• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't see anyone objecting to this. What's being objected to is a wealth tax--that is, a tax on current assets.

And, honestly, I doubt we even need to. Undo the Republican damage and see where things stand, whether we need to go farther.

(And note that the idea of a one-time wealth tax is even more onerous. Such things are never one time.)
There’s no reason a wealth tax should be one time.

Regular Americans pay wealth tax on their homes: ie property tax. For most Americans fortunate enough to own homes, they pay it directly. For those who re t: they pay property tax in their rent, which the owner of the dwelling must pay.

Musk, I believe is supposedly worth over $1Trillion. If he had to pay a wealth tax of 99%, he’d still have over a hundred million dollars worth of wealth. I’m finding it difficult to feel sorry for him. But then I’m not proposing that we tax him or anyone at 99%.

But I am saying that we have really gone off the rails by allowing anyone to accumulate that much personal wealth. At that level of wealth, rules effectively do not apply to them. Even if we applied rules as even handed as possible to everyone, the uber wealthy can afford many teams of lawyers to delay judgements.

A tax deferred is a tax not paid. Same with a judgement or fine. Fines, penalties that would cripple ordinary multimillionaires are effectively meaningless to someone like Musk.
A $100 million dollars is a huge sum for an individual, I agree. But if you are manufacturing cars or rockets that same $100 million becomes almost nothing. With only $100 million capital Musk could not continue with cars or rockets he would be out of business. And that assumes the billionaire (in this case Musk) did not run across state lines to hide everything in another country.

In a previous post you lamented concern for farmers not able to pass their land to their children and I agree with that concern. But how does a wealth tax (which you appear to agree with) destroying an existing and valuable business not do exactly the same thing? Indeed, a wealth tax is exactly the same except reaching the founder of the company (the person who actually produced something valuable to society) instead of his children who did nothing deserving at all.
Wealth taxes need not destroy viable/functioning businesses. Indeed, they usually do not. What I see locally with businesses much smaller but still employing many people is that often, the next generation is not interested in running the family business which is either sold to someone or closes down or is purchased by someone outside of this community—where the profits follow.

I’m not certain why you have such a hard on for poor poor Elon who needs a trillion dollars and all of the government subsidies his endeavors receive.
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
 
I've never met an actual economist quite so hard on the idea of keeping wealth in circulation. Money spent on luxuries is something they normally BEG the public to provide at this time of year. Unmovement, not movement, is the bane of a healthy economic system. To have only 250 households financially solvent enough to spend on the occasional luxury is not a prudent system, it's the prelude to a collapse.
 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
 
I'm aware. I'm also aware that my biological dad and my grandpa both nearly lost their completely paid off houses because of property taxes. They owned the homes outright, but the property taxes were raised significantly, and the counties threatened to seize their homes because they couldn't pay the taxes on them.

I'm also aware that estate taxes have resulted in people being forced to sell of heirlooms and property in order to pay the taxes, because the value of the estate is based on illiquid estimates of market value rather than actual money.
I've already proposed my answer for property taxes. For estate taxes: not only are there the cases you're talking about, but a family business that keeps being passed down the generations will have to pay a substantial portion of it's profits as estate tax. Thus my proposal, similar to what I suggested for property tax. When estate tax hits intergenerational transfers that which can't readily be divided, or will lose value by being divided (say, the share of the family business) you compute the estate tax, convert it to a percentage and apply it as a lien against the asset in question. In the case of family business entities and the like this also applies to any sale to another beneficiary even if it's not passed by inheritance (4 kids inherit the family business, 3 buy out the 4th, that transaction doesn't trigger the lien.) Should an asset end up with multiple such liens only the highest percentage one is kept. This protection exists only for active businesses, not any sort of holding company (but neither does a holding company preclude applying it to that which is held--it's treated as pass through.)
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
Who wants to bring down Walmart? I’d like to see Walmart be much more responsible with their labor practices and to lay the hell off demanding tax abatements while demanding access roads and utilities be installed at taxpayer expense. To provide cheap goods and drive local small businesses out of business. But hey—They can go work for Walmart and earn $7.50/hr no benefits, part time hours at employer’s pleasure so don’t go thinking you can fill in the gaps with another part time job. Oh, and you get to come to ‘tread meetings’ where you pledge allegiance to Walmart.

I mean—I would not cry if Walmart disappeared. I don’t shop there. But I know plenty of people who do.

No: I want income to be taxed in a more progressive way. I want tax code to be re-written to close loop holes and with higher tiers of income taxed. I want the cap on SS contributions to be raised significantly. I want it to be impossible for uber wealthy people to get tax write offs for personal and company jets, multiple homes, wardrobe and entertainment, etc. Also charitable contributions.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
According to New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, estate tax is not a wealth tax; it's a tax on the privilege of transferring your property at death. That's why it isn't a direct unapportioned tax, which would have made it unconstitutional.
 
