• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

I don't see Medicare for all or a wealth tax that many others support and ran on and won.
The state version of the wealth tax failed in California. It is nowhere near as popular an issue as some people want to believe.

M4A is also a very complex policy proposal where the devil is in the details.
 

Note that under his leadership Dems won a lot of Senate seats. Why punish him for his success now?
can you point to specifics that link Democrats winning Senate seats to Schumer’s actions? That is, to what extent can we say that the”blue tsunami” is “Schumer’s success”? For example, how many of the winners were endorsed by Schumer? What actions did he take to help those winners win?
Forgive me for being lazy and posting AI:

During and immediately following midterm elections, the U.S. Senate minority leader performs several critical duties focused on campaign strategy, party positioning, post-election leadership organization, and floor leadership:
Campaign and Strategic Support
    • Recruitment and Fundraising: The minority leader works closely with the party's campaign arm (such as the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee or National Republican Senatorial Committee) to recruit competitive candidates, raise funds, and direct financial resources to key Senate races. [1, 2]
    • Messaging and Public Advocacy: Acts as the primary national spokesperson for the party's platform, contrasting the minority party's vision with the policies of the majority party or the administration in power. [1, 2, 3]
    • Voter Mobilization: Helps coordinate nationwide or state-specific messaging, grassroots energy, and voter outreach efforts to flip seats and break the majority party's control. [1]
Post-Election Leadership and Caucus Organization
    • Caucus/Conference Elections: Immediately following the November general elections, the minority leader leads or participates in the internal caucus meetings where senators nominate and elect party leadership for the upcoming Congress. [1, 2]
    • Committee Assignment Coordination: Oversees or influences the assignment of minority party members to Senate committees, factoring in newly elected senators and changes in the balance of power. [1, 2]
    • Transition and Strategic Planning: Reassesses the party's legislative and oversight agenda based on whether the party gained seats, lost seats, or shifted into/out of the majority. [1]
Floor and Legislative Duties
    • Negotiating Legislative Schedules: Consults with the majority leader on unanimous consent agreements, floor debate limits, and the scheduling of remaining legislative business. [1, 2]
    • Protecting Minority Rights: Directs floor strategy, organizes opposition to or amendments for majority-backed bills, and works with party whips to ensure members are present for crucial post-election votes.[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]
 
  • Expand Child Tax Credit
  • Reverse Medicaid cuts and ACA subidy restoration
  • Ban congressional stock trading
  • Overturn Citizen United
  • Statutory right to abortion
  • Ban mid-decade gerrymadering
  • Restore SNAP funding
  • Eradicate Trumps tarriffs
  • Stop the war in Iran
These are the same things that Van Hollen and those who refer to themselves as progressives support, so as I said before, the Dems need to unite and work together even if they disagree on a few things. I had a hard time telling much difference when I read what Schumer supports and what Van Hollen supports.

Both of the above also support trans rights. legalizing THC, etc. so I don't see much difference between what most of these Dems want and blaming Schumer on Trump being elected in nonsense. I personally blame all the Dems that didn't vote in 2024. What the fuck were they thinking?
I don't see Medicare for all or a wealth tax that many others support and ran on and won.
It's early in the morning.... but if I remember correctly, Schumer said there should be affordable universal health care and increased taxes on the wealthy and corporations, so I don't see that as much different. Plus, what bugs me the most about M for All is nobody has really said how it will be paid for. Will there be premiums and copays based on incomes? How much will providers be paid? What will it add to the deficit? I'm all for UHC, but I want to know the details of how it will be managed and supported by the tax payers. I've been on Medicare for over 10 years. It's not cheap and the government is already having problems supporting it. It's one thing to yell that you want M for A and quite another to explain how it will be paid for and how it will be even passed into law by a disunited Congress.

I'm not necessarily against a wealth tax, but it won't be easy to do that. How do you assess one's total wealth? Won't it make it easier to put some assets overseas? I would prefer having much more progressive taxes, ending the tax cuts for the wealthy in the Trump bill and then going from there.? All of this is easier said than done.
 
  • Expand Child Tax Credit
  • Reverse Medicaid cuts and ACA subidy restoration
  • Ban congressional stock trading
  • Overturn Citizen United
  • Statutory right to abortion
  • Ban mid-decade gerrymadering
  • Restore SNAP funding
  • Eradicate Trumps tarriffs
  • Stop the war in Iran
These are the same things that Van Hollen and those who refer to themselves as progressives support, so as I said before, the Dems need to unite and work together even if they disagree on a few things. I had a hard time telling much difference when I read what Schumer supports and what Van Hollen supports.

