-
-
The AntiChris reacted to pood's post in the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist with
Smile.
Yes, I basically agree, except that I am arguing that we WOULDN’T act differently under the same circumstances, not that we COULDN’T... -
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.I don't think this is right. You're assuming that incomptatibilism necessarily entails a belief in pre-determinism. Whilst there will...
-
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.Sure, all incompatibilists insist that freedom is not possible within determinism. I can't tell if you're agreeing or disagreeing...
-
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.Yes but the disagreement is about the nature of free will, not about determinism. If the compatibilist and the incompatibilist cannot...
-
The AntiChris reacted to bilby's post in the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist with I Agree.
What kind of free will involves randomness? As far as I can see, everyone in this thread agrees that a brain making random decisions...
-
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.I disagree. As I understand it, soft determinism (compatibilism) and hard determinism (incompatibilism) are beliefs about the nature of...
-
The AntiChris reacted to pood's post in the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist with Smile.
I agree, they are not. I mention it simply to rebut his claim that determinism “permits no alternatives.” That is wrong. It’s wrong not...
-
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.I'm not sure why you mention this. Neither "variables you cannot control for" nor "random quantum fluctuations" are required for...
-
The AntiChris reacted to DBT's post in the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist with
Bang Head.
Determined actions progress without impediment, as they must. In that sense, we are able to act freely (relatively) without being... -
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.Unfortunately, given your interpretation of the Definition of freedom you provide on this thread (post #1,620), it follows that...
-
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.It may well be an element of your particular take on free will but as you must have noticed, there's more than one notion of free will...
-
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist."Basic-desert responsibility" is not a core element of compatibilism. Some compatibilists may subscribe to 'basic-desert' but many...
-
The AntiChris reacted to bilby's post in the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist with Like.
As long as will is generated by a brain, it is the will of the individual whose brain generates it. It is not the will of the starting...
-
The AntiChris reacted to DBT's post in the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist with
Roll Eyes.
As the subject matter is free will, with some arguing for compatibilism, where the subject happens to be incredibly repetitive, my... -
The AntiChris replied to the thread According to Robert Sapolsky, human free will does not exist.Oh, I see. It was just another of your standard responses.
-
-
Loading…
-
Loading…