• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Merged Gaza just launched an unprovoked attack on Israel

To denote when two or more threads have been merged
Whether Bilby can think of a better strategy is irrelevant. The fact that nobody has proposed a better strategy that can actually stand up to scrutiny means an awful lot.
Nobody anywhere? Or just nobody on this forum, which we have no reason to believe is filled with experts on the subject. And whose “scrutiny” is relevant here? Yours? I disagree it “means an awful lot”.

I admit I have no expertise on the subject so I admit I have no solution that is good. But I don’t think that means there is no good solution. That would be awful arrogant of me don’t you think?
If somebody had a better answer why have they not said something?

If they are friendly to Israel they'll tell Israel and Israel would act on it. If they're hostile to Israel they would tell the world to embarrass Israel.

This is a case where the dog not barking is very meaningful. While you can argue that some might have a motive to keep quiet the idea that all would makes no sense.
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
I assumed nothing. I suggest there might be less deadly responses that result in similar outcomes.

At least you refrained “Israel will be exterminated “ idiocy.
Consider the "logic" in your response: Your statement reduces to "there may be a better answer, therefore it must be found". This is a variation on assuming your conclusion in your argument.

Hamas has said they intend to kill every Jew. They have crowed about repeating 10/7 again and again. Why do you not believe them?
 
You really are a broken record.
Not a broken record, but some truths are worth repeating to they will maybe get through some thick skulls.
The trouble is, your ability of persuasion isn't particularly that high. The fact you feel the need to insult people you are trying to persuade is an indication that your attempts of spreading truths will fail, regardless how accurate your claims are.

The truth is, you have zero appreciation for how a 20 to 30 year old sees the Israel/Gaza relationship. People that have only been aware of it for the 2 to 10 years. Instead of young people that are in need of having additional context provided regarding the history and complexity of the situation, you judge them as thick skulled idiots. Worse yet, your approach will galvanize their naive to undereducated positions on the situation. Which will lead to future galvanization and real anti-Semitism becoming more common.

And of course, we also fall to the point where your position on Israel/Gaza is reactionary in its own right and show zero willingness to look at the problem more broadly to understand the human aspect of it.
How people see it doesn't change the facts on the ground.
That is the dumbest thing you've ever said. Perception is critical. Perception is impacted by history and knowledge, but mostly the stuff that one has noticed while they are alive. Younger people have a much different perspective on Israel because all they've known is Netanyahu controlled Israel. People who are turning 20 were born years after the wave of suicide bombings.

If you think that isn't important to breaking through the misguided positions younger people are likely to have on Israel, you really should just step away.
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
I assumed nothing. I suggest there might be less deadly responses that result in similar outcomes.

At least you refrained “Israel will be exterminated “ idiocy.
Consider the "logic" in your response: Your statement reduces to "there may be a better answer, therefore it must be found". This is a variation on assuming your conclusion in your argument.
Whether or not a better solution is possible or feasible is determined by thought and experiment, not kneejerk denials.
Hamas has said they intend to kill every Jew. They have crowed about repeating 10/7 again and again. Why do you not believe them?
It is not a matter of belief. It is a matter of capability. They are nowhere close to such a capability at this time or the near future. Plenty of time to try to change or moderate their attitude without killing magnitudes of civilians. I realize those civilians are not Israelis, but they are humans, many are children. And before you respond with your automatic "that means genocide of Jews" - it most certainly does not. Nor does it mean no defense.

Besides the only way to completely squash Hamas from achieving their stated goal is to kill all member of Hamas - present and future. In other words, genocide.
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
I assumed nothing. I suggest there might be less deadly responses that result in similar outcomes.

At least you refrained “Israel will be exterminated “ idiocy.
Consider the "logic" in your response: Your statement reduces to "there may be a better answer, therefore it must be found". This is a variation on assuming your conclusion in your argument.

Hamas has said they intend to kill every Jew. They have crowed about repeating 10/7 again and again. Why do you not believe them?
Wrong thread, guys.
 
Settler attacks suspected as five West Bank villages hit with arson overnight

Yashar party leader Gadi Eisenkot condemned the overnight arson attacks, calling them "Jewish terrorism" and warning that extremist groups setting fire to vehicles and homes were pushing the West Bank toward "anarchy."
"The night of arson attacks in the West Bank constitutes Jewish terrorism in every sense of the word, and should be called what it is," he said.

