• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

My tour of the Vatican

SLD

Contributor
Joined
Feb 25, 2001
Messages
5,109
Location
Birmingham, Alabama
Basic Beliefs
Freethinker
So did the tourist thing and visited Italy and took a guided tour of the Vatican. Word of advice, take a guided tour a skip the line ticket. The place is jammed and you otherwise wait 6 hours in line. It is an interesting museum. But as the guide was explaining when it was all built, I realized then why Luther and many others revolted. As I was thinking this the guide said, ”at that time there was a big war between the Christians and the Protestants.” I did a double take. A Freudian slip perhaps? Not one likely to play well with a group of American tourists.

But I was immediately reminded of a time when I was in a prayer group around the time I was losing my religion. We were asked to compare Christianity with other religions, and someone said, “Well, unlike Christians, Catholics believe . . .”

I guess I am naive in thinking that such thoughts had long since disappeared. It’s a fundamental aspect of religion, ours is the only true faith, anyone who disagrees is not a Christian. It doesn’t give me hope for mankind.

IAE, I still enjoyed my trip to the Vatican. I really enjoyed seeing a Tauroctony. But I wonder if the popes who built this really understood what it was. There were other pagan symbolism around it too.

E7946436-3943-4D95-B709-B2579BE31534.jpeg
 
In Catholic 50s grammar school I was taught the RCC is the one and only true Apostolic Christian church. I don't think that theology has changed, maybe softened a bit. Its the basis of the RCC assumed authority on Earth.

We are Christians, you-they are not.

A lot of Vatican expensive art and real estate. Nobody outside knows how much the RCC is worth.

If I were in Rome I'd rather take a tour of restaurants and pizzerias.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SLD
So did the tourist thing and visited Italy and took a guided tour of the Vatican. Word of advice, take a guided tour a skip the line ticket. The place is jammed and you otherwise wait 6 hours in line. It is an interesting museum. But as the guide was explaining when it was all built, I realized then why Luther and many others revolted. As I was thinking this the guide said, ”at that time there was a big war between the Christians and the Protestants.” I did a double take. A Freudian slip perhaps? Not one likely to play well with a group of American tourists.

But I was immediately reminded of a time when I was in a prayer group around the time I was losing my religion. We were asked to compare Christianity with other religions, and someone said, “Well, unlike Christians, Catholics believe . . .”

I guess I am naive in thinking that such thoughts had long since disappeared. It’s a fundamental aspect of religion, ours is the only true faith, anyone who disagrees is not a Christian. It doesn’t give me hope for mankind.

IAE, I still enjoyed my trip to the Vatican. I really enjoyed seeing a Tauroctony. But I wonder if the popes who built this really understood what it was. There were other pagan symbolism around it too.

View attachment 43346
  • "Mithras (centre), kneeling on the bull, holding it by the nostrils with his left hand, stabbing it with his right hand, and looking towards us.
  • The bull bleeds. A dog and a snake jump up to lick the blood. A scorpion grabs the bull's testicles.
  • The bull's tail is a sheaf of corn.
  • On either side of the scene are the "torch-bearers", or dadophoroi, Cautes (torch pointing up) and Cautopates (torch pointing down).
  • All this takes place in a cave, whose roof is above Mithras. Woodland scenes take place above the roof.
  • Top left is the sun, Sol, with a crown of rays. A long ray streaks down to light on Mithras. A raven sits nearby.
  • Top right is the moon, Luna.
  • Side-panels depicting events from the mythological life of Mithras appear on either side. The contents of these vary"
 
  • Like
Reactions: SLD
In Catholic 50s grammar school I was taught the RCC is the one and only true Apostolic Christian church. I don't think that theology has changed, maybe softened a bit. Its the basis of the RCC assumed authority on Earth.

We are Christians, you-they are not.

A lot of Vatican expensive art and real estate. Nobody outside knows how much the RCC is worth.

