• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

What difference does it make?

 
 
 
Sort by date Sort by votes
To whom?
To me? None whatsoever beyond the annoyance of godders’ ignorant pronouncements.
But there’s a whole universe of god threads here, so someone must give a shit.
To me, the question is exactly as germane to any aspect of my life, as is whether there’s a purple unicorn in my garage that only comes out when I’m not there.
There are enough miracles* in my life that gods are superfluous, should any exist.

* feel free to tell me whether I use the word colloquially or literally. :)
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
RIS said:
SIMPLY

What difference does it make whether OR NOT gods exist?
Click to expand...
It doesn't matter to me.

I have a god image I prefer to believe in. There's no real evidence on the subject, I just prefer to believe in it. That's why it's a Faith based belief.

If it weren't for religious people demanding that I live by their primitive moral and ethical codes I would not care at all.
Tom
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
TomC said:
It doesn't matter to me.
Click to expand...

Okay. That's a good answer. But I doubt the veracity of it because it seems contrary to the evidence. If it doesn't matter why would you be here yammering on and on about it as is our want? It could be you find it ridiculously fascinating. That's part of the reason I do it. I think your apathetic statement is true, but incomplete.

TomC said:
I have a god image I prefer to believe in.
Click to expand...

Is that a statement on the existence of this god you have an image of?

TomC said:
There's no real evidence on the subject, I just prefer to believe in it. That's why it's a Faith based belief.
Click to expand...

That makes sense. I've said it myself here. Except for the evidence part. By evidence do you mean data for or against the existence of God? Sorry, we have to talk about just one, not your image. Too bad.

TomC said:
If it weren't for religious people demanding that I live by their primitive moral and ethical codes I would not care at all.
Click to expand...

There!! That's it! That's the answer to my question of what difference it makes. It doesn't matter if God exists or not, the only thing that really matters is the control, is that a fair statement?

ETA: See how simple that was, folks. Let's give Tom here a round of applause. And me as well, of course, but I've already had a great deal of that. My cup runneth over.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
RIS said:
SIMPLY

What difference does it make whether OR NOT gods exist?
Click to expand...

To the extent that people *believe* that god(dess)(es) exist, why, it still doesn’t matter if they actually exist if there is absolutely no discernable effect on us from the god(dess)(es) themselves. And there is, indeed, no discernable effect on us from any theorized god(dess)(es).

However, discussing whether or not they exist does help us to understand the thought processes and likely reactions of people who think that they have a mandate from a god(dess)(es) to try to control others.

So in the end, the discussion is about people, not god(dess)(es).
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Elixir said:
To whom?
To me? None whatsoever beyond the annoyance of godders’ ignorant pronouncements.
But there’s a whole universe of god threads here, so someone must give a shit.
To me, the question is exactly as germane to any aspect of my life, as is whether there’s a purple unicorn in my garage that only comes out when I’m not there.
There are enough miracles* in my life that gods are superfluous, should any exist.

* feel free to tell me whether I use the word colloquially or literally. :)
Click to expand...

What, you mean return the favor? Nah. Tisn't necessary. Anyway, either way, I thought this was a very good answer. It makes sense no matter how I look at it. I would only say to anyone and everyone when you asked to whom?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
RIS said:
SIMPLY

What difference does it make whether OR NOT gods exist?
Click to expand...
It's an amusing topic to discuss.

OTOH, people who involve religion in politics make a lot of difference with punitive laws based on those religious ideas. Women and sexual issues, for example. I really don't care what you or anyone else believes, if they leave me alone and don't let their ideas restrict anyone else's rights.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
RIS said:
TomC said:
It doesn't matter to me.
Click to expand...

Okay. That's a good answer. But I doubt the veracity of it because
Click to expand...

Because you have a propensity to make claims before you understand the answers people give you. So you tend toward impugning their honor out loud before you finish listening.

RIS said:
it seems contrary to the evidence.
Click to expand...

Only if you draw conclusions before hearing all the evidence…

RIS said:
If it doesn't matter why would you be here yammering on and on about it as is our want? It could be you find it ridiculously fascinating.
Click to expand...

It turns out that it is ridiculously fascinating to ponder how people believe things. And this discussion board was built to facilitate such engagements for understanding of each other. That’s why it’s our wont here.

RIS said:
That's part of the reason I do it. I think your apathetic statement is true, but incomplete.

TomC said:
I have a god image I prefer to believe in.
Click to expand...

Is that a statement on the existence of this god you have an image of?

TomC said:
There's no real evidence on the subject, I just prefer to believe in it. That's why it's a Faith based belief.
Click to expand...

That makes sense. I've said it myself here. Except for the evidence part. By evidence do you mean data for or against the existence of God? Sorry, we have to talk about just one, not your image. Too bad.

TomC said:
If it weren't for religious people demanding that I live by their primitive moral and ethical codes I would not care at all.
Click to expand...

There!! That's it! That's the answer to my question of what difference it makes.
Click to expand...

