• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Does Putin believe in his own propaganda?

Tammuz

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2006
Messages
522
Location
Sweden
Basic Beliefs
Scientific skepticism
In Russia, Putin promotes a nationalistic, conservative ideology. He puts that in contrast with the decadent Europeans who accept homosexuality and other depravities.

What I wonder is, do you think Putin actually believes his own propaganda, or is it just a useful tool for him to gain support from the masses?

While there are and have been dictators and autocrats that are/were rational psychopathic ruthless calculators (I'd put the Syrian dictator Assad in that category), there are/were also dictators and autocrats that while ruthless, are/were not particularly rational and delusional to various degrees (notably Gaddafi but also Saddam Hussein).
 
Do you have any links (preferably video) where Putin talks about gays and decadent Europeans?
 
I can't get my head around the need for conservatives in my own country, US, to believe the lies that they make up themselves. It is doubly hard to judge people in other countries.

The cornerstone of any conservative's belief system is denial of any problems created by the status quo, the way things are and the prevailing social order. This means that they have to rely on lies to support their positions. Reality is their enemy.

But to what degree they believe the lies, I don't know. Here in the US they have been telling some lies for so long that it is possible that they don't even realize that they are lies, propaganda. But they also are so quick to adopt the new lies that they have to understand on some level that they are lies.
 
In Russia, Putin promotes a nationalistic, conservative ideology. He puts that in contrast with the decadent Europeans who accept homosexuality and other depravities.

What I wonder is, do you think Putin actually believes his own propaganda, or is it just a useful tool for him to gain support from the masses?

While there are and have been dictators and autocrats that are/were rational psychopathic ruthless calculators (I'd put the Syrian dictator Assad in that category), there are/were also dictators and autocrats that while ruthless, are/were not particularly rational and delusional to various degrees (notably Gaddafi but also Saddam Hussein).

He more than likely does to a certain extent; though probably not to the absurd degrees present in much of the propaganda noise. He seems to have an outdated understanding of the world; informed by being raised with cold war propaganda and reinforced through his career. The real danger is in how the propaganda can reinforce his pre-existing biases. A man who hates a certain group might start spreading lies about that group in order to whip up support for his position; and when his views start becoming popular and he gains power and influence, this serves to 'validate' his hate, and radicalize him further. Even to the point where he'll start believing some of his own lies.
 
Putin's laws related to LGBTs are heavily focused upon public speech. They are a tool to attack, imprison, and destroy political dissenters in general and those who question Putin's authority. People that care about liberty, equality, and humane treatment in general would object to such laws. Putin knows this. Thus by attacking gays and making it illegal to speak out to protect gays, he is cleverly outing anyone not willing to cower to his authority more generally and liberals who might oppose him in other areas. If a person or media challenge him on issue X, he will investigate whether they ever said anything supporting gays, and use it as an excuse to make them dissappear.
 
I will repeat my request:
Do you have any links (preferably video) where Putin talks about gays and decadent Europeans?
 
In Russia, Putin promotes a nationalistic, conservative ideology. He puts that in contrast with the decadent Europeans who accept homosexuality and other depravities.
Do you have link or a speech where Putin does this?
I found this where Putin briefly touches on Europe.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8xSZ9Fr4c0

I think Putin's appeal to "traditional" values is in order to somehow stir up and motivate Russians, in a world where rightly or wrongly they see "Russia" under threat. Putin often speaks of christianity as something that united various peoples there and uses it in order to stir up some feelings.
There seems little doubt now that there is a movement in Russia which is trying to prepare people for a confrontation with America.
The mythology is that, now, yet again the heroic Russian people will be called upon to defeat another empire bent on world domination.
Here is yet another article from this month talking of this and appealing to Russia's christian heritage as a motivational tool.
The reality, Americans, Germans, and foolish Poles, is, Russians will fight and 152 million people will fight to the end, not because Putin sits in power, or because we fear the enemy, but because love of Russia, the very idea of Russia, will drive fanatical, well trained and armed with advanced weaponry resistance. Russians will fight regardless of who sits the throne,because we are not fighting for the leader but for Christ and for Russia, the land He gave us as the Third Rome.[ What exactly will you be fighting for?

Nothing like putting Russian society in a threatened siege mentality to force the individual chaotic Russian nature to crystallize into one direction: total destruction of the threat and the states that generate it.