If I were in Rome I'd rather take a tour of restaurants and pizzerias.
I've done both long time ago, the Vatican and the pizzerias in Trastevere...:)
 
In Catholic 50s grammar school I was taught the RCC is the one and only true Apostolic Christian church. I don't think that theology has changed, maybe softened a bit. Its the basis of the RCC assumed authority on Earth.

We are Christians, you-they are not.

A lot of Vatican expensive art and real estate. Nobody outside knows how much the RCC is worth.

If I were in Rome I'd rather take a tour of restaurants and pizzerias.
The Vatican does have some amazing things to see. I wouldn’t ignore that. The collection of Roman art is really worth it if you Ike that stuff - which I do. The Sistine Chapel and the Pieta are perhaps two of the greatest pieces of Art in the world. They are quite breathtaking to see in person.

Another religious critique though. All of the Roman statues had their peckers chopped off and fig leaves added. You can see that the stone is different and on one they had a hole where the pecker was and the fig leave had fallen out. Same with the women. No problem with breasts but can’t have a smooth vagina for all to see. Gotta cover that up lest lust prevail! Even in the Sistine Chapel, they made Michelango cover up some peckers. You can clearly see where theres a fold, or some covering just over the crotch. Methinks it the men of that time needed it more than the women!

in the 50’s my mother visited Pompeii. They would not let her see the brothels because of the lewd paintings. Only men could go in.
 
So did the tourist thing and visited Italy and took a guided tour of the Vatican. Word of advice, take a guided tour a skip the line ticket. The place is jammed and you otherwise wait 6 hours in line. It is an interesting museum. But as the guide was explaining when it was all built, I realized then why Luther and many others revolted. As I was thinking this the guide said, ”at that time there was a big war between the Christians and the Protestants.” I did a double take. A Freudian slip perhaps? Not one likely to play well with a group of American tourists.

But I was immediately reminded of a time when I was in a prayer group around the time I was losing my religion. We were asked to compare Christianity with other religions, and someone said, “Well, unlike Christians, Catholics believe . . .”

I guess I am naive in thinking that such thoughts had long since disappeared. It’s a fundamental aspect of religion, ours is the only true faith, anyone who disagrees is not a Christian. It doesn’t give me hope for mankind.

IAE, I still enjoyed my trip to the Vatican. I really enjoyed seeing a Tauroctony. But I wonder if the popes who built this really understood what it was. There were other pagan symbolism around it too.

View attachment 43346
  • "Mithras (centre), kneeling on the bull, holding it by the nostrils with his left hand, stabbing it with his right hand, and looking towards us.
  • The bull bleeds. A dog and a snake jump up to lick the blood. A scorpion grabs the bull's testicles.
  • The bull's tail is a sheaf of corn.
  • On either side of the scene are the "torch-bearers", or dadophoroi, Cautes (torch pointing up) and Cautopates (torch pointing down).
  • All this takes place in a cave, whose roof is above Mithras. Woodland scenes take place above the roof.
  • Top left is the sun, Sol, with a crown of rays. A long ray streaks down to light on Mithras. A raven sits nearby.
  • Top right is the moon, Luna.
  • Side-panels depicting events from the mythological life of Mithras appear on either side. The contents of these vary"
There’s a lot of astrological significance to these. I have heard that it’s a reference to the precession of the equinox, moving out of Taurus and into Aries at that time. Ancient astronomers knew about the precession, but didn’t understand it and attributed it to a very powerful god.

But I don’t understand why the scorpion is grabbing the bull’s balls? Sounds painful.

And the stars, are they the Pleiades? There’s seven but it’s a different shape. Maybe the four are Corvus which are close to the crow perched there.
 
I use an image of that very relief in my class, when explaining about the "mystery cults". Interesting to see it hanging on the wall!

We know very little about the Mithraic rituals; they wrote next to nothing down. As a result, most of what we do "know" comes from either chance references in personal letters, or from people in modern times staring at friezes and guessing at what the symbolism might mean. An interesting game, but the limitations of such a method should always be kept in mind.

