• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

The Emotional and Physical Harm of Religion

southernhybrid

Contributor
Joined
Aug 12, 2001
Messages
11,172
Location
Georgia, US
Basic Beliefs
atheist
This thread is for anyone who has experienced, has known someone who has experienced or can give examples of how religion often does harm to individuals. I feel as if I've gotten over the harm it did to me during my childhood and. young adulthood, but I'd like to share my experiences and hope some of you will too. And, I will likely also add a few of the more general harms of religion to society. I'm not claiming that all religious people are harmful, or that every sect of a religion is hateful, but the more conservative ones often do harm people.

First of all, my parents were not at all religious when I was very young. Sure, they believed in a god, but never went to church or practiced any kind of religious rituals that I know of. Those memories were good. My mother started going to a conservative Baptist church in NJ when I was about 4 and became "saved". Saved, as most of you know is the term that conservative Christians use to say they are saved from hell due to their beliefs. So, how did it damage me?

1. I was told that all of my Catholic friends were going to hell for eternity if they weren't "saved". That upset me emotionally. I used to ask my father why a loving god would punish people for all eternity , including those in Africa who had never even heard of the gospel. The answer was always th at god would explain it to us when we got to heaven.

2. My mother forced me to stop going to dancing school when I was about 6 or 7. I loved dancing school. I enjoyed the creativity of dancing and performing at the recital.

3. I was told that playing cards was a sin, so I wasn't permitted to play cards, although we could play with my grandmother, despite it making my mother very nervous. It had something to do with gambling.

4. Although we were permitted to watch TV movies, we weren't allowed to go to the movies, although I did go with my friends in high school, while never telling my mother where we were going.

5. One of my first dates was with a nice, handsome Jewish boy, but since it made my mom very nervous that I wasn't dating a born again Christian, I only dated him a couple of times.

6. My father, who was a very damage man used the excuse, "spare the rod and spoil the child" He would beat us with his belt very harshly, although I was able to stand up to him and get him to stop by the age of about 8. He continued to abuse my younger sister.

7, Speaking of my damaged father, he started thinking that god would send him to hell because he had killed Japanese soldiers during WWII. Of course war is hell, but without religion, at least he wouldn't have had a fear of eternal torture.

8. My father had a massive. heart attack, but was successfully resuscitated, by the local EMTs. He never had a near death experience, and again that made him fear hell.

9. I saw a woman try to convince a relative of hers that if she didn't ask Jesus to save her, she was headed for hell. The woman was one of my patients and she was in the early stages of dementia. I felt so sorry for her being badgered like that.

10.When we owned a little get a way condo in Florida, i recall seeing a man tied to a cross at Easter time to "celebrate" the death of Jesus. It was such a weird, sad sight to see someone do that.

11. When I left Christianity, my parents stopped helping me pay for college. Okay. That's not so bad, but I probably married my first husband partly to get out of their home.

One I almost forgot. My mother had a close Catholic friend who died. I was visiting her at the time and one of her nutty evangelical friends came to visit. She said to my mom, "Did you talk to her about the Lord", with the implication that if she didn't, her friend was now in hell. I wanted to scream at her but kept silent for my mother's sake. Why would she ask my mother after the woman had died and why the fuck did they think that Catholics were going to hell? It's so crazy and cruel. if there was a god, wouldn't that entity care about how people acted instead of what they believed?

12. My first husband was a Baha'i, which at the time I thought wasn't such a bad religion, compared to Christianity. But, it turned out he was a fanatic and he blamed our failed marriage on me not being a member of his religion. Then recently he told our son and his daughter from his 2nd marriage that he was going to give his life's savings to his religion instead of to them. They deserve the money as he never did much for either of them, which is why I call the step dad, the real dad. I've never met my son's half sister but learned that she was homeless for awhile and my ex never helped her out. His third wife told my dil that all he cared about was his religion. I felt sorry for her.

13. I live in the Bible Belt and some of my Christian friends know I'm an atheist. Although they don't try to convert me, they feel free to say things in front of me about how they know god is real etc. I find that a bit rude. I never tell them that their god is fake, as I care about them and don't want to hurt their feelings. Why can't people keep their beliefs to themselves unless asked? Then there are the street preachers downtown. I so want to tell them to go do some charity work like their good book says to do instead of telling people they are going to hell if they don't have the same beliefs as they do.

14. My sister suffers from anxiety and has always had a guilt complex, which I think is a result of our religious upbringing. Oddly enough, she continues to believe, although she's not sure what version of Christianity is the right one.

15. Of course, if you read about the history of non belief and religion, you know that some people were jailed, tortured and even executed for being agnostic, atheist or simply being the wrong sect of the dominant religion in their country. Some of that is still alive today in parts of the Muslim world. I'm currently reading a book about that and even wondering if the current atmosphere in the US will lead us back to that type of discrimination. Even some of my Christian friends are concerned about that. Even my late mother supported the SCS.

