pood
Contributor
- Joined
- Last seen
Latest activity Postings About
-
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".Ad hom again. You really are contemptible. -
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".No, you have not. You have waffled, evaded, confabulated, and ignored questions. How is light at the eye instantly, when you concede it...
-
pood reacted to steve_bank's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with
Like.
Pg There is no anger, stop playing the martyr and victim. -
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".No one is angry over his claim about the eyes. His claims are laughable, and we do laugh. Not anger — but exasperation — arises with...
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".P1: Light takes time to get to the eye. P2: Light is at the eye instantly. :rolleyes:
-
pood reacted to bilby's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with Like.
Nothing happens. The light carries on through space until it encounters something. Do you know what the inverse square law is? Sorry...
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".It’s completely for naught, just as it was everywhere else you have been. I’ve been reading your latest exchanges with bilby and have...
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".What is it? In fact, there can be no evidence, because it cannot logically be the case that light is at the eye instantly while taking...
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".How did we measure the speed of light in the first place, if we see in real time, without a light delay?
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".Why are you even posting this? Do you think it helps your position? It does not.
-
pood reacted to bilby's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with Like.
Nobody believes this: "It is the light that supposedly brings to the eye the wavelength/frequency that turns into an image in the...
-
pood reacted to bilby's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with Like.
The light that is recflected off the object is not an image. That - That right there - is the light that is reflected off the object...
-
pood replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".Um, @peacegirl?? To reiterate the key point: It CANNOT be the case both that we see in real time, AND that light has a finite velocity...
-
pood reacted to bilby's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with Like.
Sure there is. If he saw Io in real time, the discrepancy he noted could not have existed; Io would be seen at the same predicted point...
-
pood reacted to bilby's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with Like.
I am certainly not ignoring that claim. I have asked repeatedly what makes light necessary as a condition of sight, if not as the means...
-
-
Loading…
-
Loading…