oppression wails from the soldiers radio and floats through tear gas clouds in the air … But resistance is nestled in the cracks in the wall, resistance flows from the minaret 5 times a day and resistance sits quietly in jail knowing its time will come again."
After a month or two, perhaps wearing out her welcome (occupation tourists tend to forget they are there to support the Palestinian protestors, not to be Palestinians) Mueller went to Tel Aviv and claimed to have done some voluntary work "empowering" African refugees in Israel (although the records on this are scanty).
Mueller then returned home to Arizona, for a year - first volunteering at an AIDS clinic and then later for a women’s shelter. Finding those a bit boring she jetted off to be an au pair in Paris, but after a while she went to Turkey in December 2012. She began volunteering with different aid groups, including the Danish Refugee Council and the Support To Life, which assists Syrian women and children refugees who have crossed into Turkey.
Mueller returned home for several months, then returned to the mideast and met her boyfriend, a Syrian activist living in Cairo. She traveled with him to Syria, but she was not under any aid organization's auspices. She was there a day and half when she was kidnapped in August of 2013.
There is tragedy and sadness in her death - in part because of her self-deception about the cultures and people's she attempted to serve... a tragedy in her own inability to see beyond her 'hunger for justice'. In her peace rallies and protest marches, in her gullibility and caring, she never really understood who was using her or what causes she was truly serving.
So it is difficult for Israel supporters to feel sorry for Mueller, because to them she was murdered by her own side...except she had no idea whose side she was on.