• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

King in His Own Words on MLK Day

Changes in the tax structure is not a change in the nature of government intrusion.

What is this intrusion you speak of?

Is this the dance you must go through to convince yourself you're not a statist while continuously advocating state control over more and more things?

The question of health care is who do you want in control?

Profit seeking little dictatorships with very little accountability?

Or a transparent not for profit government agency?

Medicare is far more efficient than any private insurance program.
 
Sounds impressive, but I don't get it.

He is saying that capitalism and communism represent extremes.

Capitalism (as it existed and still exists in the US) in it's extreme denial of society and the collective needs of society and communism (as it existed in the Soviet Union) in it's extreme denial of personal freedoms.

King is saying that a better society would exist without these extremes.

We call this today Social Democracy and it has it's best examples in places like Germany and Finland.

And it is what Bernie Sanders is calling for.

Moderation. Even if some extremists want to portray HIM as the extremist.

I'm mostly confused by what the first two lines are supposed to mean. How does Capitalism fail to realize that life is social? How does Communism fail to realize that life is personal? What are some examples that demonstrate this?
 
Is this the dance you must go through to convince yourself you're not a statist while continuously advocating state control over more and more things?

The question of health care is who do you want in control?

Profit seeking little dictatorships with very little accountability?

Or a transparent not for profit government agency?

Medicare is far more efficient than any private insurance program.

Rather than debate these questions I would just point out that If your answer to these (and many other) questions is "I want the state in control" that makes you a statist. That's what being a statist means.
 
"The revolution of values must go beyond traditional capitalism and communism. We must honestly admit that capitalism has often left a gulf between superflous wealth and abject poverty, has created conditions permitting necessities to be taken from the many to give luxuries to the few, and has encouraged smallhearted men to become cold and conscienceless so that, like Dives before Lazarus, they are unmoved by suffering, poverty-stricken humanity. The profit motive, when it is the sole basis of an economic system, encourages cutthroat competition and selfish ambition that inspire men to be more I-centered than thou-centered. Equally, communism reduces men to a cog in the wheel of the state. The communist may object, saying that in Marxian theory the state is an 'interim reality' that will 'wither away' when the classless society emerges. True--in theory; but it is also true that, while the state lasts, it is an end in itself. Man is a means to that end. He has no inalienable rights. His only rights are derived from, and conferred by, the state. Under such a system the fountain of freedom runs dry. Restricted are man's liberties of press and assembly, his freedom to vote and his freedom to listen and to read.

"Truth is found neither in traditional capitalism nor in classical communism. Each represents a partial truth. Capitalism fails to see the truth in collectivism. Communism fails to see the truth in individualism. Capitalism fails to realize that life is social. Communism fails to realize that life is personal. The good and just society is neither the thesis of capitalism nor the antithesis of communism, but a socially conscious democracy which recognizes the truths of individualism and collectivism."
http://forum.prisonplanet.com/index.php?topic=80926.10;wap2

For the full essay see the Book, Where Do We Go from Here, Chaos or Community, by Martin Luther King, Jr.
 
Back
Top Bottom