So does Putin believe it. ..mmm...probably..inasmuch as he probably "believes" in Russia and all the attendant mythology, and that includes their traditions, at least as a way of fortifying Russia
 
http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2013/09/2...-dying-out-so-why-would-we-want-gay-marriage/
Mr Putin continued to say that although some European countries have introduced same-sex marriage, “the Europeans are dying out… and gay marriages don’t produce children.”

“Do you want to survive by accepting immigrants?” Mr Putin said. “Society can’t absorb such a number of immigrants. Let us make our own choice, as we see it for our country.”

“Without the values at the core of Christianity and other world religions, without moral norms that have been shaped over millennia, people will inevitably lose their human dignity,” he argued.

The President criticised Western Europe, where “any traditional identity, … including sexual identity, is rejected… There is a policy equating families with many children with same-sex families, belief in God with belief in Satan.”


http://www.gaystarnews.com/article/...tries-considering-legalizing-pedophilia200114
‘It's called a ban on the propaganda of pedophilia and homosexuality. There are countries, including in Europe, where they're debating the possibility of legalizing pedophilia. Publicly discussing this, in parliament.

‘They can do what they want, but the people of Russia have their own cultural code, their own traditions.’
(This isn't true, of course; but claiming that legalized pedophilia is next is the usual sort of homophobic rhetoric).


http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...-anti-gay-tirade/story-fnb64oi6-1227139938552
The German chancellor was deep in one of the 40 conversations she has had with the Russian president over the past year — more than the combined total with David Cameron, Francois Hollande and Barack Obama — when he began to rail against the “decadence” of the West.

Nothing exemplified this “decay of values” more than the West’s promotion of gay rights, Mr Putin told her.

It was then, said sources close to Ms Merkel, that she realised Europe and America should abandon all hope of finding a common language with the Kremlin and instead should adopt a policy of Cold War-style containment.

http://rt.com/news/berlusconi-gay-rights-putin-123/
“Berlusconi faces trial for bedding women. If he was gay, no one would ever lay a finger on him,” he said with a smile.

When even RT.com's articles put Putin's blatantly homophobic statements and jokes on display, one really doesn't have to pretend that the man doesn't believe the hype.
 
House of Cards' take on the issue in the episode where this was part of the plot line, the Russian president thinks the law is barbaric but he supports it because the people do and the Russian people have proud traditions :)
 
Do you have any links (preferably video) where Putin talks about gays and decadent Europeans?

You got your answer above. Does it do for you?

No, it does not. First of all, that was the first time I heard him speaking on these issues, and second of all I expected much worse than that. OP paints a picture of Putin talking about it all the time. Well, he does not, that was a question from a reporter, he had to answer it. Fact is, compared to US Russia have much less number of gay-obsessed freaks. US has whole republican party.
 
Fact is, compared to US Russia have much less number of gay-obsessed freaks. US has whole republican party.

This is sheer and utter hogwash.

In the US, LGBT individuals are protected from discrimination by laws, are guaranteed equality in most areas; with marriage being a right they are getting in more and more states, and are not restricted in their right to free speech.

In Russia, there are *no* laws protecting LGBT from discrimination (and violence against them is rampant), homosexuality is classified as a mental illness, they are not allowed to talk openly about the issues they face because the law classifies this as 'gay propaganda', and they are routinely compared to pedophiles (see the previous gay propaganda law, which is aimed at protecting children and was passed *unanimously*).

There are few countries as gay-unfriendly as Russia, and the US doesn't even come close.
 
Fact is, compared to US Russia have much less number of gay-obsessed freaks. US has whole republican party.

This is sheer and utter hogwash
hogwash is in your head.
In the US, LGBT individuals are protected from discrimination by laws,
Especially in Indiana :)
are guaranteed equality in most areas; with marriage being a right they are getting in more and more states, and are not restricted in their right to free speech.

In Russia, there are *no* laws protecting LGBT from discrimination (and violence against them is rampant),
"Rampant"? You are really going with that word?
homosexuality is classified as a mental illness,
I see you have been following this topic closely :)
I am sorry to disappoint you but that was unintentional legalistic mishap. Compare it to what is happening in Indiana. There was nothing unintentional about that.
they are not allowed to talk openly about the issues they face because the law classifies this as 'gay propaganda', and they are routinely compared to pedophiles (see the previous gay propaganda law, which is aimed at protecting children and was passed *unanimously*).