Both of the above also support trans rights. legalizing THC, etc. so I don't see much difference between what most of these Dems want and blaming Schumer on Trump being elected in nonsense. I personally blame all the Dems that didn't vote in 2024. What the fuck were they thinking?
I don't see Medicare for all or a wealth tax that many others support and ran on and won.
It's early in the morning.... but if I remember correctly, Schumer said there should be affordable universal health care and increased taxes on the wealthy and corporations, so I don't see that as much different. Plus, what bugs me the most about M for All is nobody has really said how it will be paid for. Will there be premiums and copays based on incomes? How much will providers be paid? What will it add to the deficit? I'm all for UHC, but I want to know the details of how it will be managed and supported by the tax payers. I've been on Medicare for over 10 years. It's not cheap and the government is already having problems supporting it. It's one thing to yell that you want M for A and quite another to explain how it will be paid for and how it will be even passed into law by a disunited Congress.

I'm not necessarily against a wealth tax, but it won't be easy to do that. How do you assess one's total wealth? Won't it make it easier to put some assets overseas? I would prefer having much more progressive taxes, ending the tax cuts for the wealthy in the Trump bill and then going from there.? All of this is easier said than done.
I agree with you all the way. Weath taxes aren’t fair also. The only people with pensions anymore are government workers. Most non government workers rely on their 491ks for monthly payments in retirement. People with pensions aren’t taxed until they realize their income. Should be the same for non government workers.
 
I don't see Medicare for all or a wealth tax that many others support and ran on and won.
The state version of the wealth tax failed in California. It is nowhere near as popular an issue as some people want to believe.
NPR: Why did California's billionaire tax fail to surf the blue wave?

Did billionaire money tip the scales?​

Zucman blames the corrosive influence of money for Prop 40's failure.

"I am not surprised," Zucman says. Opponents of Prop 40 spent almost $400 million fighting it, including spending on competing ballot measures, making it one of the most expensive ballot initiative fights in history.

"The money spent by the billionaires was critical," Zucman says. "Anyone who lives in California has been carpet-bombed by a deluge of ads. One can easily see how this could be pivotal in such a closely contested ballot."

But didn't Democrats win plenty of races this cycle despite huge sums spent against them? In Texas, for example, Elon Musk alone poured more than $150 million into defeating Democrat James Talarico. And Talarico ended up winning his Senate race by a comfortable margin. Why would money have been so decisive with Prop 40 and not in other races around the nation?

For one, Zucman says, the spending gap was much bigger in the fight over Prop 40. "The billionaires spent more than $300 million on ads versus negligible sums on the other side," Zucman says. "On TV and in their mailboxes, voters were exposed only to the anti-tax arguments. This was very different from the other midterm races: in those races, when spending was high (e.g., Talarico vs. Paxton in Texas) it was high on both sides, even if unevenly. The net difference in spending was considerably larger for Prop 40."
Many people will vote against any tax increase no matter who it would apply to.

M4A is also a very complex policy proposal where the devil is in the details.
It's hard to do so we should not do it. There's that American spirit. (y)
 
I don't see Medicare for all or a wealth tax that many others support and ran on and won.
The state version of the wealth tax failed in California. It is nowhere near as popular an issue as some people want to believe.
NPR: Why did California's billionaire tax fail to surf the blue wave?

Did billionaire money tip the scales?​

Zucman blames the corrosive influence of money for Prop 40's failure.

"I am not surprised," Zucman says. Opponents of Prop 40 spent almost $400 million fighting it, including spending on competing ballot measures, making it one of the most expensive ballot initiative fights in history.

"The money spent by the billionaires was critical," Zucman says. "Anyone who lives in California has been carpet-bombed by a deluge of ads. One can easily see how this could be pivotal in such a closely contested ballot."

But didn't Democrats win plenty of races this cycle despite huge sums spent against them? In Texas, for example, Elon Musk alone poured more than $150 million into defeating Democrat James Talarico. And Talarico ended up winning his Senate race by a comfortable margin. Why would money have been so decisive with Prop 40 and not in other races around the nation?

For one, Zucman says, the spending gap was much bigger in the fight over Prop 40. "The billionaires spent more than $300 million on ads versus negligible sums on the other side," Zucman says. "On TV and in their mailboxes, voters were exposed only to the anti-tax arguments. This was very different from the other midterm races: in those races, when spending was high (e.g., Talarico vs. Paxton in Texas) it was high on both sides, even if unevenly. The net difference in spending was considerably larger for Prop 40."
Many people will vote against any tax increase no matter who it would apply to.

M4A is also a very complex policy proposal where the devil is in the details.
It's hard to do so we should not do it. There's that American spirit. (y)
Well, to me it’s crazy for a state to pass such a tax. Self defeating. If it passes, a person can just move across the border to the next state. A couple years ago Oregon passed a new tax that would have hurt my business. So I just moved our business 22 miles to the north in Washington. Problem solved.
 
can you point to specifics that link Democrats winning Senate seats to Schumer’s actions? That is, to what extent can we say that the”blue tsunami” is “Schumer’s success”?
First of all, I think it was far more a red undertow than a blue tsunami. But it still needed to be taken advantage of. If the Midterm result was underwhelming, surely the congressional leadership would be blamed. So why try to bring out the long knives for them when there is an overwhelming success on their watch?
Think of a football manager at the World Cup. Surely, he only has a limited influence on the outcome - you have the players themselves, you have the opposing team, and there is always the element of luck. And yet, it would be bizarre if de la Fuente had been sacked after leading his team to the title.
For example, how many of the winners were endorsed by Schumer? What actions did he take to help those winners win?
Do you mean in the primaries or in the general? In the general he endorsed all of them I am sure. Even those like Abdulrahman El Sayyed (MB-MI) who is himself hostile toward Schumer.
 
It's crazy to me to say "This person refuses to pay their taxes, so we shouldn't tax them." Even if they are a billionaire.
Or the "Democratic" candidate for Senate from Florida ...
‘I Don't Wanna Pay It Back’: Socialist Senate Nominee Angie Nixon Says It's ‘Crazy’ She Has To Pay Her Taxes And Student Loans

And it's not like billionaires are not taxed already. But some people think that billionaires should be taxed out of existence, or (like Angie Nixon) think that only billionaires should be taxed, not people making six figures like her.
 
It's crazy to me to say "This person refuses to pay their taxes, so we shouldn't tax them." Even if they are a billionaire.
Or the "Democratic" candidate for Senate from Florida ...
‘I Don't Wanna Pay It Back’: Socialist Senate Nominee Angie Nixon Says It's ‘Crazy’ She Has To Pay Her Taxes And Student Loans

And it's not like billionaires are not taxed already. But some people think that billionaires should be taxed out of existence, or (like Angie Nixon) think that only billionaires should be taxed, not people making six figures like her.
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.

I genuinely believe that much or most student debt should be wiped out/written off. We have steadily been paying a shrinking share of the cost of public education, from pre-K through university.
 
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year - at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill. From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
 
[Left wing economist Gabriel] Zucman blames the corrosive influence of money for Prop 40's failure.

