• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

Disaster for Ukraine. Rebels route Ukrainian forces at Donetsk

boneyard bill

Veteran Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2001
Messages
1,065
Location
Florida
Basic Beliefs
Idealist
There is panic in Kiev these days as the Ukrainian forces have been routed in East Ukraine. Separatist forces have encircled 5,000 Ukrainian troops near Donetsk and another 2,000 further south. Ukraine has no forces available to rescue them. Although Kiev has ordered their troops to fight to the death, and the command has not surrendered, there are reports of large scale defections of Ukrainian troops. By now they have probably been mopped up since the separatists are now organizing an offensive against the seaport of Mariupol. If they take Mariupol, they will open up a land corridor to Crimea.

The US is now accusing Russia of "invading" Ukraine. This is not the first time that accusation has been made. But there is no evidence for this so far. While it has long been admitted that there are anywhere from 1,000 to 3,000 Russian volunteers fighting on the separatist side, the descriptions of the battle do not reference and forces fighting under Russian command, and the separatists are depicted as being out-numbered.

Here is the link to the description of the battle.

http://www.globalresearch.ca/ukraine-troops-suffer-catastrophic-defeat-in-novorossiya/5398546

Ukrainian troops approached Donetsk intending to capture it, but they were prevented by a small detachment of defenders who held out tenaciously until reinforcements could arrive. But reinforcements didn't simply supplement the defenders. They surrounded the entire Ukrainian army. The battle is compared to Stalingrad where Hitler's troops, upon finally taking the city found themselves trapped inside it. A similar maneuver occurred near Novoazorsk on the Sea of Azov where rebels surrounded 2,000 Ukrainian troops making them unavailable to relieve the siege at Donetsk.

Meanwhile, Ukrainian troops are very angry with the Kiev government which they claim let them down by not providing the proper equipment, fuel, ammunition, food, and even water to enable them to do their jobs. There are even rumors that the troops may march on Kiev.

For his part Poroshenko has called for more conscriptions including men up to 50. If this sounds desperate, it probably is.

Of course, Ukraine and the US are claiming Russian troops intervened. This is obviously an attempt to avoid blame for debacle at Donetsk. But without offering any serious evidence, it hard to take the claim seriously. Every encounter I have read about in Ukraine, where the Ukrainian army wasn't massacring unarmed civilians, they were defecting to the enemy or running away and leaving the weaponry behind. The separatists have captured roughly 100 Ukrainian tanks, and those are the figures from the Ukrainian side.

What happens next is anybody's guess. I get the impression that the Kiev regime is scraping and clawing just to come up with the troops and equipment for a proper defense of Mariupol, and Putin has once again called for negotiations and Ukraine has once again refused. Meanwhile NATO is preparing to deploy a rapid deployment force in Eastern Europe.

My position on this issue remains the same. The US strategy all along has been to provoke Russia into intervening in East Ukraine and use that as an excuse for NATO to deploy troops in Kiev. But for that to happen, Putin's involvement in the war would have to be much more open than it is or the West would have to put up a good deal more evidence of Russian involvement than they have so far.

The mainstream media propaganda that Putin is somehow involved in an "imperialistic" campaign to restore the USSR is too ridiculous a view even to be considered.
 
There is panic in Kiev these days as the Ukrainian forces have been routed in East Ukraine. Separatist forces have encircled 5,000 Ukrainian troops near Donetsk and another 2,000 further south. .
The Nazi's from Ukraine are getting routed.
What the fuck were the Nazi's from Kiev doing attacking the East anyway.

There is panic in Kiev because it has been another disaster orchestrated by the fuckwits from Washington. Have you noticed there is also panic in Iraq?
The USA creates it while Americans sleep and watch the Kardashians.
For his part Poroshenko has called for more conscriptions including men up to 50.
European leaders asked him or a ceasefire..but that billionaire fuckwit decided to continue the bloodshed. Hopefully he will be made to pay for his crimes.
What happens next is anybody's guess.
What happens next is that the west via the IMF loots the Ukraine, all the while demonising Putin.
Keep sleeping, idiots in the west.
 
Ukraine is the underdog here. It is being propagandized as "Nazis" by Russian state media, and apparently more than a few folks in the west have been suckered into believing it as well.

Fact is that Russia has invaded another sovereign nation. Just because it was a bit of a dysfunctional state to begin with doesn't justify Russia exploiting its weakness and trying to annex parts of it.
 
Poroshenko fancies himself as a puppet master, but the NATO response following the meeting in Wales so far has been lukewarm at best.

I predict Ukraine will have their panties in a bunch, but will have to agree to cede some Crimean land to Russia.
 
It is being propagandized as "Nazis" by Russian state media, and apparently more than a few folks in the west have been suckered into believing it as well.
It's a fact Svoboda is neo-facist and only people suckered are the those unaware of the nazis in Ukraine.
 