I visited the Vatican myself, some years back. An interesting experience, but I found it much too crowded to really concentrate on anything I was seeing, alas. I enjoyed my visit to St John Lateran more, as it was quiet enough to think, and really observe things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SLD
My grandmother was a devout Catholic. As a family outing we went to to the 6os NY World's Fare. There was the Pieta on display. A big deal for my grandmother. There was a moving walkway past the exhibit behind a glass wall and inside a mirror so nobody could throw something through the glass and damage the statue.

I have no interest in RCC 'Roman' opulence. The key word in RCC us Roman after all....

Visual art does not do anything for me.
 
So did the tourist thing and visited Italy and took a guided tour of the Vatican. Word of advice, take a guided tour a skip the line ticket. The place is jammed and you otherwise wait 6 hours in line. It is an interesting museum. But as the guide was explaining when it was all built, I realized then why Luther and many others revolted. As I was thinking this the guide said, ”at that time there was a big war between the Christians and the Protestants.” I did a double take. A Freudian slip perhaps? Not one likely to play well with a group of American tourists.

But I was immediately reminded of a time when I was in a prayer group around the time I was losing my religion. We were asked to compare Christianity with other religions, and someone said, “Well, unlike Christians, Catholics believe . . .”

I guess I am naive in thinking that such thoughts had long since disappeared. It’s a fundamental aspect of religion, ours is the only true faith, anyone who disagrees is not a Christian. It doesn’t give me hope for mankind.

IAE, I still enjoyed my trip to the Vatican. I really enjoyed seeing a Tauroctony. But I wonder if the popes who built this really understood what it was. There were other pagan symbolism around it too.

View attachment 43346
  • "Mithras (centre), kneeling on the bull, holding it by the nostrils with his left hand, stabbing it with his right hand, and looking towards us.
  • The bull bleeds. A dog and a snake jump up to lick the blood. A scorpion grabs the bull's testicles.
  • The bull's tail is a sheaf of corn.
  • On either side of the scene are the "torch-bearers", or dadophoroi, Cautes (torch pointing up) and Cautopates (torch pointing down).
  • All this takes place in a cave, whose roof is above Mithras. Woodland scenes take place above the roof.
  • Top left is the sun, Sol, with a crown of rays. A long ray streaks down to light on Mithras. A raven sits nearby.
  • Top right is the moon, Luna.
  • Side-panels depicting events from the mythological life of Mithras appear on either side. The contents of these vary"
There’s a lot of astrological significance to these. I have heard that it’s a reference to the precession of the equinox, moving out of Taurus and into Aries at that time. Ancient astronomers knew about the precession, but didn’t understand it and attributed it to a very powerful god.

But I don’t understand why the scorpion is grabbing the bull’s balls? Sounds painful.

And the stars, are they the Pleiades? There’s seven but it’s a different shape. Maybe the four are Corvus which are close to the crow perched there.
https://www.tertullian.org/rpearse/...supp_Unknown_Unknown_ReliefWithAcanthusLeaves

The correlation between Mithras and Jesus is significant...
https://www.tertullian.org/rpearse/mithras/display.php?page=Mithras_and_Jesus
 
So did the tourist thing and visited Italy and took a guided tour of the Vatican. Word of advice, take a guided tour a skip the line ticket. The place is jammed and you otherwise wait 6 hours in line. It is an interesting museum. But as the guide was explaining when it was all built, I realized then why Luther and many others revolted. As I was thinking this the guide said, ”at that time there was a big war between the Christians and the Protestants.” I did a double take. A Freudian slip perhaps? Not one likely to play well with a group of American tourists.

But I was immediately reminded of a time when I was in a prayer group around the time I was losing my religion. We were asked to compare Christianity with other religions, and someone said, “Well, unlike Christians, Catholics believe . . .”

I guess I am naive in thinking that such thoughts had long since disappeared. It’s a fundamental aspect of religion, ours is the only true faith, anyone who disagrees is not a Christian. It doesn’t give me hope for mankind.

