• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Hand Cannot Erase

Jimmy Higgins

Contributor
Joined
Jan 31, 2001
Messages
50,503
Basic Beliefs
Calvinistic Atheist
Steven Wilson has released his latest album with his jazz buds. The effort is called Hand Cannot Erase.

The premise of the album is the story of an elderly woman that died in an apartment but wasn't noticed for three years. The tale notes that while she died alone, she was a child, she was a mother, an aunt, she had a life. She wasn't always this old woman that became forgotten.

Steven Wilson has made a career with sad depressing lyrics. Sometimes he outdoes himself. The last album had The Raven That Refused to Sing, an old man who is near death, desperate to hear the singing voice of his long lost sister of whom he lost when they were still kids. This album gives us Happy Returns, which, while seemingly full of hyperbole, is more depressing than Stop Swimming, Octane Twisted, and the Raven That Refused to Sing combined. It is that powerful.

Often, Wilson creates stories with his songs, but Hand Cannot Erase goes beyond a story. It is a reality that has occurred for some, a reality that may occur to you (the listener). I have always enjoyed his music, but this is his first album that makes you think about your own life. The steps within it, the steps to come. The steps of other lives. Where we put the value. I've always pondered the day in - day out routine of life, about how much of life is wasted waiting for later.

And this is all before we talk about the actual music, which is finely crafted, played by grossly awesome musicians. The lyrics themselves are haunting, story telling, entrapping. The vocal harmonies are nothing less than what one comes to expect in a Steven Wilson album. Wilson engineered the album, so it sounds as perfect as it possibly can.

This album will be the best album in 2015 not to make it above the radar, being pushed aside by shallow music critics that put forth less thought worthy material as the prized material.
 
If it's more depressing than The Raven That Refused to Sing (And Other Stories), I might as well just go ahead and slit my wrists now.

But seriously, I am a fan of Wilson's music, and I particularly like the progressive work he has done with his band Porcupine Tree. Fear of a Blank Planet is still on heavy rotation for me almost a decade later. I guess I will have to go looking for this one on CD, just like most of his output (other than some of the Porcupine Tree albums) I doubt I am going to find it on any of the streaming services.
 
I'd recommend the Blu-Ray. It comes with a download code for MP3s, if you can't rip a blu-ray yourself. The blu-ray offers a screen show during the playback of the album that I think enhances the story greatly. Also comes with instrumental versions of the songs, and a doc on the making of the album.
 
Should note, I was mistaken about elderly woman. I think elderly is from the original news clip that inspired the story, but the woman in the album is relatively young, just been through some pretty serious stuff that leads her to become detached.

The old prog elements in the album are many. Genesis, Yes, Rick Wakeman, King Crimson, David Gilmour, Pink Floyd, etc... etc... while still having its own sound. I really love the beginning of the album where the piano keys are played and are arranged to sound like an old video reel audio that has become distorted. Only 5 listens into the album and it is just captivating. The whole thing. It reminds me of Signify where the whole outweighs the individual parts, but the individual parts hold much better on this album, not quite Fear of a Blank Planet, but close.
 
The more I listen, while Happy Returns is terribly sad, I ponder if Routine is the most depressing. A woman going through the steps of raising children who are no longer there due to a tragedy. The lyrics at the end, Try to let go, Don't ever let go is quite possibly one of the sharpest philosophical statements one can make in a song about such a loss.
 
Finally got a copy through Amazon, and I am listening to it now. It is a fantastic album so far. At least the first few songs seem pretty upbeat, and I am on the 8th track "Ancestral", but I am working so I have not really been able to concentrate on the lyrics. I still like Fear of a Blank Planet better, it is just a bit more in tune to my musical tastes, but I think this beats out all of Wilson's other solo work.
 
I love Fear of a Blank Planet as well, however, give it a little more time. This quickly became my favorite album after a couple listens. The songs all feed off of each other and there are so many great musical/lyrical moments on the album. It is a whole album feel, like Signify, but with the individual track greatness of Fear of a Blank Planet.
 
Back
Top Bottom