Anyone else need to share how religion harmed them during childhood or adulthood? Did you get over it? What helped? When I realized there were no gods, the truth set me free. If you're a liberal Christian or member of another religion, who was raised by conservative believers, please feel to share your story too. Members of liberal religions are atheists friends imo. I've even known three atheist methodists, who enjoyed their church community. We should join with them to keep the crazies from taking over. There used to be a member here who was a minister in a very liberal Baptist church in ATL. I met him and his wife in person. Most of his church members were gay. We lost touch and I have no idea if he still believes, but people like him are our allies. if you need a bit of the supernatural in your life, use it for good and be accepting of those who don't.
 
When I was going into third grade my parents pulled me out of public school and enrolled me and my brothers into a Fundamentalist Baptist school to save me from drugs, evolution, etc. It was an hour and a half bus ride for us, which meant not being able to play team sports which is what I was dying to do and would certainly have had the opportunity to do so if I had remained in public school.
Also, because of the switch, I somehow became a pariah to the friends I had made in my first few years in whose neighborhood I lived in and thus became socially backward.
That's just a little of what I experienced.
 
When I was going into third grade my parents pulled me out of public school and enrolled me and my brothers into a Fundamentalist Baptist school to save me from drugs, evolution, etc. It was an hour and a half bus ride for us, which meant not being able to play team sports which is what I was dying to do and would certainly have had the opportunity to do so if I had remained in public school.
Also, because of the switch, I somehow became a pariah to the friends I had made in my first few years in whose neighborhood I lived in and thus became socially backward.
That's just a little of what I experienced.
Thanks for sharing that. Your experience is exactly the type of thing I was thinking about when I wrote the OP.

At least my sisters and I stayed in public schools, but luckily in NJ, where I grew up, all of the private schools were Catholic and my parents believed that Catholics were going to hell. Most of my childhood friends were Catholic or fairly liberal protestants and I never was close to any of the children I met at church.

Speaking of church, we were forced to attend Sunday school, the main church service, youth choir, youth group and then the evening church service, as well as Pioneer Girls on Fridays nights, the evangelical version of Girl Scouts. I hated it. I felt I was deprived of my Sundays. We also had to attend a Bible Study in the afternoon and day a week, as well as Vacation Bible School for about 2 weeks in the summer. Luckily the brainwashing didn't take, as I left it all behind around the age of 18, while attending a fundamentalist Christian college right down the road from Salem, Ma. where the witch burnings took place in early America. That was quite awful too, but it helped me see how crazy and hateful conservative Christians could be when being with them 24/7. One semester was all I could take.
 
Currently experiencing the country becoming a theocracy, which affects every American and is in itself psychologically harmful to exist in. If that counts.
 
Currently experiencing the country becoming a theocracy, which affects every American and is in itself psychologically harmful to exist in. If that counts.
Yes. I think it counts and it has impacted an awful lot of us, including many of my more moderately Christian friends. I just wish they would stop telling me that they are praying that god will do something about this and/or that god knows that Trump's time will be up soon etc. I've ranted about that in the rant thread, but it's sad and disturbing that people I care about think their prayers are going to save the country. They also think that we each have a preordained time when we will die. I want to shout at them if they believe that, why do they bother going to a doctor when they are sick or why are they trying to live a healthy lifestyle, if it's all been decided by their god? What's that expression? I believe in just one less god than you do. Maybe I'll use that one on them if they bring up the topic again. :giggle:
 
Currently experiencing the country becoming a theocracy, which affects every American and is in itself psychologically harmful to exist in. If that counts.
Yes. I think it counts and it has impacted an awful lot of us, including many of my more moderately Christian friends. I just wish they would stop telling me that they are praying that god will do something about this and/or that god knows that Trump's time will be up soon etc.
Sounds like my mother who's said basically the same thing. I'd ask her why god allowed more than a million to die from Covid, but Trump is still around, but I don't talk about religion with her.
 
Currently experiencing the country becoming a theocracy, which affects every American and is in itself psychologically harmful to exist in. If that counts.
Yes. I think it counts and it has impacted an awful lot of us, including many of my more moderately Christian friends. I just wish they would stop telling me that they are praying that god will do something about this and/or that god knows that Trump's time will be up soon etc.
Sounds like my mother who's said basically the same thing. I'd ask her why god allowed more than a million to die from Covid, but Trump is still around, but I don't talk about religion with her.
I get it. I avoid discussing religion with my sister, who still believes, although I have no idea if she thinks that prayer can save us from Trump. At least she never voted for him. I'll give her that.
 
What scares me is the lack of pushback from Atheists, intellectuals, people with common sense and the media
When someone says "if you don't believe, you are going to hell" does that not mean you as a human being does not matter? What we did in life, the people we helped, all that is for nothing. The only thing this "God" cares about is whether we believe & support him! Is that it?
Like a Putin, a Dictator - Dictators naturally only care whether their people support them or not - with enemies around every corner - they need to make sure the people underneath them are loyal to them or not & so we see cads, people who sold their souls and blindly support brutal dictators like Putin, Kim Jong Un being rewarded with the good life and those that did not being hunted down - families have been murdered, even children have not been spared!
And this is God? Heaven & the good life for those who believe & support him and Hell for those who do not!
God is Putin!
God is Kim Jong Un!
.
But amazingly the above makes sense if you look for Rational down-to-earth explanations
Ancient people lived under Kings, Dictators & envisioned an afterworld that was similar to the life they had back then - a King, Dictator like Putin "God" sits on his THRONE, Heaven is his KINGDOM & only those who profess to blindly believe, support, submit, obey and sing his praises are allowed in, the rest kept out to suffer!
Master/Slave religions
Take their Terminology - "Commandments, Submit, beg, obey, judge, wrath, punish, mercy, forgive, Fear" - ALL Slave/Servant words
But that was life back then, and these simple, primitive people discarded older ideas of God(God was Female) and created Gods & Religions that fit their current way of life, but it is shocking and sad to realize that WE, the so-called far more intelligent, educated, armed with far more knowledge, living in free societies, blindly follow their views of God!
.
What is frightening is the willingness of people to spew threats of hell - their victims are people, human beings with families, women, children, even babies! babies! Can they be that cruel to toss a baby into hell? A child? yes they can
Willing NAZIS!
Have you ever heard anyone in an accident scream - "Help, I am dying. Save me, but only if you are a believer!"??
An Atheist could stop by, a Buddhist doctor could help save him and his family, they would need blood and that blood could come from anyone!
A Child is lost in the forest - thousands of people will turn up to look for him - these people come from all walks of life
Today, we live in an interconnected world - what happens in China affects us here in the US
The food we put on our table did not come from God but from our customers, who come from all walks of life
And yet the amazing willingness to preach hate and division - the willingness to be Nazis!
And all it took was a cheap & easy promise of an eternal life of ease & comfort
Hinduism says such people will end up as Ghosts - caught between life & death - they get their eternal "life" - no work, no worries, just float about in the dark for eternity! One day the earth will be destroyed by the sun, then even the sun will blow up & even the Universe will be lights out but these Ghosts will still stick around hanging around where the earth once stood
They will get the "Heaven" for which they sold their souls but at a terrible price
.
And I keep going where are the articles, letters, editorials saying the above?
I found to my horror that the media is basically Christian/Islamic and will not allow such questions & views to be published
I can't get the above published even in Skeptic magazine where the editor Michael Shermer claims to be an Atheist!
If someone knows of any media that welcomes such views please respond
I am very frustrated over the censorship by the media even in the 21st century
Sometimes I think if Darwin were to try to publish his findings today, he might be rejected!
 
Actually, The Atlanta Journal Constitution, aka the AJC once published a letter of mine where I said I was an atheist. I have no idea if I'd get that letter published these days, but I was thrilled to see my letter in print. I have it somewhere as I saved it. Right now I don't recall all of the details. I've almost always been very open about my atheism and I've pushed back whenever a Christian has told me they are worried about me in the afterlife or something like that. My husband has always been quite open about his atheism. In fact, when. he was working in one of his job, he convinced a Christian that atheists are often some of the best people around. By being open, I also found out that one of my nurse coworkers also an atheist and we became friends, until we relocated to another state.

I do have atheist friends that are too frightened to come out of the closet. One finally told a lot of her close friends that she was an atheist and they were shocked. Considering the times we live in, I do sort of understand why so many are afraid to come out.

However, I did put some information in the thread about SCS about the Secular Coalition, a group in Congress made up of a couple of atheists as well as about a dozen liberal believers who are firm supporters of the SCS. We do need to push back as well as find allies among liberal believers like Unitarians and such.
 
I forgot that I actually had two letters published in the AJC about my atheism. I just found them. I had them plastic coated so I could save them, as perhaps my son or grandkids might enjoy reading them one day.

The first one was published on Novemeber 19th, 2005. The paper had asked people to write letters about what they were grateful for during the Thanksgiving season. My letter had been published right next to a fundamentalist Christian's letter, which I thought was very funny.

I am a Humanist, so my Thanksgiving is a secular one, with no references to dieties. I am thankful to be living in a time when women in this country are more independent and can openly speak their minds without fear.

I am thankful that in small ways I've had the opportunity to relieve the suffering of others as a nurse; and for humans who have had the intelligence and courage to develop technologies that have have made our lives safer, longer and healthier; and the ability to be awed and find pleasure in the natural world. I am thankful that I am healthy and physically fit, for friendship and family, for the companionship of tiny pets, and- perhaps most of all-I am thankful for my husband, for his love, devotion and loyalty, while sharing my joyous life for the past 25 years.

Sadly, a lot has changed since 2005, including the rights of women. I might post the other letter later to bore you all. :giggle: I guess I was proud to have two letters published in the South's' major newspaper back when people still read the news. The 2nd one was published in 2006. It's a little bit longer and was published in the "Faith and Values" section, which was discontinued by the AJC many years ago.
 
Back
Top Bottom