• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Why does Iran hate Isreal?

Obvious reasons like religion and the issues of their settlement don't seem to be enough for this much contempt.

Why does Iran have such a vested interest in fighting Israel, http://time.com/2977228/israel-iran-hamas/ ?
Iran doesn't give a shit about the settlements. The religious angle is about right, but mainly, I thinkit's because Iran wants to be a regional power and they get a lot of clout by supporting anyone who is fighting Israel. Also, they are not in good terms with USA so they really have no reason to moderate themselves.
 
Obvious reasons like religion and the issues of their settlement don't seem to be enough for this much contempt.

Why does Iran have such a vested interest in fighting Israel, http://time.com/2977228/israel-iran-hamas/ ?
Iran doesn't give a shit about the settlements. The religious angle is about right, but mainly, I thinkit's because Iran wants to be a regional power and they get a lot of clout by supporting anyone who is fighting Israel. Also, they are not in good terms with USA so they really have no reason to moderate themselves.

Obvious reasons like religion and the issues of their settlement don't seem to be enough for this much contempt.

Why does Iran have such a vested interest in fighting Israel, http://time.com/2977228/israel-iran-hamas/ ?
Hamas gets most of it's funding from Saudi Arabia and Qatar.

Why do they hate Israel?

Actually there are two factors. They're both trying to promote their brand of Islam and they both like having an EastAsia.
 
The hypothesis that Shia Iran is supporting Sunni Hamas because it wants to "promote its brand of Islam" doesn't really hold water.

EDITED TO ADD: Oops, thought Loren was talking about Iran and not Saudi Arabia and Qatar.

Yes, those guys definitely support Hamas for religious reasons.
 
Last edited:
The hypothesis that Shia Iran is supporting Sunni Hamas because it wants to "promote its brand of Islam" doesn't really hold water.
And the idea that either supports Hamas for economic reasons is equally absurd.
 
Hamas gets most of it's funding from Saudi Arabia and Qatar.

I thought it was mainly Iran. Do you have any links that supports this?
Here's a couple articles about Qatar. They also talk about the support of Hamas from Turkey.

http://www.jns.org/latest-articles/2014/7/25/gaza-conflict-spotlights-role-of-qatar-the-hamas-funding-us-ally#.U91sLWNiJj0=

http://www.timesofisrael.com/as-it-battles-hamas-israel-singles-out-its-sponsor-qatar/

The Wikipedia article about Hamas mentions the funding from Saudi Arabia that actually is declining but at one time was substantial.

Iran is a minor supporter of Hamas, and there are deep divisions between the two over Syria.
 
Iran may be a minor supporter in monetary terms, but they're the ones giving rocket parts and (presumably) training.
 
I do not know if it is hate.

I think Iran giving arms and aid to Hamas is a political strategy.

It gives Iran street creds at the regional street level. The goal of the Iranian clerics is to topple the Arab monarchies and establish a regional theistic hegemony with Iran at the top.

Israel is to a degree pawn in the greater regional dynamics.

Hamas has been pin pricking and goading Israel for a long time. Israel finally took the bait.

In living live video we see West Bank unarmed protestors shot and killed by Israeli soldiers. We see an American kid being kicked senseless by Israeli police while hog tied and face down on the ground.

Wed see the massive destruction and bloodshed in Gaza as it happens.

Ir is being said the Arab leadership is looking the other way because they fear Hamas. But the Israeli response fuels the Arab hatred. Iran wins a major propaganda battle.

Israel is a pawn in the centuries old sectarian blood feud between Persians and Arabs.
 
Hamas has been pin pricking and goading Israel for a long time. Israel finally took the bait.
Hamas won a legitimate election and Israel simply nullified the vote.

A blockade is an act of aggression.

The truth is, Israel was very upset when Hamas tried to establish a unity government in Gaza. That is what this is all about. Every movement towards peace by the Palestinians is always met with violence from Israel. The thing it fears most is having to make peace with the Palestinians and end it's dreams of taking the entire West Bank.
 
Iran may be a minor supporter in monetary terms, but they're the ones giving rocket parts and (presumably) training.
What exactly are the total Israeli casualties from these rockets?
In this conflict, I think just one. But these are the only rockets that can reach Tel Aviv or any other part of Israel besides the villages just next to Gaza, and it's not like Hamas can just buy them from Home Depot.
 
What exactly are the total Israeli casualties from these rockets?
In this conflict, I think just one. But these are the only rockets that can reach Tel Aviv or any other part of Israel besides the villages just next to Gaza, and it's not like Hamas can just buy them from Home Depot.
So all this talk about rockets is the concern over one dead Israeli?

That's why there are hundreds of dead Palestinian children?
 
What exactly are the total Israeli casualties from these rockets?
In this conflict, I think just one. But these are the only rockets that can reach Tel Aviv or any other part of Israel besides the villages just next to Gaza, and it's not like Hamas can just buy them from Home Depot.
They've spent almost ten years designing, building, testing and refining the designs of those things. They've had old Russian and Iranian rockets to examine and use, they've had their own designs to play with. They've had every opportunity to learn how to make these rockets ON THEIR OWN and every reason to continue to do so. I don't think they're "buying" them from anyone, I think they make those rockets entirely on their own.

Given the amount of time they've had to develop that capability, it's not really that far fetched. If anything, it's surprising after all this time that their rockets are as unsophisticated as they are.

In this conflict, I think just one. But these are the only rockets that can reach Tel Aviv or any other part of Israel besides the villages just next to Gaza, and it's not like Hamas can just buy them from Home Depot.
So all this talk about rockets is the concern over one dead Israeli?

That's why there are hundreds of dead Palestinian children?

No, it's about Hamas officially joining the Palestinian government and agreeing -- for once in its retched existence -- to behave like a responsible government instead of a revolutionary gang. The Israelis saw that they were actually SERIOUS about this and realized it was only a matter of time before Hamas began to be perceived as an almost-rational political party capable of being reasoned with on logical terms.

So they launched a campaign of terror and harassment designed to provoke them into an otherwise ineffectual counter-attack, which they then used to justify bombing the living shit out of them.


It's sort of like a guy seeing that his wife has gotten herself some new bipolar meds and isn't going to make an ass of herself in divorce court, so a day before the trial he breaks into her house and ransacks all the furniture, hoping she'll get pissed off and take a swing at him; then, when she inevitably DOES, proceeds to curb-stomp her in front of the entire neighborhood while shouting "See? She's crazy! I just want a little peace and quiet, GAWD!"
 
In this conflict, I think just one. But these are the only rockets that can reach Tel Aviv or any other part of Israel besides the villages just next to Gaza, and it's not like Hamas can just buy them from Home Depot.
So all this talk about rockets is the concern over one dead Israeli?

That's why there are hundreds of dead Palestinian children?
The context here is support given to Hamas. Iran may be a "minor supporter", but the support it gives is something that can't be bought with money.

But if you insist, there are hundreds of dead Palestinian children because Hamas are bunch of fuckers who know nothing but violence. Instead of rocket parts, they could have smuggled in food, medicine, tools, machine parts, and so on. Instead of building bunkers and tunnels they could have been building houses and factories, farms.
 
But if you insist, there are hundreds of dead Palestinian children because Hamas are bunch of fuckers who know nothing but violence. Instead of rocket parts, they could have smuggled in food, medicine, tools, machine parts, and so on.
They DID. That's what the majority of the smuggling was actually FOR.

Instead of building bunkers and tunnels they could have been building houses and factories, farms.

They DID. That, also, is what the lion's share of the smuggling was meant to support.
 
Back
Top Bottom