To go back to the actual news from the Seattle Soviet Republic (aka CHAZ aka CHOP aka the other CHOP aka ...), they now demand racial segregation in medicine.
Seattle's Autonomous Zone Protesters Demand Race Based Health Care—Would it Work?
Newsweek said:
Protesters in Seattle's Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone, or CHAZ, put forth a list of 30 demands upon taking over the area, one of which is that hospitals hire black doctors and nurses to treat black patients, a move that would require health care facilities to walk a fine legal line.
So racial segregation is now considered a progressive value I guess ...
Race-based health care, while having gained support, presents legal and practical challenges to implementation. Proponents say it's one way to start closing disparities in health care, but it could take years and require changes to the education system to fill the shortage of black doctors, and CHAZ's demand that black doctors be employed for the specific purposes of treating black patients isn't quite legally sound.
"Change the education system" to make
medical school admissions and residency matching even more race-based than it already is. That would mean more competent white and Asian prospective doctors will be rejected and more preferred blacks and hispanics with mediocre grades and scores will be accepted. Brilliant plan! Hasn't Coronavirus pandemic shown that we need more competence and less politics in medicine?
However, patients are within their legal right to choose their doctor and physicians and researchers support increasing opportunities for black patients to see black doctors.
I guess if a patient insists on their racial bigotry you have to humor them, but I do not see what that kind of racism should be encouraged.
It's not a new concept and data shows there's merit to racial concordance between doctors and patients.
Really? What data?
Black people are more likely than white people to die at an early age from chronic conditions such as heart disease, stroke and diabetes, in part, because they aren't being screened and treated, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
And pushing more marginal students to treat them will help their treatment how?
And increasing minority representation will require more than just implementing changes in who is being hired.
One of the "biggest challenges" to increasing the number of black doctors in the health care field is standardized testing, Dr. Ryan Huerto, a family medicine doctor and a health services researcher at the National Clinician Scholars Program, told Newsweek. Experts called into question the exams' ability to measure potential and criticized it for skewing the playing field against already disadvantaged students.
Bull-fucking-shit! Standardized testing is a crucial tool for admissions because it is an objective measurement of their students no matter their background or school they attended.
A 3.9 GPA at Bumfuck State University is very different than a 3.9 from Emory. And not all students take the same classes in their undergrad. So MCAT is a way to subject them all to the same test.
Colleges and universities are already getting rid of SAT and ACT requirements and not all medical schools require students to take the MCAT, exams Huerto said aren't indicative of a person's ability to become a good physician. Even in a world without standardized exams, the pool of first-generation, low income and minority students pursuing a career in the medical field would still be smaller because it's costly to apply and train to be a doctor.
It is a big mistake to do away with SAT/ACT in the name of sneaking more racial preferences into the admissions process and the same goes for MCAT, except the stakes are higher given that physicians work on live people. For Huerto to say that MCAT is not indicative of ability to become a good physician is sheer nonsense. Most of MCAT measures a person's background in the scientific fundamentals linked to medicine. Obviously it is important to have a physician who is well versed in those.
It's the dumbing down of medical education. It goes hand it hand with USMLE Step 1 going pass-fail in a few years. There will be no actual scores reported and so there will be no difference between somebody who aced the exam and somebody who barely passed by the skin of their teeth and perhaps thinks that is no metaphor.
This Ryan Huerto seems like a race-baiting idiot.