• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

I am not familiar with this case and I would have to look into it more deeply before commenting on it as I will not assume that you are providing a thorough enough and unbiased summary for me to properly assess.
This the Kate Steinle case. It was highly publicized in the Bay Area...which is (I believe) where you live, IIRC.
 
Last edited:
I am not familiar with this case and I would have to look into it more deeply before commenting on it as I will not assume that you are providing a thorough enough and unbiased summary for me to properly assess.
This the Kate Steinle case. It was highly publicized in the Bay Area...which is (I believe) where you live, IIRC.
It is possible that I can live here and still not know this case.

I don’t have the capacity to stay abreast of the important news in the same manner as Derec.
 
I am not familiar with this case and I would have to look into it more deeply before commenting on it as I will not assume that you are providing a thorough enough and unbiased summary for me to properly assess.
This the Kate Steinle case. It was highly publicized in the Bay Area...which is (I believe) where you live, IIRC.
The most important thing to note from that Wikipedia article is that both the Prosecution and Defense agreed that the bullet ricocheted, so it was impossible for the bullet to have been intentionally aimed to hit the woman (plus of course he had no motive, and it would be stupid to do this with witnesses present). Of course, a person's immigration/citizenship status shouldn't make a difference in how they are judged.
 
I am not familiar with this case and I would have to look into it more deeply before commenting on it as I will not assume that you are providing a thorough enough and unbiased summary for me to properly assess.
This the Kate Steinle case. It was highly publicized in the Bay Area...which is (I believe) where you live, IIRC.
The most important thing to note from that Wikipedia article is that both the Prosecution and Defense agreed that the bullet ricocheted, so it was impossible for the bullet to have been intentionally aimed to hit the woman (plus of course he had no motive, and it would be stupid to do this with witnesses present). Of course, a person's immigration/citizenship status shouldn't make a difference in how they are judged.
Based solely on the Wikipedia article I just read, I am assuming the part that Derec finds objectionable would be this:

The Department of Justice unsealed a federal arrest warrant for García Zárate following his trial. The charges include felon in possession of a firearm, involuntary manslaughter, and assault with a deadly weapon.

Is the assumption that SF’s “sanctuary city” laws prevented this information from being given to the jury during the trial? The Wikipedia article doesn’t give enough information to know why the unsealing was done after the trial. Presumably, the prosecution wouldn’t have known about this during the trial, unless I am misunderstanding what “unsealed” means.

Also, a warrant is not a conviction, so we would need to know the details of that case too. And should a warrant have changed the facts the jury deliberated on in this case?

Presumably, had the jury known of this warrant it could have changed their opinions and made it more likely to convict, but without knowing how they deliberated we cannot know for sure.

Perhaps there is more direct evidence Derec can provide that shows how the “sanctuary city” laws specifically led to a miscarriage of justice here.
 
I am not familiar with this case and I would have to look into it more deeply before commenting on it as I will not assume that you are providing a thorough enough and unbiased summary for me to properly assess.
This the Kate Steinle case. It was highly publicized in the Bay Area...which is (I believe) where you live, IIRC.
The most important thing to note from that Wikipedia article is that both the Prosecution and Defense agreed that the bullet ricocheted, so it was impossible for the bullet to have been intentionally aimed to hit the woman (plus of course he had no motive, and it would be stupid to do this with witnesses present). Of course, a person's immigration/citizenship status shouldn't make a difference in how they are judged.
You are correct about the ricochete...he didn't intentionally set out to kill her. Still, there are supposed to be consequences to killing someone through your own recklessness. Something seems pretty fucked up here:

On November 30, 2017, after five days of deliberations, a jury acquitted García Zárate of all murder and manslaughter charges, and federal manslaughter and assault charges were dropped due to lack of evidence. He was convicted of being a felon in possession of a firearm, but that conviction was overturned on appeal on August 30, 2019.[2]
 
Perhaps there is more direct evidence Derec can provide that shows how the “sanctuary city” laws specifically led to a miscarriage of justice here.
The miscarraige of justice started before Kate was killed. Rather than detain him so he could be picked up by immigration authorities, SF released him under their sanctuary city policies:

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) had issued a detainer for García Zárate requesting that he be kept in custody until immigration authorities could pick him up. However, as a sanctuary city, San Francisco's "Due Process for All" ordinance[25] restricted cooperation with ICE to only cases where the immigrant had both current violent felony charges and past violent felony convictions; therefore, San Francisco disregarded the detainer and released him.[26][27] He was released from San Francisco County Jail on April 15, 2015, and had no outstanding warrants or judicial warrants, as confirmed by the San Francisco Sheriff's Department.[21]
 
I think that destroying value just so you can stick it to people wealthier than you think they should be allowed to be is an ideology built on envy.
Taxing redistributes value but does not necessarily destroy it. Taxing wealth has advantages and disadvantages. Whether it is a good or bad idea depends on the details and one's values.
All such schemes end up being about tearing down those above. And if you hand out the money to the people you just get inflation, coupled with an unwillingness to invest in new things.
5% of a billionaire's wealth is tearing them down? Stop sucking the wealthie's dicks. They don't give a shit about you.
 
Last edited:
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
Who wants to bring down Walmart? I’d like to see Walmart be much more responsible with their labor practices and to lay the hell off demanding tax abatements while demanding access roads and utilities be installed at taxpayer expense. To provide cheap goods and drive local small businesses out of business. But hey—They can go work for Walmart and earn $7.50/hr no benefits, part time hours at employer’s pleasure so don’t go thinking you can fill in the gaps with another part time job. Oh, and you get to come to ‘tread meetings’ where you pledge allegiance to Walmart.

I mean—I would not cry if Walmart disappeared. I don’t shop there. But I know plenty of people who do.

No: I want income to be taxed in a more progressive way. I want tax code to be re-written to close loop holes and with higher tiers of income taxed. I want the cap on SS contributions to be raised significantly. I want it to be impossible for uber wealthy people to get tax write offs for personal and company jets, multiple homes, wardrobe and entertainment, etc. Also charitable contributions.
Walmart starting pay here in my small city in Georgia is 15 bucks an hour, not great, but certainly much better than the minimum wage. Plus the girls who work at the small assisted living facility where I volunteer only make 10 bucks an hour. That bothers me much more as their job is much harder and more stressful than most jobs at Walmart. I know the starting pay at Walmart because the son of a close friend of mine works there. He loves his job and was recently promoted to assistant manager of some type. I'm not saying working for Walmart is great, but at least let's get the pay right. My friend works in a shoe store and only makes 18 bucks an hour. She's been working there for about 10 years. She does have some benefits and pays about 400 bucks a month for health insurance. She likes her job, but I think she deserves much more than she gets. I do agree agree that the minimum wage needs to be raised to about 20 an hour, but I don't think anyone makes less than 10 an hour these days.
 
Perhaps there is more direct evidence Derec can provide that shows how the “sanctuary city” laws specifically led to a miscarriage of justice here.
The miscarraige of justice started before Kate was killed. Rather than detain him so he could be picked up by immigration authorities, SF released him under their sanctuary city policies:

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) had issued a detainer for García Zárate requesting that he be kept in custody until immigration authorities could pick him up. However, as a sanctuary city, San Francisco's "Due Process for All" ordinance[25] restricted cooperation with ICE to only cases where the immigrant had both current violent felony charges and past violent felony convictions; therefore, San Francisco disregarded the detainer and released him.[26][27] He was released from San Francisco County Jail on April 15, 2015, and had no outstanding warrants or judicial warrants, as confirmed by the San Francisco Sheriff's Department.[21]
Thank you for providing the additional context.
 
A $100 million dollars is a huge sum for an individual, I agree. But if you are manufacturing cars or rockets that same $100 million becomes almost nothing. With only $100 million capital Musk could not continue with cars or rockets he would be out of business. And that assumes the billionaire (in this case Musk) did not run across state lines to hide everything in another country.

In a previous post you lamented concern for farmers not able to pass their land to their children and I agree with that concern. But how does a wealth tax (which you appear to agree with) destroying an existing and valuable business not do exactly the same thing? Indeed, a wealth tax is exactly the same except reaching the founder of the company (the person who actually produced something valuable to society) instead of his children who did nothing deserving at all.
Wealth taxes need not destroy viable/functioning businesses. Indeed, they usually do not. What I see locally with businesses much smaller but still employing many people is that often, the next generation is not interested in running the family business which is either sold to someone or closes down or is purchased by someone outside of this community—where the profits follow.