IAE, I still enjoyed my trip to the Vatican. I really enjoyed seeing a Tauroctony. But I wonder if the popes who built this really understood what it was. There were other pagan symbolism around it too.

View attachment 43346
  • "Mithras (centre), kneeling on the bull, holding it by the nostrils with his left hand, stabbing it with his right hand, and looking towards us.
  • The bull bleeds. A dog and a snake jump up to lick the blood. A scorpion grabs the bull's testicles.
  • The bull's tail is a sheaf of corn.
  • On either side of the scene are the "torch-bearers", or dadophoroi, Cautes (torch pointing up) and Cautopates (torch pointing down).
  • All this takes place in a cave, whose roof is above Mithras. Woodland scenes take place above the roof.
  • Top left is the sun, Sol, with a crown of rays. A long ray streaks down to light on Mithras. A raven sits nearby.
  • Top right is the moon, Luna.
  • Side-panels depicting events from the mythological life of Mithras appear on either side. The contents of these vary"
There’s a lot of astrological significance to these. I have heard that it’s a reference to the precession of the equinox, moving out of Taurus and into Aries at that time. Ancient astronomers knew about the precession, but didn’t understand it and attributed it to a very powerful god.

But I don’t understand why the scorpion is grabbing the bull’s balls? Sounds painful.

And the stars, are they the Pleiades? There’s seven but it’s a different shape. Maybe the four are Corvus which are close to the crow perched there.
"The creation of the world is the central episode of Mithraic mythology. According to the myths, the sun god sent his messenger, the raven, to Mithra and ordered him to sacrifice the bull. Mithra executed the order reluctantly; in many reliefs he is seen turning aside his face in sorrow. But at the very moment of the death of the bull, a great miracle happened. The white bull was metamorphosed into the moon; the cloak of Mithra was transformed into the vault of the sky, with the shining planets and fixed stars; from the tail of the bull and from his blood sprang the first ears of grain and the grape; and from the genitals of the animal ran the holy seed which was received by a mixing bowl. Every creature on earth was shaped with an admixture of the holy seed. One Mithraic hymn begins: “Thou hast redeemed us too by shedding the eternal blood.” The plants and the trees were created. Day and night began to alternate, the moon started her monthly cycle, the seasons took up their round dance through the year, and thus time was created. But, awakened by the sudden light, the creatures of the dark emerged from earth. A serpent licked the bull’s blood. A scorpion tried to suck the holy seed from the genitals. On the reliefs a lion often is also seen. With the bull’s death and the creation of the world, the struggle between good and evil began: thus is the condition of human life. The raven symbolizes air, the lion fire, the serpent earth, and the mixing bowl water. So the four elements (air, fire, earth, and water) came into being, and from them all things were created. After the sacrifice, Mithra and the sun god banqueted together, ate meat and bread, and drank wine. Then Mithra mounted the chariot of the sun god and drove with him across the ocean, through the air to the end of the world.


The myth was interpreted by the Roman Mithraists in terms of Platonic philosophy. The sacrifice took place in a cave, an image of the world, as in the simile of the cave in Plato’s Republic. Mithra himself was equated with the demiurge, or creator, of the Timaeus: he was called “demiurge and father of all things,” like the Platonic demiurge. The four elements, the mixing bowl, the creation of time, and the attack of the wicked animals upon the newborn creature are well-known features of the Timaeus. The Mithraic doctrine of the soul is intimately linked with the myth of creation and with Platonic philosophy. As in the Timaeus, the human soul came down from heaven. It crossed the seven spheres of the planets, taking on their vices (e.g., those of Mars and of Venus), and was finally caught within the body. The task of human life is to liberate one’s divine part (the soul) from the shackles of the body and to reascend through the seven spheres to the eternal, unchanging realm of the fixed stars. This ascent to the sky was prefigured by Mithra himself, when he left the earth in the chariot of the sun god."

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Mithraism
 
  • Like
Reactions: SLD
Just so everyone is aware: Baptists do not consider Catholics to be Christians. Not certain about other Protestant faiths’ positions on Catholicism. Baptists also do not consider Mormons to be Christians.