"I am not surprised," Zucman says. Opponents of Prop 40 spent almost $400 million fighting it, including spending on competing ballot measures, making it one of the most expensive ballot initiative fights in history.
It could not possibly have anything to do with wealth taxes being a bad idea in general, and this bill being especially poorly written even by wealth tax standards.
"The money spent by the billionaires was critical," Zucman says. "Anyone who lives in California has been carpet-bombed by a deluge of ads. One can easily see how this could be pivotal in such a closely contested ballot."
Everybody who has lived anywhere with competitive races has been deluged by political ads from both sides.
Zipr himself said:
Many people will vote against any tax increase no matter who it would apply to.
That is true. California has high state taxes, but also one that has the ballot initiative system that lets people pass laws directly regardless of consequences. So they have passed a freeze on property taxes which means that people who have lived in their houses for decades contribute very little to the property tax base of a community.
I think fixing issues like that would be far more beneficial to California than gimmicky things like a one-time wealth tax.
But what you did not quote from that article:
NPR said:
But Prop 40 didn't come with the same clear partisan signal. In fact, prominent Democrats, including California Gov. Gavin Newsom, came out against it. Newsom said he favored a national minimum tax on billionaires instead.
[...]
More moderate Democratic voters, especially in affluent areas like the Bay Area, may simply dislike this novel way of taxing rich people in America and the consequences it could have. After all, this policy idea has divided Democrats before. During the 2020 presidential primary, Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders both championed wealth taxes, but rivals like Sen. Cory Booker and Michael Bloomberg opposed them. Joe Biden said he didn't oppose a wealth tax on the campaign trail, but early in his presidency, he declined to pursue Sen. Warren's wealth tax proposal.
Or maybe voters weren't rejecting the idea of a wealth tax per se. Maybe they were rejecting the particulars of this wealth tax.
For one thing, Prop 40 was a one-time tax, and it earmarked its projected revenue in ways that drew opposition from traditional Democratic allies. It allocated 90% of the revenue to health care, leaving only 10% for food assistance and education-related programs.
That helped put some typically left-leaning organizations in the opposition camp. For example, the California Teachers Association, a powerful teachers union. It argued that Prop 40 shortchanged public schools and did "not provide the sustainable and long-lasting funding that our schools and communities deserve."
The opposition to Prop 40 did not break neatly along party or ideological lines.
back to Zipr said:
It's hard to do so we should not do it. There's that American spirit. (y)
I did not say that. But too many (like Sanders for example) are treating it as an easy solution with no drawbacks when it's anything but.
The reason we Americans pay more for healthcare is not just our convoluted system of payers, public and private. It's also that doctors (especially certain specialists) and hospital administrators make so much more than in other developed countries. So we need to work on how medical services are billed as well, which will of course be very unpopular with AMA and such, but necessary if overall costs are to be reduced. But I do not think that something like NHS or even gesetzliche Krankenversicherung in Germany would be viable if e.g. a psychiatrist there can make $700k mostly doing 10 minute SSRI refill appointments over Zoom and charging hundreds of dollars to insurance for each of them. And yes, that is what is happening in the US.
 
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year -
Why does the Left love to compute income taxes as percentage of wealth and not income. They are called income taxes for a reason.
at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill.
Six figures of income, not wealth. Why are you conflating dissimilar things?
From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
She and her husband have rental properties and businesses. They are doing fine. They just don't want to pay their fair share of taxes, nor pay back their debts.
 
And it's not like billionaires are not taxed already. But some people think that billionaires should be taxed out of existence, or (like Angie Nixon) think that only billionaires should be taxed, not people making six figures like her.
Do you have a citation for Ms Nixon saying that only billionaires should be taxes?
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Perhaps we don't, although there is this false idea that persists that billionaires pay no (or hardly any) taxes.
Wealth taxes are also a bad way to do that. Higher tax brackets and fewer loopholes would be a better idea.
There is also far too few billionaires for hyperfocus on them to be effective in increasing tax revenues in any meaningful way. I do not see why people like Nixon should not pay her own fair share just because she doesn't make "105 billion" as she puts it.
I genuinely believe that much or most student debt should be wiped out/written off. We have steadily been paying a shrinking share of the cost of public education, from pre-K through university.
While I do think we should invest more in education, I think much of the money we already invest is wasted. US does spend a lot on all levels of education, but we spend it in a very inefficient way, although that is a discussion for a different thread.
I also disagree that most student loans should be forgiven, especially for those who make enough to pay it back, like Nixon herself. She is just an entitled person who thinks rules should not apply to her.

I am very glad she lost, but dismayed that it was as close as it was, and that she will probably try again in 2028.
 
Do you have a citation for Ms Nixon saying that only billionaires should be taxes?
"Should be taxes"?

Anyway, she certainly implied it. From the article:
Angie Nixon said:
And listen, I ain't made $105 billion, but you making me pay $12,000 to the feds? Like, really? That's what we're doing? And they already took some of the taxes away anyway. I paid over $10,000. It's just, it is crazy.
Is that really the type of person Democrats want in the US Senate, and not somebody like Alex Vindman?
 
Think of a football manager at the World Cup. Surely, he only has a limited influence on the outcome - you have the players themselves, you have the opposing team, and there is always the element of luck. And yet, it would be bizarre if de la Fuente had been sacked after leading his team to the title.


That is still a general statement and not specific actions by Schumer.
For example, how many of the winners were endorsed by Schumer? What actions did he take to help those winners win?
Do you mean in the primaries or in the general? In the general he endorsed all of them I am sure. Even those like Abdulrahman El Sayyed (MB-MI) who is himself hostile toward Schumer.
My understanding is that he endorsed multiple candidates in the primaries that lost. Endorsing the Democrat candidate in the general election is the bare minimum a democratic leader should do.

I’m just trying to understand the supposed greatness of Schumer that makes him not deserve any challengers for leader.
 
Back
Top Bottom