It is being propagandized as "Nazis" by Russian state media, and apparently more than a few folks in the west have been suckered into believing it as well.
It's a fact Svoboda is neo-facist and only people suckered are the those unaware of the nazis in Ukraine.

What surprises me is actually how quickly this fell into the memory hole. I don't remember this being propaganda back in the 90s.
 
It is being propagandized as "Nazis" by Russian state media, and apparently more than a few folks in the west have been suckered into believing it as well.
It's a fact Svoboda is neo-facist and only people suckered are the those unaware of the nazis in Ukraine.

Yep, the Ukies are putting up statues to Bandera all over the place. Most people in the West "never heard of him", then, when told who he was, think he's a good guy because "he fought the Commies". They seem to forget that Hitler and Co also "fought the Commies", does that make them good guys too?
At least the Jews in the USA should know who Bandera and his gang were but we do not see any comment along those lines on this forum.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepan_Bandera

Assessments of his work have ranged from totally apologetic to sharply negative.[3] On 22 January 2010, the outgoing President of Ukraine Viktor Yushchenko awarded Bandera the posthumous title of Hero of Ukraine.[4] The award was condemned by European Parliament, Russian, Polish and Jewish organizations[5][6][7][8] and was declared illegal by the following Ukrainian government and a court decision in April 2010. In January 2011, the award was officially annulled.[9]

Monuments
This section needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (February 2014)
Monument to Stepan Bandera in Lviv.
Monument to Stepan Bandera in Berezhany.

Monument of Stepan Bandera in Staryi Uhryniv
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Lviv
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Ternopil
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Ivano-Frankivsk
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Kolomyia
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Kozivka
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Drohobych
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Dubliany
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Terebovlya
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Berezhany
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Boryslav
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Buchach
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Mykytyntsi
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Mostyska
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Sambir
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Staryi Sambir
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Stryi
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Truskavets
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Zalishchyky
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Chervonohrad
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Verbiv
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Horodenka
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Hrabivka
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Seredniy Bereziv
Monument of Stepan Bandera in Strusiv
 
The Nazi's from Ukraine are getting routed.
What the fuck were the Nazi's from Kiev doing attacking the East anyway.

There is panic in Kiev because it has been another disaster orchestrated by the fuckwits from Washington. Have you noticed there is also panic in Iraq?
The USA creates it while Americans sleep and watch the Kardashians.
For his part Poroshenko has called for more conscriptions including men up to 50.
European leaders asked him or a ceasefire..but that billionaire fuckwit decided to continue the bloodshed. Hopefully he will be made to pay for his crimes.
What happens next is anybody's guess.
What happens next is that the west via the IMF loots the Ukraine, all the while demonising Putin.
Keep sleeping, idiots in the west.

Last I heard, Poroschenko has agreed to a cease-fire and negotiations. That alone is a victory for Putin and an act of desperation by Ukraine. Separatist troops are now close to Mariupol, and if negotiations fail, that city will probably fall to the separatists as well.
 
Ukraine is the underdog here. It is being propagandized as "Nazis" by Russian state media, and apparently more than a few folks in the west have been suckered into believing it as well.

Fact is that Russia has invaded another sovereign nation. Just because it was a bit of a dysfunctional state to begin with doesn't justify Russia exploiting its weakness and trying to annex parts of it.

The "Nazi" claim is far from propaganda. The Svoboda Party (formerly the Social Nationalists) are avowed pro-Nazis and they have four ministries in the government including the Ministries of Internal Affairs and the Ministry of Defense.

There was no Russian invasion. The US made the claim but provided only a few very fuzzy photographs of military vehicles which could not be identified and with way to determine their actual location. Nothing else has been forthcoming, but OSCE, which has observers on the ground, claims that there was no Russian invasion.

Observers from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) “have registered no troops, ammunition or weapons crossing the Russian-Ukrainian border over the past two weeks” (Itar-Tass)



“Throughout the week, the Observer Teams noticed a net increase of young people (both men and women) wearing military-style dress crossing the border in both directions but did not observe any weapons among these groups,” the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission’s report covering a period from August 20 to September 3 said.

The observers said they had regular interactions with supporters of the self-proclaimed republics. “Some discussed openly with the OSCE while others expressed their total mistrust toward the OSCE. At both Border Crossing Points, some supporters of the self-proclaimed republics explained that they are not allowed to cross the border with weapons,” the report said.

The observers registered a decrease in helicopter sightings compared to last week but they were still observed at border crossing points flying at low altitude along the border.

http://www.globalresearch.ca/obama-...ave-crossed-the-russia-ukraine-border/5399457

So the US claimed that Russia has invaded Ukraine which has been disproved. The US claimed that Ukrainian separatists shot the MH17 which has also been disproven. The US claimed that Russia invaded Crimea, also untrue. And the US claimed that armed neo-Nazi thugs in the Maidan were "democracy fighters" even though they overthrew a democratically elected government that had already agreed to submit to new, early elections.