There are few countries as gay-unfriendly as Russia,
Define "few"? Is anything other that Europe and parts of North America a "few"?
Russian legal system is not particularly people-friendly. So you need to have a perspective.
I admit that from a legal point standpoint they are not doing well in Russia. But if you look at the entertainment industry they are doing as well as anywhere.
and the US doesn't even come close.
You are such a ridiculous exaggerator.

Anyhow, OP creates an impression of Putin being anti-gay activist or something. In reality he does not give a shit about it and given a choice would not bring that issue at all. Thees anti-gay laws were pushed by Christian lobby not by Putin or other "normal" politicians.
 
Especially in Indiana :)

The state legislature of Indiana has enacted specific protections against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity. And gay marriage is legal there. Neither of this is invalidated by the recent religious objection law; which isn't even remotely equivalent to Russia's anti-gay laws.

So yes, Indiana is far ahead of Russia.

"Rampant"? You are really going with that word?

Yes I am, as are many international organizations tasked with monitoring this sort of thing. Anti-gay violence has risen dramatically in the past couple of years in Russia. As a result, asylum requests in the West from Russian LGBT's are also up dramatically. The facts are clear. Instead of acknowledging the reality though, you choose to nit-pick over terminology, convincing absolutely nobody in the process that things aren't getting very bad indeed.

I see you have been following this topic closely :)
I am sorry to disappoint you but that was unintentional legalistic mishap. Compare it to what is happening in Indiana. There was nothing unintentional about that.

On this one thing, at least, I was mistaken. Russia declassified homosexuality as a mental illness in '99. No, this isn't a point in their favor, as this is (ironically, given your own claim) just a consequence of endorsing the WHO's IC-10. Incidentally, the US declassified homosexuality as a mental disorder as far back as '73-75. ('73 for the Netherlands, btw)

Define "few"? Is anything other that Europe and parts of North America a "few"?

You're not very up to date on gay rights around the world, are you? Gay rights aren't just a thing in Europe and North-America. Did you even know that Brazil and Argentinia have legalized gay marriage? What about South-Africa? LGBT rights are explicitly supported by more countries than those that oppose them. 94 UN members have signed a general assembly declaration of LGBT rights. That includes almost all of South-America, all of North-America, all of Europe except for Russia and Belarus, A number of African countries, as well as Japan, South-Korea, Thailand, Mongolia, Australia, and New Zealand.


Russian legal system is not particularly people-friendly. So you need to have a perspective.

If your argument is literally "Russia's legal system abuses everyone, not just LGBT people", you've already lost.


You are such a ridiculous exaggerator.

You're the one who tried to re-direct from the suffering LGBT people in Russia to the US. You were the one trying to imply that things were just as bad or even worse for them in the US; an implication that is not just demonstrably false, but an outright ridiculous exageration.

Anyhow, OP creates an impression of Putin being anti-gay activist or something. In reality he does not give a shit about it and given a choice would not bring that issue at all. Thees anti-gay laws were pushed by Christian lobby not by Putin or other "normal" politicians.

Riiight.

Except this law was passed *unanimously* in the duma and signed into existence by Putin himself. So either Putin and almost the entirety of the Russian political system are a bunch of spineless weasels terrified of the Christian lobby; OR they actually *do* agree with it.

Try again.
 
The state legislature of Indiana has enacted specific protections against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity. And gay marriage is legal there. Neither of this is invalidated by the recent religious objection law; which isn't even remotely equivalent to Russia's anti-gay laws.

So yes, Indiana is far ahead of Russia.
Have you been to Indiana or Russia?
I have spent considerable amount of time in both.

"Rampant"? You are really going with that word?

Yes I am, as are many international organizations tasked with monitoring this sort of thing. Anti-gay violence has risen dramatically in the past couple of years in Russia. As a result, asylum requests in the West from Russian LGBT's are also up dramatically. The facts are clear. Instead of acknowledging the reality though, you choose to nit-pick over terminology, convincing absolutely nobody in the process that things aren't getting very bad indeed.

I see you have been following this topic closely :)
I am sorry to disappoint you but that was unintentional legalistic mishap. Compare it to what is happening in Indiana. There was nothing unintentional about that.

On this one thing, at least, I was mistaken. Russia declassified homosexuality as a mental illness in '99. No, this isn't a point in their favor, as this is (ironically, given your own claim) just a consequence of endorsing the WHO's IC-10. Incidentally, the US declassified homosexuality as a mental disorder as far back as '73-75. ('73 for the Netherlands, btw)
It was what I said it was - unintentional legalistic mishap.
Define "few"? Is anything other that Europe and parts of North America a "few"?

You're not very up to date on gay rights around the world, are you? Gay rights aren't just a thing in Europe and North-America. Did you even know that Brazil and Argentinia have legalized gay marriage? What about South-Africa? LGBT rights are explicitly supported by more countries than those that oppose them. 94 UN members have signed a general assembly declaration of LGBT rights. That includes almost all of South-America, all of North-America, all of Europe except for Russia and Belarus, A number of African countries, as well as Japan, South-Korea, Thailand, Mongolia, Australia, and New Zealand.
You did not mention Ukraine, why is that? :)
And it were civilized Europeans who killed Alan Turing. And russians did not kill Chaikovsky. So tone your outrage down a little.
Russian legal system is not particularly people-friendly. So you need to have a perspective.

If your argument is literally "Russia's legal system abuses everyone, not just LGBT people", you've already lost.
Yes, that's my argument, legal system abuses everyone equally without discrimination. And it is you who lost here.
You are such a ridiculous exaggerator.

You're the one who tried to re-direct from the suffering LGBT people in Russia to the US. You were the one trying to imply that things were just as bad or even worse for them in the US; an implication that is not just demonstrably false, but an outright ridiculous exageration.
They are not as bad as you think in Russia.
Anyhow, OP creates an impression of Putin being anti-gay activist or something. In reality he does not give a shit about it and given a choice would not bring that issue at all. Thees anti-gay laws were pushed by Christian lobby not by Putin or other "normal" politicians.

Riiight.

Except this law was passed *unanimously* in the duma and signed into existence by Putin himself. So either Putin and almost the entirety of the Russian political system are a bunch of spineless weasels terrified of the Christian lobby; OR they actually *do* agree with it.
They are, but so is any politician including yours.
The only reason gays are doing better (relatively speaking) in US is because they have spent a lot of time fighting for it and because majority of people now seem to support them and politicians see that. But 30 years ago US was not better than Russia now.
Try again.
You try.
 
Have you been to Indiana or Russia?
I have spent considerable amount of time in both.

Have you been to either whilst being an open member of the LGBT community? Because if you have, and you'd be honest instead of just doing your usual 'Russia uber alles' routine, you wouldn't be trying to claim that the former is worse than the latter.

It was what I said it was - unintentional legalistic mishap.

You realize what you're saying here is that its *declassification* was an unintentional legalistic mishap, right? In other words, you're saying that it was Russia's intention to KEEP classifying it as a mental disorder. Is that really what you want to be caught saying in black and white?


You did not mention Ukraine, why is that? :)

I did, actually, mention Ukraine. I know geography is hard for Russians. Take a look at what I said: ALL of Europe *except* for Russia and Belarus. Ukraine is part of Europe. Therefore, I mentioned it. And yes, Ukraine signed that pro-LGBT declaration.

And it were civilized Europeans who killed Alan Turing. And russians did not kill Chaikovsky. So tone your outrage down a little.

Another typical tu quoque attempt. You're talking about two people who lived before either of us were even born. They are not relevant to the modern situation. You're also conveniently leaving out the fact that Tchaikovsky actively *hid* his homosexuality from society at large; and the actual cause of his death remains controversial to this day with many at the time and even now claiming that it was in fact suicide. As usual, you manage to shoot your own arguments in the foot.


Yes, that's my argument, legal system abuses everyone equally without discrimination.

Except that is demonstrably false, because heterosexuals are not imprisoned for openly talking about heterosexuality.


And it is you who lost here.

Sick burn yo.

They are not as bad as you think in Russia.

http://gawker.com/inside-occupy-pedophilia-russias-largest-anti-gay-vig-1517366131

Yes. It is exactly as bad as I think it is in Russia. You're either just ignorant of what these people actually face, or you're deliberately closing your eyes. I'm not sure which is worse.


They are, but so is any politician including yours.

Our parliament doesn't unanimously vote on ANYTHING. Our politicians are not prone to voting for or against things based on these kinds of minority pressures. Even if some individual politicans might, the nature of our multi-party democratic system ensures that parties and parliament as a whole will not vote against their own positions because they're pressured into it by others.

Your politicians, of course, also don't massively vote against their own beliefs and positions based on such pressure; but I think it's hilarious that the image you paint is of Russia being led by a bunch of cowards who are totally cool with gay people but who are scared of Christian bullies; and that consequently it is in fact the European leaders who have something resembling a spine because they don't habitually vote to deprive entire communities of free speech because a few religious people are pushing them to.


The only reason gays are doing better (relatively speaking) in US is because they have spent a lot of time fighting for it and because majority of people now seem to support them and politicians see that. But 30 years ago US was not better than Russia now.

Yes, even 30 years ago the US was better than Russia is today. Not that it'd be anything remotely resembling a valid point if you were actually right; you're defending Russia on the basis that it's still too ignorant and hateful to be at the same level as the west. Which surely even you must realize isn't a very good justification for its behavior.
 
Have you been to either whilst being an open member of the LGBT community? Because if you have, and you'd be honest instead of just doing your usual 'Russia uber alles' routine, you wouldn't be trying to claim that the former is worse than the latter.

It was what I said it was - unintentional legalistic mishap.

You realize what you're saying here is that its *declassification* was an unintentional legalistic mishap, right? In other words, you're saying that it was Russia's intention to KEEP classifying it as a mental disorder. Is that really what you want to be caught saying in black and white?


You did not mention Ukraine, why is that? :)

I did, actually, mention Ukraine. I know geography is hard for Russians. Take a look at what I said: ALL of Europe *except* for Russia and Belarus. Ukraine is part of Europe. Therefore, I mentioned it. And yes, Ukraine signed that pro-LGBT declaration.

And it were civilized Europeans who killed Alan Turing. And russians did not kill Chaikovsky. So tone your outrage down a little.

Another typical tu quoque attempt. You're talking about two people who lived before either of us were even born. They are not relevant to the modern situation. You're also conveniently leaving out the fact that Tchaikovsky actively *hid* his homosexuality from society at large; and the actual cause of his death remains controversial to this day with many at the time and even now claiming that it was in fact suicide. As usual, you manage to shoot your own arguments in the foot.


Yes, that's my argument, legal system abuses everyone equally without discrimination.

Except that is demonstrably false, because heterosexuals are not imprisoned for openly talking about heterosexuality.


And it is you who lost here.

Sick burn yo.

They are not as bad as you think in Russia.

http://gawker.com/inside-occupy-pedophilia-russias-largest-anti-gay-vig-1517366131

Yes. It is exactly as bad as I think it is in Russia. You're either just ignorant of what these people actually face, or you're deliberately closing your eyes. I'm not sure which is worse.


They are, but so is any politician including yours.

Our parliament doesn't unanimously vote on ANYTHING. Our politicians are not prone to voting for or against things based on these kinds of minority pressures. Even if some individual politicans might, the nature of our multi-party democratic system ensures that parties and parliament as a whole will not vote against their own positions because they're pressured into it by others.

Your politicians, of course, also don't massively vote against their own beliefs and positions based on such pressure; but I think it's hilarious that the image you paint is of Russia being led by a bunch of cowards who are totally cool with gay people but who are scared of Christian bullies; and that consequently it is in fact the European leaders who have something resembling a spine because they don't habitually vote to deprive entire communities of free speech because a few religious people are pushing them to.


The only reason gays are doing better (relatively speaking) in US is because they have spent a lot of time fighting for it and because majority of people now seem to support them and politicians see that. But 30 years ago US was not better than Russia now.

Yes, even 30 years ago the US was better than Russia is today. Not that it'd be anything remotely resembling a valid point if you were actually right; you're defending Russia on the basis that it's still too ignorant and hateful to be at the same level as the west. Which surely even you must realize isn't a very good justification for its behavior.
I think there is no need for you to repeat all this bullshit which was refuted already. Just type "I am a russophobe" and we will be done with it.
 
Just type "I am a russophobe" and we will be done with it.

By the same token, you could just type "I'm a Russophile" and be done with it.

Thanks to your posts here, I don't even need to seek out the official Kremlin line on any subject. I just read your posts and I know what they want disseminated.
 
Just type "I am a russophobe" and we will be done with it.

By the same token, you could just type "I'm a Russophile" and be done with it.

Thanks to your posts here, I don't even need to seek out the official Kremlin line on any subject. I just read your posts and I know what they want disseminated.
Oh another usual russophobe.
And I am not a Russophile. Just don't like when bullshit some on the west spread about countries they don't like.
 
Back
Top Bottom