If the baby can survive outside the womb is abortion "murder"?

[aupmanyav]

I see people trying to clarify your position on this subject. That is, you seem to endorse what appears to be a double standard under Indian law as it pertains to sexual intercourse between men and women.

I am giving as much information as possible. The problem is in your perspective. You do not seem to have much respect for Constitution and law of other countries. Obviously American or British laws will not work in India. We have a Constitution which is working for us very nicely for the last 76 years and has created a solid democratic society with regular elections and changes of governments. The laws have been created and amended by due process as per the requirement of time, by our two houses of parliament and have been ratified by our Supreme Court, which is independent of any government interference, as being valid according to our Constitution, and finally promulgated by our President. What more can be asked for?

 

[aupmanyav]

Marital rape (and any rape) can be very difficult to prove.

The woman's word will be enough in India in this particular case. She would not have to show a torn condom. We are still struggling for the correct solution of the problem of 'marital rape'. The Indian government does not recognize 'marital rape' at the moment. It accepts only 'marital violence' for which we have stringent laws.

Contraceptives are known to fail so wouldn’t that be part of the risk that the woman takes and thus should not absolve her of her responsibility? Its ok to murder a baby if a condom breaks?

OK to some, not OK to others, but the woman is eligible for termination of pregnancy in such case.

I don’t know the law, I’m only going by what you are saying.

It does not (make it into a woman's fault).

Good for you. I am the son of a lawyer, so one generation closer to a lawyer than you.

I accept that.

 

[aupmanyav]

a solid democratic society with regular elections and changes of governments.

Even today the results of elections in two states and other elections in various states to fill vacancies were announced. Modi's party won resoundingly in Maharashtra elections but lost in Jharkhand.
The 'vacancy' elections also went Modi's way in two major states. In two states, his party was defeated. That is the way of democracy.
Now the state of Delhi will go for polls in February 2025.

 

[Jimmy Higgins]

Yeah. That is so. The woman has no right to burden the man post-act with a responsibility that he never took up.

The helpless male! He needs protection of the law from women with immoral vaginas!