Is there ONE THING the US government has said about the Ukraine situation that has been the truth?
 
Poroshenko fancies himself as a puppet master, but the NATO response following the meeting in Wales so far has been lukewarm at best.

I predict Ukraine will have their panties in a bunch, but will have to agree to cede some Crimean land to Russia.

Crimea will remain a part of Russia. Ukraine will not cede any other lands, however, they will probably have to agree to autonomy for the Eastern provinces and probably to all provinces. In other words, the separatists will get part of what they want but not all of it. Kiev will make huge concessions, and Putin will get everything he has been asking for from the beginning. A unified federated Ukraine that is, and must remain, outside of NATO.

But that assumes that real negotiations actually take place and this cease fire isn't merely a ruse by Poroshenko to buy time some other desperate measures.
 
The "Nazi" claim is far from propaganda. The Svoboda Party (formerly the Social Nationalists) are avowed pro-Nazis and they have four ministries in the government including the Ministries of Internal Affairs and the Ministry of Defense.

There was no Russian invasion. The US made the claim but provided only a few very fuzzy photographs of military vehicles which could not be identified and with way to determine their actual location. Nothing else has been forthcoming, but OSCE, which has observers on the ground, claims that there was no Russian invasion.
Rebels leaders themselves have said there are thousands of Russian troops in Ukraine. Only difference is that they say they are merely volunteers and friends who are "vacationing", and somehow got to take their weapons, tanks, and anti+aircraft missile systems with them on their vacation. That sounds plausible! :rolleyes:

Observers from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) “have registered no troops, ammunition or weapons crossing the Russian-Ukrainian border over the past two weeks” (Itar-Tass)
Is Russian military equipment incapable of crossing the border except at designated border crossing points? Please.

http://www.globalresearch.ca/obama-...ave-crossed-the-russia-ukraine-border/5399457

So the US claimed that Russia has invaded Ukraine which has been disproved.
If you believe everything you read on crank conspiracy theorist sites like Globar Research, then I suppose 9/11 was a false flag operation committed by CIA and Mossad as well.

The US claimed that Ukrainian separatists shot the MH17 which has also been disproven.
No it hasn't, on the contrary despite Russian propagandist attempts to disprove it, it has been shown without shadow of a doutb that there was a BUK in rebel held territory at exactly the same time and place where the plane was shot down. Of course there is some uncertainty whether it was the separatists or straight up Russian military, but they are part of the same command structure anyway.

The US claimed that Russia invaded Crimea, also untrue.
Only because Russia had military bases already in Crimea, so they did not have to "invade" anything. But even Putin admitted that the unmarked troops that precipitated Crimea's cesession were Russian. Exactly the same ploy was used in Eastern Ukraine.
 
There is a rather odd and sometimes eclectic group of adoring Russophiles that have arisen since the end of the the first cold war. Otherwise intelligent and insightful folk, too often from the Paleo-Conservative wing of neo-isolationists, have totally forgotten their prior anti Russian-Soviet imperialism stances and now have an affection for a Russian oligarch of the super-rich (ex-Communist party) functionaries, attracted I suppose to his proto fascism.

If this were a choice between Russian fascism and Ukrainian fascism Bonehead might have a point - but that is not the choice. The choice is between a country trying to become more European in culture and economic systems vs. a country sinking deeper into a dictatorship that is fanning Russian nationalism into hysteria - not unlike Uncle Adolph.

Bonehead, this is not difficult.

First, Yanukovych, in the face of a popular Euromaidan uprising fled the country, and was impeached by his own Parliament. Done deal. Were he to return, if he were not arrested, he'd have no basis of support left (starting with the Crimea which was taken by Russia).

Second, Poroshenko, an independent, beat Rada in the May Presidential Election. The only folks who couldn't vote were the Crimeans, annexed by Russia, and the Donbass region where the Russian insurgents did not permit a vote. (A case of be careful what you wish for, you might get it).

Third, The Parliament under also freely elected a PM. Six of the seven parties (of which Svoboda is a minor member) voted to install Yatsenyuk of the Batkivshchyna Party as PM. Only the tiny communist party refused to vote for him.

Fourth, the PM is not from Svoboda, but Batkivshchyna. In fact 6 cabinet posts are held by Bat. and 3 posts held by Svoboda and 17 posts held by independents.

Finally, Svoboda only holds 36 of 450 seats in Parliament. Going apeshit over this party, regardless of what folks think of it, is a red herring. It's an excuse for Russian imperialism.

