Jason Harvestdancer
Contributor
But that is typically committed by the Libertarian, explaining X who did Y couldn't a 'real libertarian'.When someone self-identifies as a libertarian, it is usually a better indicator than someone at TalkFreeThough saying "that person is a libertarian because I say so, why don't you libertarians like him?"
I have seen many examples of the No False Scotsman fallacy here.
You're confusing the No True Scotsman with the No False Scotsman.