iolo Veteran Member Joined Feb 28, 2015 Messages 1,409 Location Rhondda Basic Beliefs Socialist Aug 3, 2016 #101 untermensche said: iolo said: Not at all - I just believe in total determinism. Seems to me obvious. Click to expand... Determined by what? Click to expand... Whatever went before.
untermensche said: iolo said: Not at all - I just believe in total determinism. Seems to me obvious. Click to expand... Determined by what? Click to expand... Whatever went before.
U untermensche Contributor Joined Feb 1, 2006 Messages 24,504 Location Here Basic Beliefs magic mood ring Aug 3, 2016 #102 iolo said: untermensche said: Determined by what? Click to expand... Whatever went before. Click to expand... If true any discourse is meaningless.
iolo said: untermensche said: Determined by what? Click to expand... Whatever went before. Click to expand... If true any discourse is meaningless.
iolo Veteran Member Joined Feb 28, 2015 Messages 1,409 Location Rhondda Basic Beliefs Socialist Aug 4, 2016 #103 untermensche said: iolo said: Whatever went before. Click to expand... If true any discourse is meaningless. Click to expand... No determined, like everything else.
untermensche said: iolo said: Whatever went before. Click to expand... If true any discourse is meaningless. Click to expand... No determined, like everything else.
U untermensche Contributor Joined Feb 1, 2006 Messages 24,504 Location Here Basic Beliefs magic mood ring Aug 5, 2016 #104 iolo said: untermensche said: If true any discourse is meaningless. Click to expand... No determined, like everything else. Click to expand... Determined IS meaningless. There is no meaning in a rock falling. Only with a mind that makes decisions based on conceptions of the world, not because of determined brain activity, is there any meaning. And of course that is what we experience.
iolo said: untermensche said: If true any discourse is meaningless. Click to expand... No determined, like everything else. Click to expand... Determined IS meaningless. There is no meaning in a rock falling. Only with a mind that makes decisions based on conceptions of the world, not because of determined brain activity, is there any meaning. And of course that is what we experience.