• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Big Think video Reza Aslan: Is the Trump Presidency a Cult?

Underseer

Contributor
Joined
May 29, 2003
Messages
11,413
Location
Chicago suburbs
Basic Beliefs
atheism, resistentialism


Holy sweet fucking shit, but I had to stop watching this video after 50 fucking seconds.

Has Reza Aslan never read the Bible or talked to a Christian?

Aslan seems to be shocked that Christians overwhelmingly voted for Trump despite the many "un-Christian" characteristics of Trump.

What in the actual fuck is un-Christian about Trump?

Racism
Christians are statistically more likely to be racist. That doesn't mean all Christians are overtly racist nor does it mean no atheists are (we even know which web sites and Internet communities are preferred by racist atheists), but Christians are more likely to be racist than atheists.

In fact, the original animating issue that launched the modern conservative Christian political movement was school busing. Abortion was arbitrarily selected as an issue simply because Christian leaders realized that the busing issue made them look like a bunch of racists and so they needed a different issue to get the base worked up. Abortion was chosen almost at random. Racism is the cause of the modern political incarnation of Christianity, and America history is full of Christians using Christianity to make excuses for slavery and later for racism.

Corruption
Trump is using the office of the president to enrich himself in ways that are probably illegal? So do many religious leaders that theists are taught to blindly follow. Pat Robertson didn't lose very many followers after news of the blood diamonds thing came out, and Pope sits on a golden throne built from wealth collected from human misery. Countless megachurch and televangelist leaders collect money from the poor to buy themselves private jets and mansions.

Support for leaders interested only in their own wealth and earthly power is hardly anything new in Christendom. It's been going on for as long as Christianity has been a thing.

Xenophobia
Trump hates foreigners? What's not Christian about that? Have you read the Old Testament? What about Luke 19:27?

Misogyny
Anyone who thinks Trump's treatment of women should be a problem for Christians has been living under a rock for the last 2000 years or so.

For example, Christian missionaries had trouble getting native Americans to accept Christianity until they made fundamental changes to native American society and got them to start treating their women worse. After that, Christianity spread quickly through native American communities. It does make one wonder what European cultures were like before Christianity, doesn't it?

It should surprise no one that modern Christians oppose the equal treatment of women at every possible opportunity. Every feminist advance in the past had to be made over the opposition of Christians. The fact that Muslims are on average worse when it comes to women's issues doesn't make Christians good on women's issues.

While some Christians might have a problem with his multiple divorces, the fact that he treats women like shit more than makes up for that in the eyes of a devout Christian.

Treason
Jesus instructed his followers to turn on and hate their own family members. In Jesus' name! Amen!

In fact the only genuinely un-Christian thing about Trump I can think of is that he has not (to my knowledge) ever advocated for slavery.

I can think of lots of things that would cause liberal/moderate Christians to oppose Trump, but I honestly can't think of anything that would cause most American Christians to abandon him. He sounds like everything the average Christian voter could ever have hoped for.
 
I liked this fellow's take on it.

There were two kinds of Trump voters, and they belong to either Team Because or Team Despite.

Some people are still supporting Trump despite all the awful things he has said and done. Despite his “grab them by the pussy” boasts of sexual assault, despite his fantasies about Mexican rapists pouring over the border, despite his enthusiasm for torture, [etc]...They don’t like any of that and find it all embarrassing and unfortunate, but despite it all they’re still leaning Trump because of abortion, or because they hate Hillary Clinton, or because of the Supreme Court, or just because they’re Republicans and Trump these days carries an “R” by his name....

Trump won those primaries without the help of Team Despite because he had the unwavering allegiance of Team Because. These are the folks who look at that whole long list above and love every bit of it. They love and support Donald Trump because of his crude language, because of his anti-immigrant slurs, [etc]...

I spent last weekend with a couple of long-time friends. They are what I consider to be good Christians. And they love love love Donald Trump. They love (I'm paraphrasing them) that he's the first President to get anything done about North Korea. They love that he won't back down to liberalism. And they especially love that his name is not Hillary Clinton, because everybody knows how evil she is.

Before this weekend, I thought that my two friends were on Team Despite. I was saddened to see that they actually belong to Team Because.
 
I liked this fellow's take on it.

There were two kinds of Trump voters, and they belong to either Team Because or Team Despite.

Some people are still supporting Trump despite all the awful things he has said and done. Despite his “grab them by the pussy” boasts of sexual assault, despite his fantasies about Mexican rapists pouring over the border, despite his enthusiasm for torture, [etc]...They don’t like any of that and find it all embarrassing and unfortunate, but despite it all they’re still leaning Trump because of abortion, or because they hate Hillary Clinton, or because of the Supreme Court, or just because they’re Republicans and Trump these days carries an “R” by his name....

Trump won those primaries without the help of Team Despite because he had the unwavering allegiance of Team Because. These are the folks who look at that whole long list above and love every bit of it. They love and support Donald Trump because of his crude language, because of his anti-immigrant slurs, [etc]...

I spent last weekend with a couple of long-time friends. They are what I consider to be good Christians. And they love love love Donald Trump. They love (I'm paraphrasing them) that he's the first President to get anything done about North Korea. They love that he won't back down to liberalism. And they especially love that his name is not Hillary Clinton, because everybody knows how evil she is.

Before this weekend, I thought that my two friends were on Team Despite. I was saddened to see that they actually belong to Team Because.

I'm confused about Team Despite.

How can anyone see Trump and think that he is in any way un-Christian? Why isn't every Christian (other than the liberal/moderate Christian minority of course) on Team Because?
 
I'm confused about Team Despite.

How can anyone see Trump and think that he is in any way un-Christian? Why isn't every Christian (other than the liberal/moderate Christian minority of course) on Team Because?

Depends on the flavor of Christianity. His sexual escapades disqualify him in certain Christian circles, but only from, say, serving as a deacon in a church, or running a youth ministry. But since he's gonna nominate judges that will forevermore make abortion illegal, then they'll give him a mulligan.
 
I'm confused about Team Despite.

How can anyone see Trump and think that he is in any way un-Christian? Why isn't every Christian (other than the liberal/moderate Christian minority of course) on Team Because?

Depends on the flavor of Christianity. His sexual escapades disqualify him in certain Christian circles, but only from, say, serving as a deacon in a church, or running a youth ministry. But since he's gonna nominate judges that will forevermore make abortion illegal, then they'll give him a mulligan.

In the case of sexual assault and the allegation of raping a 13 year old, can't he just blame his female victims? I know Christians are big on blaming female victims to let rapists off the hook.
 
Back
Top Bottom