• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

Why does the Left love to compute income taxes as percentage of wealth and not income. They are called income taxes for a reason.
Because wealth disparity is the problem that income taxes, as currently interpreted, are blatantly and obviously failing to alleviate. There's a cancer at the top of our economic ladder, draining the entire system dry and contributing next to nothing to society for our pains.
You know perfectly well that economics is not a zero sum game, yet in your economic reasoning you blithely take for granted that it is. Psychiatrists call this "double bookkeeping"; progressives seem peculiarly susceptible to it.

To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars. That's not "contributing next to nothing to society". That's contributing something worth more billions to society than the billionaires received. The trades were voluntary; if both parties didn't benefit then one of them wouldn't have volunteered. Mutually beneficial trades do not "drain the entire system dry"; mutually beneficial trades are what made the entire system un-dry in the first place.

Or it means people didn't pay you billions of dollars, so you don't have billions of dollars -- you just have something that didn't exist until you caused it to exist, and "multibillionaire" is a measurement only of how much other people want what you caused to exist. It's hypothetical billions -- billions you would receive if you counterfactually agreed to sell your stuff. Entire systems are not "drained dry" by hypothetical trades and by people wanting your stuff more than they used to.

Or it means some other multibillionaire voluntarily decided to gift you his billions of dollars or gift you his stuff other people wish was theirs. That contributes next to nothing, true, but it also doesn't drain any system dry; everybody else is just as un-dry as he was before. Actually, less dry, usually, since the community as a whole typically takes a cut in inheritance taxes.

Or it means you took billions of dollars by force, or got people to give you the money by lying to them about what you were giving them in return. That really is a cancer draining the entire system dry and contributing nothing; if you think that's how those at the top of our economic ladder became multibillionaires, show your work.

People die on the streets, just so these forty assholes can watch imaginary numbers get bigger on their money managers' screen every so often.
Taking private property rights seriously is what drove the rate of people dying on the streets to its current historic low. If we choose to confiscate someone's property for no better reason than because somebody else wants it and forty million assholes deliberately deceive themselves into thinking taking it away from him is the way to save other people from dying on the streets, choices become habits become character. In societies run by people with that character a lot more people die on the streets.

<expletive deleted> these people. They wouldn't spit on your grave to put out a fire, don't suck their dick for free. You owe nothing to them and they don't give a <expletive deleted> about you.
The difference between you and the antisemites is that they feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of, whereas you, in contrast, feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of.
 
Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
Zionism means supporting the right of Israel to exist.
Bullshit. Zionism means God gave Israel to the Jews and the Jews only.

Anti-zionists want to abolish Israel and replace it with yet another Arab, Muslim state.
Again, bullshit.
Do you have some rational reason to think that the Palestinians will not do exactly what they have promised to do repeatedly: genocide? What they have done since long before 1948--Jews would be attacked for not accepting subservient status. You're telling the battered woman to just go back to her husband, it will be fine.
 
Why does the Left love to compute income taxes as percentage of wealth and not income. They are called income taxes for a reason.
Because wealth disparity is the problem that income taxes, as currently interpreted, are blatantly and obviously failing to alleviate. There's a cancer at the top of our economic ladder, draining the entire system dry and contributing next to nothing to society for our pains.
You know perfectly well that economics is not a zero sum game, yet in your economic reasoning you blithely take for granted that it is.
That is certainly news to me. I'm not even sure what you mean, and I certainly do not recognize it as any claim I have made.

To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars.
Nonsense. No one becomes a billionaire because of individual exchanges of labor for pay. The very idea is nonsensical. Extreme wealth can only be generated by seizing vast pools of existing capital and institutional control over capital investments, monetary production, and the means of exchange and production. Jensen Huang didn't personally make graphics cards. He doesn't even know how. Even his company does not, for the most part. They create and sell technology, as a corporate (communal) entity that contracts with other companies to facilitate production of graphics cards and now other related technologies, drawing investor interest by incorporating them into new spheres. None of this requires Jensen Huang the person, nor any of his labor. He occupied a corporate office, which is now occupied by another. But he gets to keep his billions. Madison Huang will also be a billionaire before she dies. Why? Because she is Jensen Huang's daughter. She is not a skilled manager, engineer, or tradesman. She's Jensen Huang's daughter. A leech, in short. But you're panicking at the thought that she might have to pay taxes on the wealth she inherits? Why? Why does she have any more claim on those billions than anyone else? And what could she possibly need them for, that her present millions cannot provide her?

I note that Huang himself has never minded paying tax on his wealth, and often says as much.

