Shelly Manne & His Men at the Black Hawk, Vol 1-5 (Original Jazz Classics)
I've given these discs a play as I drove in the past month. When I have a multi-disc set, it often sits on the shelf and seems like too much to listen to. These discs are all strong performances, recorded by one of Shelly's best groups during a three day stand at San Francisco's Black Hawk Club in the fall of 1959. This is one tight band: Shelly on drums, Monty Budwig on bass, Victor Feldman on piano, Joe Gordon on trumpet, and Richie Kamuca on tenor. As you'd expect, the pianist and the horn men get the lead roles on each tune, and all three are exemplary, playing with control and passion, and soloing brilliantly. The band's songbook is a mix of ballads and cookers. If you dread the thought of hearing one more version of Summertime, try the version that opens Vol 1. It's a showcase for Joe Gordon, and it will tell you that, if he hadn't died four years later in a house fire, he'd be a well-known name in jazz. (He recorded one lp as leader, Lookin' Good!, and it's one to search for.)
Volumes 1 through 4 came out in '60, and Vol. 5, containing all-new selections from the original gigs, didn't come out until 1991, by which point the only surviving band member was Monty Budwig (and he died the following year.) Unexpectedly, I found Vol. 5 to be the most captivating disc in the set. Lots of Kamuca and Gordon on the main themes, and two spotlight selections for Feldman, who stands out on this volume more than on 1-4. This is a band that let the soloists build major statements; no one plays a conventional couple of bars and pulls back for the next man. A few more highlights: Our Delight and Blue Daniel, from Vol.1; What's New and the 20-minute Vamp's Blues on Vol. 2; Black Hawk Blues on Vol. 3; Just Squeeze Me on Vol. 4; and all six cuts on Vol. 5 (How Deep Are the Roots/This Is Always/Wonder Why/Eclipse of Spain/Pullin' Strings/A Gem from Tiffany.)
Mainstream jazz, as good as it gets. Available as separate volumes.