Eventually when adding smaller and smaller numbers which all operations of this equation must, the numbers you add become too small to throw it off of convergence.Take the sum of x from 1 to infinity of 1/x^n, can anyone prove that it always converges for all n > 1? It does not for n=1. Obviously it converges for n=2 and greater. By experiment it also converges for n=1.01. But will it converge for some n infinitesimally close to 1? And a proof of such.
View attachment 40116
I'd have to look up how to test a series for convergence. Can't do it off the top of my head.Take the sum of x from 1 to infinity of 1/x^n, can anyone prove that it always converges for all n > 1? It does not for n=1. Obviously it converges for n=2 and greater. By experiment it also converges for n=1.01. But will it converge for some n infinitesimally close to 1? And a proof of such.
View attachment 40116
I'm guessing that you meanIpetrich,
Are you saying 1/(x^1) does not converge?
That’s right. If you integrate 1/x from 1 to infinity You get infinity. If some one said for you to paint the wall of 1/x from 1 to infinity, you might say it can’t be done. But you’d be wrong. What is the volume of the bounded trumpet formed by rotating 1/x around the x axis? The answer is pi! Try it. It’s a simple integration. So all you have to do is create a circular barrier around the function and fill it with pi units of paint and voila, you’ve painted an infinite area wall!I guess I did not fully comprehend the meaning of convergence and divergence.
I took convergence to mean asymptotically approaching a value as the series goes to infinity. I may be confusing limits with convergence and divergence.
From this link 1/x flattens out, but the area goes to infinity, diverges.
Learn something new every day....
That’s right. If you integrate 1/x from 1 to infinity You get infinity. If some one said for you to paint the wall of 1/x from 1 to infinity, you might say it can’t be done. But you’d be wrong. What is the volume of the bounded trumpet formed by rotating 1/x around the x axis? The answer is pi! Try it. It’s a simple integration. So all you have to do is create a circular barrier around the function and fill it with pi units of paint and voila,I guess I did not fully comprehend the meaning of convergence and divergence.
I took convergence to mean asymptotically approaching a value as the series goes to infinity. I may be confusing limits with convergence and divergence.
From this link 1/x flattens out, but the area goes to infinity, diverges.
Learn something new every day....
Well it seemed intuitively obvious, but I didn’t know what the proof was. Just experimentally it seems to approach infinity as n goes to 1. I knew 1 didn’t converge. The series gets infinitesimally closer to 1 the higher the number. But all even n take the from of pi^n/(natural number).That’s right. If you integrate 1/x from 1 to infinity You get infinity. If some one said for you to paint the wall of 1/x from 1 to infinity, you might say it can’t be done. But you’d be wrong. What is the volume of the bounded trumpet formed by rotating 1/x around the x axis? The answer is pi! Try it. It’s a simple integration. So all you have to do is create a circular barrier around the function and fill it with pi units of paint and voila,I guess I did not fully comprehend the meaning of convergence and divergence.
I took convergence to mean asymptotically approaching a value as the series goes to infinity. I may be confusing limits with convergence and divergence.
From this link 1/x flattens out, but the area goes to infinity, diverges.
Learn something new every day....
I think I get it now
Sonids le you knew the answer before you asked the question.
Mathematically yes, but the engineering side in me is screaming "Gabriel's horn becomes narrower than a paint molecule's maximum dimension so you cannot fill it with paint."That’s right. If you integrate 1/x from 1 to infinity You get infinity. If some one said for you to paint the wall of 1/x from 1 to infinity, you might say it can’t be done. But you’d be wrong. What is the volume of the bounded trumpet formed by rotating 1/x around the x axis? The answer is pi! Try it. It’s a simple integration. So all you have to do is create a circular barrier around the function and fill it with pi units of paint and voila, you’ve painted an infinite area wall!
Maybe that's why it rings so loudly, on account of the molecule being compressed infinitely.Mathematically yes, but the engineering side in me is screaming "Gabriel's horn becomes narrower than a paint molecule's maximum dimension so you cannot fill it with paint."That’s right. If you integrate 1/x from 1 to infinity You get infinity. If some one said for you to paint the wall of 1/x from 1 to infinity, you might say it can’t be done. But you’d be wrong. What is the volume of the bounded trumpet formed by rotating 1/x around the x axis? The answer is pi! Try it. It’s a simple integration. So all you have to do is create a circular barrier around the function and fill it with pi units of paint and voila, you’ve painted an infinite area wall!
F$&#$king engineers. You have ruined mathematics!Mathematically yes, but the engineering side in me is screaming "Gabriel's horn becomes narrower than a paint molecule's maximum dimension so you cannot fill it with paint."That’s right. If you integrate 1/x from 1 to infinity You get infinity. If some one said for you to paint the wall of 1/x from 1 to infinity, you might say it can’t be done. But you’d be wrong. What is the volume of the bounded trumpet formed by rotating 1/x around the x axis? The answer is pi! Try it. It’s a simple integration. So all you have to do is create a circular barrier around the function and fill it with pi units of paint and voila, you’ve painted an infinite area wall!