I would really like to see the Sistine Chapel and the rest of Italy.
 
Just so everyone is aware: Baptists do not consider Catholics to be Christians. Not certain about other Protestant faiths’ positions on Catholicism. Baptists also do not consider Mormons to be Christians.

I would really like to see the Sistine Chapel and the rest of Italy.
Not all Baptists agree on all things, it's a pretty broad roof. When I was attending seminary I took classes at the ABCUSA-sponsored Berkeley School of Theology, which very clearly considered non-Baptist Christians part of the family given that their seminary was non-denominational in its recruitment and in communion with the other GTU institutions.

You should find a way out to Italy if you haven't been! Wonderful country. I have more love for Florence than Rome, but Rome does protect some of the most important sites of European history, and is at least an interesting if rather wild metropolis.
 
Just so everyone is aware: Baptists do not consider Catholics to be Christians. Not certain about other Protestant faiths’ positions on Catholicism. Baptists also do not consider Mormons to be Christians.

I would really like to see the Sistine Chapel and the rest of Italy.
Not all Baptists agree on all things, it's a pretty broad roof. When I was attending seminary I took classes at the ABCUSA-sponsored Berkeley School of Theology, which very clearly considered non-Baptist Christians part of the family given that their seminary was non-denominational in its recruitment and in communion with the other GTU institutions.

You should find a way out to Italy if you haven't been! Wonderful country. I have more love for Florence than Rome, but Rome does protect some of the most important sites of European history, and is at least an interesting if rather wild metropolis.
Ah, I meant to write Southern Baptists, or at least those churches of my youth. Actually in the town where I grew up, virtually all churches were a form of Baptist, regardless of whether or not Baptist was on the front of the church. There was a Methodist church as well—the most liberal of the denominations in my town. Also Jehovah’s witnesses. Definitely not liberal. The women and girls could not cut their hair. I remember one family where all the girls had their hair piled on their heads in an elaborate arrangement that looked old fashioned on their mother. Oh, and no pants or gym shirts. They were allowed to wear long culottes for gym.

I had intended to spend some time in Europe when I retired but: pandemic. Probably not in 2024 but hoping for 2025!
 
Just so everyone is aware: Baptists do not consider Catholics to be Christians. Not certain about other Protestant faiths’ positions on Catholicism. Baptists also do not consider Mormons to be Christians.

I would really like to see the Sistine Chapel and the rest of Italy.
Not all Baptists agree on all things, it's a pretty broad roof. When I was attending seminary I took classes at the ABCUSA-sponsored Berkeley School of Theology, which very clearly considered non-Baptist Christians part of the family given that their seminary was non-denominational in its recruitment and in communion with the other GTU institutions.

You should find a way out to Italy if you haven't been! Wonderful country. I have more love for Florence than Rome, but Rome does protect some of the most important sites of European history, and is at least an interesting if rather wild metropolis.
Ah, I meant to write Southern Baptists, or at least those churches of my youth. Actually in the town where I grew up, virtually all churches were a form of Baptist, regardless of whether or not Baptist was on the front of the church. There was a Methodist church as well—the most liberal of the denominations in my town. Also Jehovah’s witnesses. Definitely not liberal. The women and girls could not cut their hair. I remember one family where all the girls had their hair piled on their heads in an elaborate arrangement that looked old fashioned on their mother. Oh, and no pants or gym shirts. They were allowed to wear long culottes for gym.

I had intended to spend some time in Europe when I retired but: pandemic. Probably not in 2024 but hoping for 2025!
The ruination of many a plan. Back in 2020, we had this whole trip planned to visit Austria and Germany by rail from Zurich. Not this year obviously, but we'll see! We've still got the itinerary to pull out.
 
I did a tour of the Vatican in 1996. I was in Rome mainly for my interest in ancient Rome but in the Vatican a lot of really interesting looking areas were bypassed to focus on Roman Catholic stuff.
 
Back
Top Bottom