• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

"DC fans" try to sabotage Black Panther Rotten Tomatoes score

Underseer

Contributor
Joined
May 29, 2003
Messages
11,413
Location
Chicago suburbs
Basic Beliefs
atheism, resistentialism
https://movieweb.com/black-panther-movie-dc-fans-sabotage-rotten-tomatoes-audience-score/

article said:
It worked for The Last Jedi, didn't it? After some hackers declared they'd dropped Rotten Tomatoes audience score for the latest Star Wars sequel (which the site claims just isn't true), a new group is planning to sabotage Disney's Black Panther by rigging it so that the audience score is as equally dreadful. These threats come from rage-fueled DC fans who believe the DCEU just isn't getting a fair shake on the aggregating review site. Which was accused by some of promoting and glorifying Star Wars 7 with great critics reviews, while Justice League and the rest of the DCEU universe (aside from Wonder Woman) has been relegated to the rotten category.

Let me offer some wild speculation, and I stress that this is all completely unsubstantiated.

I don't think these are really DC fans. I think these are white supremacists who are using DC fans as cover.

Again, this is a wild guess on my part. Feel free to completely dismiss this as speculative nonsense, because, well, it is.

But white supremacists long ago figured out that they needed to obfuscate their identity and motives. That's why the conservatives worked so hard to get everyone to use the phrase "alt right" instead of "white supremacist" or "white nationalist." There are lots of DC fans who genuinely think that there is some kind of conspiracy between the critics and Disney to give DC movies lower critical ratings despite the "fact" that the DC movies are exactly as good as the Marvel movies. (Nerds are insane, I'm one of them.)

Wouldn't this provide rather ideal cover for white supremacists in something like this obvious 'bot attack?

If you begin with "Hey, this group on the Internet started a 'bot attack to drive down the user rating for this movie," then ask them about their motives, and you see the usual conspiracy theory being thrown around by many DC fans, this certainly sounds plausible.

But what if we start with "What do DC fans think about Black Panther?" It looks very different. In fact, it looks like this:

https://heroichollywood.com/dc-fans-black-panther-reactions/

Most of it boils down to "Gosh, I hope Black Panther does well, because then maybe we will get a Static/Cyborg/Black Lightning movie!"

I think most of them understand that such an attack on the Black Panther movie could ultimately have negative consequences for superhero movies in general, while a genuinely good Black Panther movie would force Warner Brothers to step up their game and compete. It's the same reason I hope every DC movie is good, and am disappointed when they aren't.

This same group that went after Black Panther's low user ratings also claims responsibility for doing the same thing to Star Wars: the Last Jedi. Why these two movies? Why not Thor: Ragnarok to name one very recent example?

It seems plausible to me that perhaps a small group of white supremacists alt right free speech advocates identitarians with basic script-kiddie skills are using disputes within nerd culture as cover to try and discourage Hollywood from making movies that don't have white and/or male protagonists.

Again, this is all extremely speculative and I acknowledge that.
 
This DC vs. Marvel thing is international. Here are some Czech DC fans rallying against Marvel. Some of them are even cosplaying as Lex Luthor to show that they are true fans.

img.php
 
This is very counter productive, I will be giving it the highest level of praise on RT.

e0638a75c2df1346fe4104dd7ecef6db2e2c609662c594f4046e157cddc11427.jpg

3bdae687588d47945f799315ab3358816f548947105f28b2f55307f899d6a789.png
 
This is very counter productive, I will be giving it the highest level of praise on RT.

View attachment 14387

View attachment 14388

See? Our own resident white nationalist is attacking Black Panther. I don't see any DC fans in this thread attacking Black Panther. Repoman has added evidence (however circumstantial) to my hypothesis.

Your arguments are ridiculous, but I don't see the point in getting in an argument with a white supremacist. It's not as if you're going to see reason. The important thing is that you made the argument in the first place, which proves my point.
 
I approve of Black Panther, unironically.

I want that Make Wakanda Great Again hat.
 
I approve of Black Panther, unironically.

I want that Make Wakanda Great Again hat.

In other words, you approved of everything on your list. It doesn't matter that your list is insane, you just confirmed everything I said about you.

Did I err in calling you a white supremacist? Or do you people prefer the term "identitarian" now?
 
This DC vs. Marvel thing is international. Here are some Czech DC fans rallying against Marvel. Some of them are even cosplaying as Lex Luthor to show that they are true fans.

img.php

It's hilarious how they characterize the group they are against as evil, when Lex Luthor is supposed to be an embodiment of evil. Total lack of self-reflection.
 
So, Mark Kermode says it is a pretty good movie. Most importantly he says that he fully followed the plot and motivations of the movie during the final action scenes. Interestingly, the first rotten review on RT was for the final part of the movie being incoherent to that reviewer.

I wonder if the CG being immersive (for current high demand audiences) for the whole movie. That is a very tall order. It seems like it may be almost mystical in the portrayal of Wakanda.

 
Back
Top Bottom