And you could have just listened patiently until you got to this prt and you wouldn’t have had to type all that embarrassing pre-judgment stuff that turned out to be (predictably) wrong about his thoughts that you put above.

RIS said:
It doesn't matter if God exists or not, the only thing that really matters is the control, is that a fair statement?
Click to expand...

It’s incomplete. What matters is the damaging and harmful manifestations of control that other people exert on him.

Don’t be confused into thinking it’s about Tom wanting control. He’s been clear over the years that it’s not a desire to be in control (aka to “want to be god-like” as the religionists mistakenly assume), it is a desire to not be harmed by the prejudices of others.

RIS said:
ETA: See how simple that was, folks. Let's give Tom here a round of applause. And me as well, of course, but I've already had a great deal of that. My cup runneth over.
Click to expand...

You cup of derision runneth over. Tom didn’t do anything to earn snark from you. He didn’t reach some epiphany that you nurtured. It’s what he’s said all along. It’s you who finally caught up.


This entire board is absolutely full of evidence for the relatively universal opinion that if religionists, cultists and believers didn’t try to harm us so regularly, we wouldn’t give a care what fantasies they indulge.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Rhea said:
RIS said:
SIMPLY

What difference does it make whether OR NOT gods exist?
Click to expand...

To the extent that people *believe* that god(dess)(es) exist, why, it still doesn’t matter if they actually exist if there is absolutely no discernable effect on us from the god(dess)(es) themselves. And there is, indeed, no discernable effect on us from any theorized god(dess)(es).

However, discussing whether or not they exist does help us to understand the thought processes and likely reactions of people who think that they have a mandate from a god(dess)(es) to try to control others.

So in the end, the discussion is about people, not god(dess)(es).
Click to expand...

Would you agree that if it wasn't gods in question, if it was some other means of control, the effect would be the same? I think that's what you are saying but HEY - I wouldn't want to presume anything.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
lostone said:
RIS said:
SIMPLY

What difference does it make whether OR NOT gods exist?
Click to expand...
It's an amusing topic to discuss.

OTOH, people who involve religion in politics make a lot of difference with punitive laws based on those religious ideas. Women and sexual issues, for example. I really don't care what you or anyone else believes, if they leave me alone and don't let their ideas restrict anyone else's rights.
Click to expand...

I agree. On one hand. On the other hand (OTOH if you insist) there's a lot problematic there unless you are absolute. Let people believe what they want to believe is an illusion in a democracy. Mob rules. Sorry. In a rupublic on the other hand the rights of the individual eclipse the right of a group, or mob, if you will. Jesus said he was no part of the world and his followers would be no part of the world. When they tried to make him king, he fled. When Satan, the ruler of the world, tried to tempt him with all of the kingdoms of all time, he refused.

His alleged followers? Not so much, but on the other hand they have democracy.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Rhea said:
Because you have a propensity to make claims before you understand the answers people give you.
Click to expand...

Correct.

Rhea said:
So you tend toward impugning their honor out loud before you finish listening.
Click to expand...

Here we go again. Hell hath no fury. YAY! Another thread about me! For a recluse you certainly are obsessed with what others think of your presentation.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Rhea said:
It’s incomplete. What matters is the damaging and harmful manifestations of control that other people exert on him.
Click to expand...

But the control isn't dependent upon the existence of God. If the God didn't exist something else could be used. Like science.

Rhea said:
Don’t be confused into thinking it’s about Tom wanting control.
Click to expand...

It isn't about Tom wanting to control his own life without the interference of anyone else for any reason?

Rhea said:
He’s been clear over the years that it’s not a desire to be in control (aka to “want to be god-like” as the religionists mistakenly assume), it is a desire to not be harmed by the prejudices of others.
Click to expand...

I didn't think it would take long for you to do what every other ideologue always does. What you say I'm doing. Let Tom speak for himself. Let the religionists speak for themselves. Put away your fragile dented mask.

Rhea said:
You cup of derision runneth over. Tom didn’t do anything to earn snark from you. He didn’t reach some epiphany that you nurtured. It’s what he’s said all along. It’s you who finally caught up.
Click to expand...

Do please be quiet.

Rhea said:
This entire board is absolutely full of evidence for the relatively universal opinion that if religionists, cultists and believers didn’t try to harm us so regularly, we wouldn’t give a care what fantasies they indulge.
Click to expand...

Bullshit.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
pood said:
“Hell hath no fury …” “Do please be quiet … Yes, all of us and especially the Wimmins need to sit down and shut up while RIS manplains/religionsplains the facts of reality to us. But before that maybe he will learn to spell “fabulous,” “wont,” and “hazard.”
Click to expand...

Maybe you'll stop checking the spellcheck to see if I've spelled wright.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0 Downvote
Don2 (Don1 Revised) said:
The gods make a huge difference. Money, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Kim Jong Un have a significant impact on our lives. Don't understand the confusion.
Click to expand...

Exactly. Not all of those have an impact on all of us, but all of them have an impact on some of us. That's why Paul said their God is their belly. That's why Jehovah said to Moses, you will be God to Aaron and Pharaoh.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom