Angra Mainyu
Veteran Member
The following is an argument meant to prove that the square root of two is not a rational number - in other words, it is not a quotient of integers.
Suppose there are integers m, n (both different from zero, obviously) such that
\( \begin{equation} \sqrt{2}=\frac{n}{m}. \end{equation} \)
If n and m are both even numbers, then we simplify them, obtaining n1, m1 such that
\( \begin{equation} \sqrt{2}=\frac{n_1}{m_1}, \end{equation} \)
and at least one of the numbers n1 or m1 or is odd (note that if either n is odd or m is odd, we can just let n1 :=n and m1 or:=m. Hence, in any case, we get that the equation above holds with either n1 or odd, or m1 or odd).
It follows from the previous equation that
\( \begin{equation} 2m_1^2=n_1^2. \end{equation} \)
This implies that n12 is even. Hence, n1 is even. Therefore, there is an integer n2 such that
\( \begin{equation} n_1=2n_2. \end{equation} \)
It follows from the previous equations that
\( \begin{equation} 2m_1^2=(2n_2)^2=2^2n_2^2, \end{equation} \)
which entails that
\( \begin{equation} m_1^2=2n_2^2. \end{equation} \)
Therefore, m12 is even, and so m1 is even. Now we have obtained that both n1 and m1 are even, which is a contradiction because we had simplified above so that at least one of the two is odd.
In short, our argument was as follows: First, we assumed there were integers m, n such that
\( \begin{equation} \sqrt{2}=\frac{n}{m}. \end{equation} \)
From that assumption and known facts about numbers, we derived a contradiction. We conclude that there are no integers n, m for which that equation holds (in other words, the square root of two is not a rational number).
In the proof above, we made a deduction with an inconsistent set of premises, namely the premise that the square root of two is a quotient of integers, and known facts about numbers. From that, we derived a contradiction. Is that deduction valid?
Suppose there are integers m, n (both different from zero, obviously) such that
\( \begin{equation} \sqrt{2}=\frac{n}{m}. \end{equation} \)
If n and m are both even numbers, then we simplify them, obtaining n1, m1 such that
\( \begin{equation} \sqrt{2}=\frac{n_1}{m_1}, \end{equation} \)
and at least one of the numbers n1 or m1 or is odd (note that if either n is odd or m is odd, we can just let n1 :=n and m1 or:=m. Hence, in any case, we get that the equation above holds with either n1 or odd, or m1 or odd).
It follows from the previous equation that
\( \begin{equation} 2m_1^2=n_1^2. \end{equation} \)
This implies that n12 is even. Hence, n1 is even. Therefore, there is an integer n2 such that
\( \begin{equation} n_1=2n_2. \end{equation} \)
It follows from the previous equations that
\( \begin{equation} 2m_1^2=(2n_2)^2=2^2n_2^2, \end{equation} \)
which entails that
\( \begin{equation} m_1^2=2n_2^2. \end{equation} \)
Therefore, m12 is even, and so m1 is even. Now we have obtained that both n1 and m1 are even, which is a contradiction because we had simplified above so that at least one of the two is odd.
In short, our argument was as follows: First, we assumed there were integers m, n such that
\( \begin{equation} \sqrt{2}=\frac{n}{m}. \end{equation} \)
From that assumption and known facts about numbers, we derived a contradiction. We conclude that there are no integers n, m for which that equation holds (in other words, the square root of two is not a rational number).
In the proof above, we made a deduction with an inconsistent set of premises, namely the premise that the square root of two is a quotient of integers, and known facts about numbers. From that, we derived a contradiction. Is that deduction valid?