He blamed National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich for the deteriorating situation, and called on the government and security forces to use all available means, including administrative detention and targeted Shin Bet operations, to arrest the perpetrators and impose severe sanctions.
Democrats chairman Yair Golan and Together co-leader Yair Lapid condemned the attacks, describing them as "Jewish terror."

Joint List chairman Yousef Jabarin condemned the attacks and their perpetrators, calling them the "military wing of Otzma Yehudit and the Religious Zionism party."

Terrorism has begat terrorism.

At least people are calling out Ben-Gvir and Smotrich for their contributions to the violence.
 
Settler attacks suspected as five West Bank villages hit with arson overnight

Yashar party leader Gadi Eisenkot condemned the overnight arson attacks, calling them "Jewish terrorism" and warning that extremist groups setting fire to vehicles and homes were pushing the West Bank toward "anarchy."
"The night of arson attacks in the West Bank constitutes Jewish terrorism in every sense of the word, and should be called what it is," he said.

He blamed National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich for the deteriorating situation, and called on the government and security forces to use all available means, including administrative detention and targeted Shin Bet operations, to arrest the perpetrators and impose severe sanctions.
Democrats chairman Yair Golan and Together co-leader Yair Lapid condemned the attacks, describing them as "Jewish terror."

Joint List chairman Yousef Jabarin condemned the attacks and their perpetrators, calling them the "military wing of Otzma Yehudit and the Religious Zionism party."

Terrorism has begat terrorism.

At least people are calling out Ben-Gvir and Smotrich for their contributions to the violence.
Would it be fair to call Gadi Eisenkot an antisemite then?
 
Settler attacks suspected as five West Bank villages hit with arson overnight

Yashar party leader Gadi Eisenkot condemned the overnight arson attacks, calling them "Jewish terrorism" and warning that extremist groups setting fire to vehicles and homes were pushing the West Bank toward "anarchy."
"The night of arson attacks in the West Bank constitutes Jewish terrorism in every sense of the word, and should be called what it is," he said.

He blamed National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich for the deteriorating situation, and called on the government and security forces to use all available means, including administrative detention and targeted Shin Bet operations, to arrest the perpetrators and impose severe sanctions.
Democrats chairman Yair Golan and Together co-leader Yair Lapid condemned the attacks, describing them as "Jewish terror."

Joint List chairman Yousef Jabarin condemned the attacks and their perpetrators, calling them the "military wing of Otzma Yehudit and the Religious Zionism party."

Terrorism has begat terrorism.

At least people are calling out Ben-Gvir and Smotrich for their contributions to the violence.
Would it be fair to call Gadi Eisenkot an antisemite then?
He's certainly not part of the solution. He's the guy who initially penned the IDF doctrine of collective punishment and all civilian targets are fair game.
 
He's certainly not part of the solution.
Then he must be part of the precipitate.
He's the guy who initially penned the IDF doctrine of collective punishment and all civilian targets are fair game.
[Citation needed]
Ostensibly "civilian" targets are fair game when used for a military purpose. For example when Islamic Jihad terrorists use a truck marked with a World Central Kitchen logo.
IDF identifies three PIJ terrorists targeted in Gaza, disputes claims they were aid workers
Jerusalem Post said:
The IDF on Sunday revealed the terrorist backgrounds of three Gazans it targeted on Saturday. Gaza’s Hamas authorities had tried to portray them as humanitarian aid workers.
Two of the individuals never served in an aid capacity and were members of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, The Jerusalem Post has learned.
A third PIJ operative had previously served with a “dual-hat” as both an aid worker and a terrorist, but he was expelled from his aid position after Israel exposed his terrorist activities.
[...]
According to foreign reports, the “aid workers” were affiliated with the World Central Kitchen, because the truck that was struck and some of the food in the truck bore the WCK logo. The WCK, however, denied that the workers were currently affiliated with it.
But of course, media outlets, including Haaretz, initially ran with "IDF kills air workers" story without verifying Palestinian claims. :rolleyesa:

These terrorist tactics put real aid workers at risk. If you cannot trust markings on a battlefield to be accurate, they lose much of their meaning.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom