-
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".DBT, these are two different discoveries. His second discovery does play a part, but it's not the one that will prevent that for which...
-
Ppeacegirl reacted to DBT's post in the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will" with
Like.
No doubt. It just doesn't relate all that well with the nature of determinism as it happens to be defined. -
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".Yes, as they define it, but definitions mean nothing where reality is concerned. Absolutely nothing. The definition of free will does...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".You are making general statements in order to distinguish contingent from necessary, but this really doesn't relate to the individual...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".I'm sorry but Pood's effort to prove that we have free will based on Swartz's modal logic is just beyond me. I really don't get that he...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".This whole modal logic thing does not prove that determinism is false, or compatibilism is true, when free will is a figment of the...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".So what if it is logically possible to choose from any number of alternatives and therefore our choices are not necessary truths like...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".I am not sure where the word "contingent" means something could have happened in a different way or not at all. It's just a synonym for...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".Being logically possible is not even being contested. Everyone knows it’s logically possible for Trump not to lie tomorrow or for you...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".But these writings are not compatibilism because the two are opposites if you don't cheat by changing the definition of "free will" to...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".But "contingent" does not mean "free." It means dependent on in this context. (contingent on/upon) occurring or existing only if...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".A law of nature describes, not prescribes; consequently, there is nothing wrong with saying something is a law of our nature. We are...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".How can a contingent act (acts that could have been otherwise) be reversed after the act is executed? There is no way it can be proven...
-
Ppeacegirl replied to the thread “Revolution in Thought: A new look at determinism and free will".In different situations, it's obvious that when something is contingently true, our choices could be different depending on the...
-
-
Loading…
-
Loading…