I was comparing you to that sick two-thousand-year history of irrational ideologically-driven discrimination, blood libel, despoiling, forced conversions, and driving them out of country after country.
Which is both disingenous and despicable, thereby making your complaints ironical.
:consternation2:
Hey man, I totally get why you think what I said is despicable -- it's entirely predictable and in character for a left-winger to despise me for applying logic and the same moral standard to an attack on his outgroup that would apply to an attack on his ingroup. Outgroups are like children: it's different when they're yours. But why on earth do you think what I said is disingenuous? :confused2:
 
Show your evidence she said only billionaires sh You made the claim she said only billionaires should be taxed. Produce the quote or stop misrepresenting her.
You know the quote. Your problem is not finding the quote, but that you only seem capable of surface level reading. At least when it benefits your apologetics. Saying that it is "crazy" that she has to pay taxes (and student loans) because she is not making billions of dollars is implying that only billionaires should be taxed. Just because she did not say verbatim does not mean that it is not a corollary of what she said.
Trying, getting support from the DNC or the Senate Democrats, and winning are 3 distinctly different outcomes.
Nobody said otherwise. But she will surely try again, and will have a more left-wing, more DSA and Hasan Piker infiltrated Democratic Party behind her.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
According to New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, estate tax is not a wealth tax; it's a tax on the privilege of transferring your property at death. That's why it isn't a direct unapportioned tax, which would have made it unconstitutional.
It is a percentage of wealth which logically makes it a tax on wealth.
 
I dont know who “Hasan Piker”
He is a popular far left content creator who thinks US deserved 9/11 terrorist attacks and who supports Hamas. He has campaigned with many Dems including some newly elected ones like Abdulrahman El Sayed (MB-MI).
HSIXhD0XUAoG7qJ

It is the Hasan Piker caucus who finds Schumer and any other Dems who support Israel an anathema.

is but I do know that Schumer has not come across as a strong leader in the news that I have watched over the past couple of years.
Over the past couple of years Schumer had been in a solid minority (47-53). Between 2021-2025 he has been the Majority Leader, but with a very thin majority (50-50 in the 117th Congress, 51-49 in the 118th). Nevertheless he did manage to pass a lot of Biden's spending agenda, even if the full Spendapalooza was (heroically) blocked by Manchin and Sinema.
120th Congress will be the first time Dems have a solid majority in the Senate in a decade, since the 113th Congress (55-45).
I’m not saying he shouldn’t be leader but I also don’t see why he should just automatically be without potential options being presented to the party for a vote. If he wins then he wins, that’s the decision of the other Democratic Senators, who would be in the best position to know his adequacy to the role.
The problem is that there are now more radicals in the Senate. People like Abdulrahman (probably the most prominent member of the Hasan Piker caucus) and Flannagan to join the likes of Sanders.
 
Show your evidence she said only billionaires sh You made the claim she said only billionaires should be taxed. Produce the quote or stop misrepresenting her.
You know the quote. Your problem is not finding the quote, but that you only seem capable of surface level reading. At least when it benefits your apologetics. Saying that it is "crazy" that she has to pay taxes (and student loans) because she is not making billions of dollars is implying that only billionaires should be taxed.

Apparently you don't know the quote. Here it is
"And listen, I ain't made $105 billion, but you making me pay $12,000 to the feds? Like, really? That's what we're doing? And they already took some of the taxes away anyway. I paid over $10,000. It's just, it is crazy."
She is not saying she shouldn't pay any taxes. She is literally complaining about the amount she is liable for. To an unbigoteddl literate reader, she is complaining that she is not rich enough to pay that level of taxes.
Just because she did not say verbatim does not mean that it is not a corollary of what she said.
Because she did not say it verbatim, then, by definition, she did not say it at all. Your interpretation is an unnatural extension of her words, so it is not a corollary, but a falsehood.

Ms Nixon is a poor enough candidate without anyone having to impute falsehoods about her position.
 
Last edited:
There is evidence that musk overstayed his visa and worked without legal authorization. You can look it up or I can paste it in here but it would be a longer post.
Or since you are making the claim that there is such evidence, perhaps you could provide such evidence.
And explain why overstaying a student visa to start a business is a worse offense than people who have a felony record and have been deported previously crossing the border illegally (and then being protected by sanctuary cities).

