1 - the set of Scotsmen (lots of types)
2 - the set of people who are not part of set #1
An atheist is not a "true Christian" for the same reason #1 cannot be a subset of #2
phands doesn't get this basic logic. So he keeps on sticking his head in the sand pretending that filthy scum pedophile atheist masquerading as a pastor is a True Pastor
How do you know that that this Pastor wasn't a Christian? And that he was an atheist? You don't, you are just making up shit. What does the Bible say about making up shit?
You can believe in Bronze Age stories about magical gods and still be a child molester. You can believe in Bronze Age stories about magical gods and still be a habitual shit-maker-upper. I see Christians do things that their Bible forbids all the time. You don't have to be perfect to be a Christian, you just have to accept the zombie god-clone JC as your personal savior. You can do all sorts of bad shit, including molesting little children, and still get into Heaven to suck on aforementioned JC's cock for all eternity if you do that.