That's not "contributing next to nothing to society". That's contributing something worth more billions to society than the billionaires received.
They did not contribute the labor, the means, the knowledge, the land, or the product. They just own all of the above. That is very much the problem. The connection between their person, the activities, and their value isn't just thin, it's actively deceptive.

The trades were voluntary; if both parties didn't benefit then one of them wouldn't have volunteered. Mutually beneficial trades do not "drain the entire system dry"; mutually beneficial trades are what made the entire system un-dry in the first place.
That would only be true if all of these exchanges were voluntary and mutually beneficial. Gaming the legislative system to avoid paying tax is neither.

Or it means you took billions of dollars by force, or got people to give you the money by lying to them about what you were giving them in return.
There is no other way to seize control of billions of dollars.

Taking private property rights seriously is what drove the rate of people dying on the streets to its current historic low.
Holding billionaires to the same standards as other citizens is respecting private property rights.

The difference between you and the antisemites is that they feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of, whereas you, in contrast, feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of.
You fucking serious? You think some rich asshole having to pay taxes once a year is a crime equivalent to genocide? Jesus Christ, you must drink nothing bit Koolaid (tm) from morning til night. Stop worshipping these people. Inconveniencing someone does not become a dire crime just because someone is powerful. They don't deserve your adoration, and you shouldn't be so willing to give it.
 
Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
Zionism means supporting the right of Israel to exist.
Bullshit. Zionism means God gave Israel to the Jews and the Jews only.

Anti-zionists want to abolish Israel and replace it with yet another Arab, Muslim state.
Again, bullshit.
Do you have some rational reason to think that the Palestinians will not do exactly what they have promised to do repeatedly: genocide?
Palestinians... as in all of them? You seem to be arriving at a Final Solution to the Gaza problem.
What they have done since long before 1948--Jews would be attacked for not accepting subservient status. You're telling the battered woman to just go back to her husband, it will be fine.
Egypt and Jordan stopped.... (after we started giving them money... but they stopped)
 
FIFY. Strictly speaking, anti-Zionists are against Israel existence as a Jewish state.
At least you admit as much. Some on here are really confused about what what antizionists are all about.

It's "replacement" is a separate issue.
The intended replacement is not really up in the air. Just like if you think Ukraine should be abolished as a sovereign state, it's not like it's any mystery who would take over.
While I agree that if Israel is "replaced", it is most likely with a Muslim state, that does not mean anti-zionists necessarily want to replace Israel with a Muslim state. So, your definition was incorrect
We don't live in Burger King.

You don't get to pick your fantasy outcome, you have to look at realistic outcomes and decide which is best. And your fantasy selection will actually be a vote for genocide.
 
That is still a general statement and not specific actions by Schumer.
I don't want to get bogged down in analyzing the minutia of Schumer's (or Jeffries') activities over the last year or so. Suffice to say that they were the congressional leaders presiding over one of the biggest midterm victories in recent history. Wanting to get rid of them because they are not sufficiently ideologically pure for the likes of Abdulrahman in the Senate or Hamawy (disciple of the Blind Sheikh) is more than a little backstabby.
My understanding is that he endorsed multiple candidates in the primaries that lost.
So what? I think both the party and the country would have been better off had more of the moderate Dems had won their primaries.
Endorsing the Democrat candidate in the general election is the bare minimum a democratic leader should do.
I think that should be conditional on Democratic Party being at least a little selective in whom they allow to run in the Democratic primaries in the first place. I do not think DSA candidates should be able to run as Democrats. And most certainly people with terrorism connections like Adam Hamawy should have been excluded from the primaries.
I’m just trying to understand the supposed greatness of Schumer that makes him not deserve any challengers for leader.
I am trying to understand the supposed badness of Schumer that makes him deserve being deposed. Other than him supporting Israel which is anathema to the Hasan Piker caucus.
 
Do you want businesses to pay income tax? Many of them would go broke if that happened.
Businesses do already pay corporate tax.
Note that billionaires aren't financially individuals but operate as incorporated entities.
There is a difference between taxes paid by a business and by an individual, e.g. capital gains tax.
Also those who oppose more tax for billionaires are always, like here, talking about income tax. Not only do ordinary people pay higher income tax than billionaires,
Define "ordinary people"? Long-term capital gains tax is 0% incomes less than almost $50k for singles and almost $100k for marrieds. It goes up to 20% for incomes above $545k for singles and $614k for marrieds.
For income taxes themselves, the tax rate is 12% on incomes up to a bit over $50k (single) or $100k (married) and that counts income above the standard deduction ($16k/$32k) if you are not itemizing.
I definitely think there should be higher brackets for even higher incomes, but it is just not true that the rich pay lower rates than "ordinary people".
I also do not think wealth taxes are the right approach, especially not a one time 5% tax like California tried to implement.
but also pay things like sales tax.
You don't think billionaires pay sales tax?
 