I’m not certain why you have such a hard on for poor poor Elon who needs a trillion dollars and all of the government subsidies his endeavors receive.
A PE ratio of 20 would not be unreasonable in valuing a business. Passing it to the next generation at the highest rate thus takes out 10 years of profits. A third of the total.

In hard times, such a business dies.
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
In your example, yeah, it does no harm to WalMart. The only harm would be to future WalMarts where the founder directed more money to personal consumption since he wouldn't be able to pass it on. Think yachts.

But let's look at another big one: Warren Buffet/Berkshire Hathaway. As an investor in Berkshire Hathaway I very much want his philosophy in control. He's stepped down now and passed the torch to one who thinks like he does. Take it away in inheritance, other investors buy it up--and now Wall Street is in control, favoring the short term rather than the long term. I would expect to see half the value destroyed--not just his wealth, but I would expect to see the value of the shares I own halved or more also. I think it should be obvious why I think that would be a bad thing.
 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
He's spending like 1% on elections.
 
I have been wondering about the "buy, borrow, die" schemes and taxing wealth could work.
What is the buy borrow die scheme?
I think he means when billionaires buy an expensive mansion and then borrow against it for their cash flow and daily liquidity. That way they never have to touch any of their company assets or pay income tax. Their loan is completely tax deductable:

    • Buy: Acquire appreciating assets such as stocks, real estate, businesses, or art. Unrealized gains generally are not taxed until the asset is sold. [1, 2, 3]
    • Borrow: Use appreciated assets as collateral for loans—such as a securities-backed line of credit (SBLOC), margin loan, or real estate refinance—to access cash. Because loans are debt rather than income, borrowing typically does not trigger capital gains tax or count as taxable income. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Die: Hold assets until death so heirs receive a step-up in basis (under IRC §1014), resetting the cost basis to fair market value at death and wiping out capital gains tax on lifetime appreciation. Outstanding loans remain obligations of the estate and are paid off using estate funds or pledged assets
I did the math on this a while back, it does not work. You end up paying more in interest than you save in taxes when figured over a generation.
Then why is it such a common practice among the super wealthy? Do you think these people do not have accountants for financial advice? What interest rate and terms did you use to make that calculation? What is your financial educational background?

But there is a related thing that does make sense: they got where they were because their companies were growing rapidly. Anyone whose company is growing like that is better off living on margin loans rather than selling stock.
Or taking a salary that would be subject to a tax rate far higher than any bank loan.

 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
He's spending like 1% on elections.
One percent of what?
 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
He's spending like 1% on elections.
Better that than funding the military or Medicare then.

We aren’t talking about raiding Scrooge mcducks money bin here and making it rain on the rest of us.
 
The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.

I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.

We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.
Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Technicality. Doesn't change the basic issue. He made electric cars a practical option.
Strange. I still see Chevy Volts on the roads around here. Musk did what, again?
 
I think that destroying value just so you can stick it to people wealthier than you think they should be allowed to be is an ideology built on envy.
Taxing redistributes value but does not necessarily destroy it. Taxing wealth has advantages and disadvantages. Whether it is a good or bad idea depends on the details and one's values.
All such schemes end up being about tearing down those above. And if you hand out the money to the people you just get inflation, coupled with an unwillingness to invest in new things.
And when taxes are skewed too far to the bottom and wealth consolidates in too few entities…
 
The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.

I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.

We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.
Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Technicality. Doesn't change the basic issue. He made electric cars a practical option.
Strange. I still see Chevy Volts on the roads around here. Musk did what, again?
Cyber Truck. After the engineers used Musks money, hype, and gubmint subsidies to fix Tesla, the super genius stuck his fingers in and made them build the dumpster.
 
The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.

I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.

We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.
Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Technicality. Doesn't change the basic issue. He made electric cars a practical option.
Strange. I still see Chevy Volts on the roads around here. Musk did what, again?
Cyber Truck. After the engineers used Musks money, hype, and gubmint subsidies to fix Tesla, the super genius stuck his fingers in and made them build the dumpster.
The Pinto, the Pacer, and the Gremlin were all in production longer than the Cyber Truck.
 
Back
Top Bottom