Anarchism/Capitalism Thread Split

[Jason Harvestdancer]

I did nothing for you.

I am not caring much about you.

You have childish strawmen and no ideas.

If you don't care about morality Anarchism will not interest you much.

Is the master/servant relationship a moral relationship?

Is a dictatorship a moral arrangement of power?

Nihilists oppose Anarchism.

And are attracted to capitalism. It is a death cult.

Me: Define your version of anarchism without mentioning capitalism.
You: That's a strawman.

I admire your dedication but there is one thing you need to consider.

The closer we've gotten to my version of anarchism, the more people that have been lifted out of poverty.
The closer we've gotten to your version of anarchism, the more people that have been lifted out of life.

 

[untermensche]

Define capitalism.

 

[untermensche]

Is there a capitalist who takes these questions seriously?

Is the master/servant relationship a moral relationship?

Is a dictatorship a moral arrangement of power?

Because when you take these questions seriously you can't support capitalism as it exists.

 

[untermensche]

The closer we've gotten to your version of anarchism, the more people that have been lifted out of life.

The Colonization of India and Africa were capitalist adventures. Untold misery and uncounted dead all over the place.

WWI was a capitalist war. In WWII Germany was capitalist. State capitalist. Saying they had a connection to socialism was just another Nazi lie.

Vietnam was capitalist rape.

The invasion of Iraq was a capitalist scheme.

The capitalists have killed millions and millions.

They have crushed democracy all over the world.

In Greece, in Nicaragua, in Iran, in Chile, in Haiti, in Guatemala.......

It is laughable to think Anarchists have killed more than capitalists.

And the Communists worked to destroy the Anarchists. Anarchism is far from Communism.

 

[Jason Harvestdancer]

The closer we've gotten to your version of anarchism, the more people that have been lifted out of life.

The Colonization of India and Africa were capitalist adventures. Untold misery and uncounted dead all over the place.

WWI was a capitalist war. In WWII Germany was capitalist. State capitalist. Saying they had a connection to socialism was just another Nazi lie.

Vietnam was capitalist rape.

The invasion of Iraq was a capitalist scheme.

The capitalists have killed millions and millions.

They have crushed democracy all over the world.

In Greece, in Nicaragua, in Iran, in Chile, in Haiti, in Guatemala.......

It is laughable to think Anarchists have killed more than capitalists.

And the Communists worked to destroy the Anarchists. Anarchism is far from Communism.

"I don't like it, so I will call it 'capitalism'. Since by my definition, capitalism has caused all these problems, that is proof that capitalism is bad."

Did you know one could use another term for each and every one of those items in your sad attempt at a Gish Gallop, and by your logic prove that the substitute term is bad? No, you didn't know that.

Then again, several pages ago, you did say that Communist China is an example of Capitalism.

 

[untermensche]

The closer we've gotten to your version of anarchism, the more people that have been lifted out of life.

The Colonization of India and Africa were capitalist adventures. Untold misery and uncounted dead all over the place.

WWI was a capitalist war. In WWII Germany was capitalist. State capitalist. Saying they had a connection to socialism was just another Nazi lie.

Vietnam was capitalist rape.

The invasion of Iraq was a capitalist scheme.

The capitalists have killed millions and millions.

They have crushed democracy all over the world.

In Greece, in Nicaragua, in Iran, in Chile, in Haiti, in Guatemala.......

It is laughable to think Anarchists have killed more than capitalists.

And the Communists worked to destroy the Anarchists. Anarchism is far from Communism.

"I don't like it, so I will call it 'capitalism'. Since by my definition, capitalism has caused all these problems, that is proof that capitalism is bad."

Did you know one could use another term for each and every one of those items in your sad attempt at a Gish Gallop, and by your logic prove that the substitute term is bad? No, you didn't know that.

Then again, several pages ago, you did say that Communist China is an example of Capitalism.

The economy of totalitarian China is state capitalism.

Proving beyond doubt capitalism has no connection to democracy.

How exactly are any of those things not the constant result of capitalism?

Your fantasy capitalism has never existed and wouldn't last 20 years. It would devour itself and descend into near slavery for most without government protections.