FIFY. Strictly speaking, anti-Zionists are against Israel existence as a Jewish state.
At least you admit as much. Some on here are really confused about what what antizionists are all about.

It's "replacement" is a separate issue.
The intended replacement is not really up in the air. Just like if you think Ukraine should be abolished as a sovereign state, it's not like it's any mystery who would take over.
While I agree that if Israel is "replaced", it is most likely with a Muslim state, that does not mean anti-zionists necessarily want to replace Israel with a Muslim state. So, your definition was incorrect
We don't live in Burger King.

You don't get to pick your fantasy outcome, you have to look at realistic outcomes and decide which is best. And your fantasy selection will actually be a vote for genocide.
Bravo - delusion masquerading as irony.
 
The richest of the rich these days didn’t sell stuff or services in amounts equivalent to their accumulated wealth. They secured capital. Underpaid labor. Got tax breaks that didn’t get passed to consumers or labor. Dumped negative externalities on the commons.

In the case of accumulating investment capital we have worst case scenarios where it is just fraud like Theranos or whatever the fuck it is the Trumps are “selling”.

I know though. As long as you don’t take the stuff at gun point then it is rightfully got. Buyer or laborer beware. Don’t like those Walmart wages? Go work somewhere else. Don’t like the terms and conditions on the VISA or cell phone? I’m sure you can do without. Just go work somewhere else. But don’t try to migrate to find work. We should have the free movement of capital but not labor.
 
Do you have some rational reason to think that the Palestinians will not do exactly what they have promised to do repeatedly: genocide? What they have done since long before 1948--Jews would be attacked for not accepting subservient status. You're telling the battered woman to just go back to her husband, it will be fine.
You are ignorant of history and appear determined to remain so.

What source of information on the history of Palestinian Jews before 1948 do you regularly use? Do you just make it up as you go along or did you buy a line of propaganda and like it so much you kept it?

Hopefully Hakeem Jeffries has a much better grasp of the facts, historical and current, and is capable of much better reasoning than what you keep showing.
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year - at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill. From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
Taxing wealth is a bad idea. I know, I know, a lot of people think it's somehow horrible for people to have a lot of wealth... but a lot of those people also don't understand the difference between income and wealth, and haven't thought it all the way through.
I'd say the people insisting that a class-blind income tax is a fair system, and deny that generational wealth even exists, are the ones who do not understand the difference between wealth and income. There is no universe in which taxing the wealthy and taxing the poor is functionally the same act.
 
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't like the wording "taxing the rich/billionaires". It implies that they are not taxed anyway.
"Taxing the rich/billionaires more" would be more accurate. And I am glad we agree that this can be accomplished without wealth taxes, especially without gimmicky ones like Prop 40.
My biggest issue with uber wealthy is that effectively, laws don’t apply to them, and indeed they and their corporations are able to skirt tax laws and other regulatory laws that apply to mere mortals.
Do they? Famously, Jeff Bezos could not even construct HQ2 in Queens because a certain congresswoman objected.
IMO—No one should be above the law—including politicians and including wealthy people.
Including the likes of Angie Nixon. She should pay her taxes and pay back her student loans. Even if she is not making billions.
My next biggest issue with uber wealthy is that often, they accumulate their wealth through the labor of workers who are under compensated, including lack of meaningful benefits.
That may be true for some businesses, but you'd be hard-pressed to argue that workers for Nvidia, Tesla/Space X or Berkshire Hathaway are underpaid or lack benefits.
Our nation was supposedly founded on the principle that no one is above the law. We need to get back to that.
But Prop 40 was not about people being above the law. It's about creating a novel, one-time tax on people's wealth.
And we need to quit allowing unelected persons to call the shots about anything other than their own personal lives and their corporations plus voting if they are qualified citizens.

Ending Citizens United would be a good step to take.
How do you propose to do that without a constitutional amendment? Or at least without SCOTUS justices willing to overturn the CU precedent? Neither is likely to happen anytime soon.
 
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't like the wording "taxing the rich/billionaires". It implies that they are not taxed anyway.
"Taxing the rich/billionaires more" would be more accurate. And I am glad we agree that this can be accomplished without wealth taxes, especially without gimmicky ones like Prop 40.
My biggest issue with uber wealthy is that effectively, laws don’t apply to them, and indeed they and their corporations are able to skirt tax laws and other regulatory laws that apply to mere mortals.
Do they? Famously, Jeff Bezos could not even construct HQ2 in Queens because a certain congresswoman objected.

He could have built it.

But he wanted the City of New York to build infrastructure to support it and to not have to pay the going rate in taxes on it. He wanted freebies and expected the politicians would offer them up with both hands.

AOC pointed out that Amazon didn't need tax breaks and that the City was facing major expenses just by having one of its warehouses there, so really Amazon was the one that should have been offering concessions to sweeten the deal, not the other way around.
 
While I agree that if Israel is "replaced", it is most likely with a Muslim state, that does not mean anti-zionists necessarily want to replace Israel with a Muslim state. So, your definition was incorrect
Add "tacitly" if it makes you happy, but it doesn't change much practically. It's the same with any anti-Ukrainists: if you want Ukraine to be dissolved as a sovereign state, you at least tacitly support it being taken over by Russia. Antizionism is no different.
Nonsense. In the case of Anti-Zionist it could be extreme optimism, naïveté, or a very long time horizon.
Optimism/naivete--both are countered by an examination of the facts. If someone still holds this position they are being willfully blind.

Long time horizon--what's that got to do with it? Dead Jews would not come back.

(And that ignores the fact that it's asking a nuclear armed country to simply accept execution.)
 
Because wealth disparity is the problem that income taxes, as currently interpreted, are blatantly and obviously failing to alleviate.
There is a reason why most countries that tried a wealth tax abandoned the idea.
One of the reasons that if you tax wealth which is mostly bound in values of their companies, you will force significant stock selloffs in order to pay that tax, which would destabilize the stock market.
There's a cancer at the top of our economic ladder, draining the entire system dry and contributing next to nothing to society for our pains.
That is certainly not true, and is in fact a very naïve view of how the economy works. First, the companies these people started became successful because they fulfilled a genuine need. Tesla made first mainstream viable electric cars (compare with the G-Wizes and EV1s that came before it). Nvidia made the graphics cards people played Halflife and GTA on long before they started selling chips for AI data centers.
Second, it's not like they are not already paying billions in taxes. Even that ProPublica article from a few years ago admits that much.
People die on the streets, just so these forty assholes can watch imaginary numbers get bigger on their money managers' screen every so often. Fuck these people.
How many people are "dying in the streets" and why?
They wouldn't spit on your grave to put out a fire, don't suck their dick for free. You owe nothing to them and they don't give a shit about you.
Nobody is "sucking their dick" except maybe that Chinese spy. I am even supportive of higher income and capital gains brackets.
But wealth taxes are a bad idea, and would need a constitutional amendment to be implemented federally. To get back to the actual topic, wealth tax is a bad litmus test to put on prospective congressional leaders.
 
So no, you don’t, and, no, she didn’t
She most definitely did. Your famous lack of reading comprehension strikes again.
Show your evidence she said only billionaires sh You made the claim she said only billionaires should be taxed. Produce the quote or stop misrepresenting her.

Derec said:
She’s not in the Senate. The national Democrats did little to help her.
She is bound to try again in 2028. This was a special election and there is a redo in two years time.
Trying, getting support from the DNC or the Senate Democrats, and winning are 3 distinctly different outcomes.
 
Your story is inconsistent, then.
Not at all. The point is her attitude, not the particulars of her tax situation. Especially for somebody running for Senate.
Is she rolling in dough and just didn't pay tax; or did she fail to prepare for tax season and could not afford tax?
I do not know if she has the liquid assets to pay her tax debt right away. Even if she failed to plan ahead and set aside money for taxes, the remedy is to set up a payment plan with the IRS. Not complain how it's "crazy" that she has to pay her taxes and debts.
 

I’m just trying to understand the supposed greatness of Schumer that makes him not deserve any challengers for leader.
I am trying to understand the supposed badness of Schumer that makes him deserve being deposed. Other than him supporting Israel which is anathema to the Hasan Piker caucus.
I dont know who “Hasan Piker” is but I do know that Schumer has not come across as a strong leader in the news that I have watched over the past couple of years. I’m not saying he shouldn’t be leader but I also don’t see why he should just automatically be without potential options being presented to the party for a vote. If he wins then he wins, that’s the decision of the other Democratic Senators, who would be in the best position to know his adequacy to the role.
 
Back
Top Bottom