Again, while Trump's ICE certainly overreached, there is a legitimate concern with illegal immigration that helped Trump get elected both times. And yet, it looks increasingly like Dems want to overreach themselves on this issue, and others.
In 2020 Dem presidential candidates were in a sort of competition over who would be more supportive of illegals. I think it is only COVID that prevented Trump from being reelected in a landslide, because those 2019 debates were embarrassing.
No. I think those who commit crimes should be charged by the appropriate legal authorities.
Except that we have "legal authorities" that shield illegals, including criminal illegals, from consequences.
But I also understand that this is a complicated situation in which federal authorities have harassed non-criminals in certain ways and it is not clear to me that state or municipal law enforcement necessarily need to be required to assist the feds.
You either have local law enforcement assist the feds in apprehending wanted illegals, or ICE itself needs to conduct raids and other operations. Neither solution is perfect, but I think the former is preferable. Unfortunately, it has become anathema among Dem run cities to render any assistance in immigration enforcement.
And it goes even beyond not rendering assistance, and into actively obstructing.
So, while I believe that criminals should not be “protected” I also understand the basis for some of rhe decisions by certain cities.
Do you think e.g. San Francisco acted appropriately in the case of García Zárate? He entered US illegally and became involved in heroin trafficking, for which he was convicted and deported repeatedly. And reentering the US after previous deportation is an additional felony.
In 2015 (Obama was president then, mind you) García Zárate was caught crossing the border illegally and placed in federal custody. San Francisco requested him for prosecution on a drug charge, but instead of returning him to the feds, being a sanctuary city, they released him.
That's when he found a gun and killed an innocent woman with it. A SF jury let him get away with murder, but that's another issue. He never should have been released in the first place.
I think that is the feds operated in professional, good faith manners, which they often have not, especially under the current administration, there would be little to no need for these so-called “sanctuary cities”.
Sanctuary cities existed well before Trump descended that escalator. The failed immigration system and Republicans like ¡Jeb! "illegal immigration is an act of love" Bush are a big part of why Trump was able to win in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Do you think we should have sanctuary cities that protect criminal illegals?
Do you realize that overstaying a visa or otherwise being in the US without authorization is a misdemeanor?
And reentering upon previous deportation is a felony. Those illegals are protected by sanctuary cities as well, as are illegals committing additional crimes such as drug trafficking. See José Inez García Zárate, a felonious illegal whom San Francisco protected from deportation, and whom SF Public Defender's Office still calls an innocent man.
 
Very few are prosecuted. Even those who are either avoid prison time or receive much more minor sentences. Trump, for instance, has faced zero penalties despite his 34 felony convictions.
Nobody else would even have been prosecuted for something like this, much less for 34 felonies. And note that this DA, Alvin Bragg, is known for downgrading clear felonies (such as armed robberies) into misdemeanors (like petit theft), but in this case he did the exact opposite - he took a clear misdemeanor and used questionable legal maneuvering to elevate it into 34 felonies.

It is funny that the same tactics that are generally rightly criticized by those who want to reform the criminal justice system, tactics like charge stacking, are applauded here, just because of who the target is.

I think this prosecution helped Trump win back the White House. It lent credence to his claim that Democrats are engaging in politically motivated lawfare. And in this case, he was correct.
 
Very few are prosecuted. Even those who are either avoid prison time or receive much more minor sentences. Trump, for instance, has faced zero penalties despite his 34 felony convictions.
Nobody else would even have been prosecuted for something like this, much less for 34 felonies.
Defense of Trump duly noted.
Derec said:
And note that this DA, Alvin Bragg, is known for downgrading clear felonies (such as armed robberies) into misdemeanors (like petit theft), but in this case he did the exact opposite - he took a clear misdemeanor and used questionable legal maneuvering to elevate it into 34 felonies.
Attack on a successful prosecution of a multiple felon duly noted.
 
Do you think we should have sanctuary cities that protect criminal illegals?
Do you realize that overstaying a visa or otherwise being in the US without authorization is a misdemeanor?
And reentering upon previous deportation is a felony. Those illegals are protected by sanctuary cities as well, as are illegals committing additional crimes such as drug trafficking. See José Inez García Zárate, a felonious illegal whom San Francisco protected from deportation, and whom SF Public Defender's Office still calls an innocent man.
You mean: those immigrants. Those people. Those fellow human beings.

It is not the job of state or local police to lo keep tabs on persons who move in or out of their jurisdiction. Most of the time, states inform ICE if they have someone who dies not have legal authorization to be in the US when they are released after serving whatever sentence they received. My understanding from friends and family living in the area, this is/has been the case for years in Minnesota and I assume other states as well.
 
Do you think we should have sanctuary cities that protect criminal illegals?
Do you realize that overstaying a visa or otherwise being in the US without authorization is a misdemeanor?
And reentering upon previous deportation is a felony. Those illegals are protected by sanctuary cities as well, as are illegals committing additional crimes such as drug trafficking. See José Inez García Zárate, a felonious illegal whom San Francisco protected from deportation, and whom SF Public Defender's Office still calls an innocent man.
A jury acquitted him of the crimes with which he was charged.
 
Very few are prosecuted. Even those who are either avoid prison time or receive much more minor sentences. Trump, for instance, has faced zero penalties despite his 34 felony convictions.
Nobody else would even have been prosecuted for something like this, much less for 34 felonies. And note that this DA, Alvin Bragg, is known for downgrading clear felonies (such as armed robberies) into misdemeanors (like petit theft), but in this case he did the exact opposite - he took a clear misdemeanor and used questionable legal maneuvering to elevate it into 34 felonies.

It is funny that the same tactics that are generally rightly criticized by those who want to reform the criminal justice system, tactics like charge stacking, are applauded here, just because of who the target is.

I think this prosecution helped Trump win back the White House. It lent credence to his claim that Democrats are engaging in politically motivated lawfare. And in this case, he was correct.
Wow. You are defending someone who knowingly, willingly and deliberately violated campaign finance laws at least 34 times.

Who was then found guilty of said charges.

WOW.
 
Back
Top Bottom