• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

The biggest threat to US democracy that you haven’t heard of

phands

Veteran Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2013
Messages
1,976
Location
New York, Manhattan, Upper West Side
Basic Beliefs
Hardcore Atheist
This is rather scary, especially as 28 states have demanded such a convention....

The biggest threat to our democracy that nobody is talking about is the real possibility of a rogue Constitutional convention – empowering extremists to radically reshape the Constitution, our laws, and our country.


If just a few more states sign on to what’s called an “Article V convention” for a balanced budget amendment, there’s no limit to the damage they might do.


Let me explain.


There are 2 ways to amend the United States Constitution: One way – the way we’ve passed every amendment since the Bill of Rights – is for two-thirds of the House and two-thirds of the Senate to vote for a proposed amendment, and then have it ratified by at least three quarters of the states – now 38 in number.


But there’s a second way to amend the Constitution. Two thirds of the states may demand that Congress form a constitutional convention to propose amendments.


Once such a constitutional convention is convened, there are no rules to limit or constrain what comes next.


Amendments proposed by an Article V convention are supposed to be ratified by 38 states. But convention delegates could hijack the process and change the ratification process itself, tossing out the 38 state requirement.


A balanced budget amendment would be crazy enough. But nothing would be safe. A woman’s right to choose. Marriage equality. First Amendment protections for free speech and a free press. Equal protection of the laws. Checks and balances.


An Article V convention would allow delegates to write their own agenda into our Constitution.

Read the full thing - it's important.
 
The harm of Republicans gerrymandering districts is a much more clear and present (and been fucking us over the last 8 years) danger to our democracy than an Article V convention.
 
The harm of Republicans gerrymandering districts is a much more clear and present (and been fucking us over the last 8 years) danger to our democracy than an Article V convention.
Agreed. This is like the states that 'vote to succeed' every few years. It wont' really go anywhere, but it serves to rile up some of the more rabid end of the base, and lets the politicians say they 'tried'....
 
I read about this a couple of weeks ago, and while it's some scary stuff, I agree with those that say it's not going to happen. I seriously doubt that even if they held a new constitutional convention, there would never be enough states to agree on some of the more extreme measures. I think I probably read about this in one of the two major newspapers that I rely on for my news.
 
They shouldn't have allowed a new constitutional convention in the first place. Changes should be by amendment only.
 
Back
Top Bottom