Anyone under the age of 50 in the Ukraine sees a future with the west and western economic systems. Get with it Bonehead.
 
Anyone under the age of 50 in the Ukraine sees a future with the west and western economic systems. Get with it Bonehead.
What will happen is the west will loot the Ukriane. Already money has been loaned to the Ukraine which has likely gone to the Oligarchs (fact is we don't know where it has gone).
Ukrainian assets will be sold or seized. Ukrainians will end off worse than before.

- - - Updated - - -

But even Putin admitted that the unmarked troops that precipitated Crimea's cesession were Russian. .
Where did he say that?
 
There is panic in Kiev these days as the Ukrainian forces have been routed in East Ukraine. Separatist forces have encircled 5,000 Ukrainian troops near Donetsk and another 2,000 further south. Ukraine has no forces available to rescue them. Although Kiev has ordered their troops to fight to the death, and the command has not surrendered, there are reports of large scale defections of Ukrainian troops. .
Many have been captured in recent times, but the Eastern Ukrainians, let them go back to their wives and children. Even though the forces from the west have been killing civilians.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=us9lPiQ9btA&list=UUdnB82ob_V7EXwwcCtB1vUg
 
Rebels leaders themselves have said there are thousands of Russian troops in Ukraine.
Bullshit. Where did they say that?

What motivates you to be transmission belt of Russian propoganda? Think about it, why yell bullshit at news that everyone else is aware of? How is it you have become so emotionally attached to Russia and Putin the ex-KGB Colonel? Are you Russian? A paleo-Conservative? A listener of Micheal Savage? An ex John Bircher or Tri-lateral commission conspiracy loon? Maybe it is the Illuminati vexes you? Do you lose sleep over the black helicopters?

One of the top rebel leaders in eastern Ukraine claims that his forces have recently received 1,200 fighters who had undergone training in Russia. The claim came during a speech to leading rebels, apparently recorded on Friday and posted to YouTube by a pro-separatist media outlet. His language suggested the men had already crossed the border.

Alexander Zakharchenko, prime minister of the self-declared Donetsk People's Republic, also spoke about 150 armoured vehicles, of which 30 are tanks and the rest wheeled or tracked armoured personnel carriers. He said the men and equipment had gathered in an area near a "corridor" to the Russian border...

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/16/ukraine-fighters-russia-top-rebel-leader

Given you are a 'true believer' of some sort I am sure you will rationalize it. But "bullshit" is a false charge and you ought to acknowledge your error to Jayjay.
 
What will happen is the west will loot the Ukriane. Already money has been loaned to the Ukraine which has likely gone to the Oligarchs (fact is we don't know where it has gone).
Ukrainian assets will be sold or seized. Ukrainians will end off worse than before.

Well yes, it has been widely accepted that the impeached puppet of Putin's, Yanukovych, was very corrupt. But the bottom line is that it is not up to the Russian imperialists and empire dreamers to decide which economic system or trade links the Ukraine wishes to establish. If they end up worse than before, then that is their problem - not yours or Russia's.

In short...Leave them the f$#@ alone! Can Russians manage to do that? Nope...
 
The US claimed that Ukrainian separatists shot the MH17 which has also been disproven.
No it hasn't, on the contrary despite Russian propagandist attempts to disprove it, it has been shown without shadow of a doutb that there was a BUK in rebel held territory at exactly the same time and place where the plane was shot down. Of course there is some uncertainty whether it was the separatists or straight up Russian military, but they are part of the same command structure anyway.
If it was the rebels or the Russians then America would release its satellite images. If it was the western Ukrainian forces then America would probably not release the images.
America has not released the images which suggests it was neither the Russians or the rebels, but some Ukrainians.

- - - Updated - - -

What will happen is the west will loot the Ukriane. Already money has been loaned to the Ukraine which has likely gone to the Oligarchs (fact is we don't know where it has gone).
Ukrainian assets will be sold or seized. Ukrainians will end off worse than before.

Well yes, it has been widely accepted that the impeached puppet of Putin's, Yanukovych, was very corrupt. But the bottom line is that it is not up to the Russian imperialists and empire dreamers to decide which economic system or trade links the Ukraine wishes to establish. If they end up worse than before, then that is their problem - not yours or Russia's.
In short...Leave them the f$#@ alone! Can Russians manage to do that? Nope...
The Russians have left them alone unless you have some evidence they have not.
The Americans on the other hand have not
 
Given you are a 'true believer' of some sort I am sure you will rationalize it. But "bullshit" is a false charge and you ought to acknowledge your error to Jayjay.
Your article says it is unverified, and doesn't even link to the source. Which it could easily do. I wonder why?
I also consider Shaun Walker as suspect.

But as the Kiev forces have been killing civilians, I would support the Russians doing something to defend the innocent civilians in East Ukraine.
 
Back
Top Bottom