Why do supporters of Israel act like Jews, Muslims, and Christians didn't live peacefully side by side for centuries when the Ottoman Turks were in charge of Palestine? Is it because Zionist myths don't allow historical facts to get in the way of the narrative? Is it because they have no interest in learning about the history of Israel/Palestine/Canaan? Or is it just racism and religious bigotry overriding common sense and honesty?
Jerusalem and the surrounding countryside has been the home of Jews, Christians, and Muslims for the past 14 centuries, and the place was pretty darn quiet for nearly all of them. All this bloviating about how peaceful co-existence is impossible looks and smells like bullshit.
And whites and blacks lived basically peacefully side by side in the 1800's in the south. Liberating the slaves turned things hostile.
Do you think you can stretch the meaning of the word peaceful to encompass murderous oppression? Even if you could, the Ottomans didn't enslave the Palestinians.
Are you admitting that Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived peacefully side by side in Palestine for centuries? If we compared the history of a village of Palestinian Jews with that of a nearby village of Christians and Muslims, do you acknowledge we aren't going to find much in the way of conflict between them?
You're the one who stretched the meaning. I simply applied it to another situation where I knew you would see the oppression.
The non-Muslims weren't enslaved but they were definitely second-class citizens and had to put up with occasional murders and massacres.
- - - Updated - - -
It takes all sides to make peace - the first step is promoting trust among all the relevant actors. Until that happens, there is no peace. And that requires every side to act.One set of actors has the ability to make peace.
The oppressed set of actors are helpless.
They can do nothing to move the process forward.
Yes, one group has the ability to make peace: The Palestinians.
Yeah, it takes all sides--and the Palestinians aren't interested. I posted this to show what happens to a Palestinian who actually advocates for peace.
- - - Updated - - -
Using your analogy, the hostilities occurred because some of the whites could not handle that liberation. Applying your analogy to the Israeli-Palestinian situation, the Israelis are clearly the "whites" (i.e. oppressors) and the Palestinians are clearly the "slaves" (i.e. the oppressed). Which means you are tacitly admitting the Israelis will be the problem.And whites and blacks lived basically peacefully side by side in the 1800's in the south. Liberating the slaves turned things hostile.
Total failure.
The Israelis are the ones who threw off their oppressors.
The Palestinians are the whites, the Jews are the blacks.
- - - Updated - - -
Why do supporters of Israel act like Jews, Muslims, and Christians didn't live peacefully side by side for centuries when the Ottoman Turks were in charge of Palestine? Is it because Zionist myths don't allow historical facts to get in the way of the narrative? Is it because they have no interest in learning about the history of Israel/Palestine/Canaan? Or is it just racism and religious bigotry overriding common sense and honesty?
Jerusalem and the surrounding countryside has been the home of Jews, Christians, and Muslims for the past 14 centuries, and the place was pretty darn quiet for nearly all of them. All this bloviating about how peaceful co-existence is impossible looks and smells like bullshit.
And whites and blacks lived basically peacefully side by side in the 1800's in the south. Liberating the slaves turned things hostile.
Slaves were continually beaten and tortured. Any infraction could result in torture, to the point of visible mutilation to persuade others.
That is not peace.
It is a state of continual violence or threat of violence.
That you think it is peace is telling.
It's as much peace as existed in Muslim lands before the formation of Israel.