lpetrich
Contributor
Opinion | The Fading Line Between Rhetorical Extremism and Political Violence - The New York Times - Oct. 31, 2022
There is much more of that on the Right than on the Left, it must be noted.Under Mr. Trump’s leadership, groups on the right have felt increasingly comfortable incubating, encouraging and carrying out violence.
The consistency of the rhetoric (“enemy of the people,” “Our house is on fire,” “You’re not going to have a country anymore,” “the greatest theft in the history of America,” “Where’s Nancy?”) has ingrained dehumanization of Republican opponents in parts of the political culture; conservatives have often painted their critics as enemies who must be annihilated before they destroy you. As the Department of Homeland Security has reported, domestic violent extremism — such as the white supremacist Charlottesville riots and the Jan. 6 insurrection — is one of the most pressing internal threats facing the United States.
Some on the left, too, have increasingly abandoned norms of civility and respect for rules and institutions. The gunman who in 2017 targeted Republican members of Congress and shot five people playing baseball — the Republican House whip, Steve Scalise, was seriously wounded — drew inspiration from his hatred of Republicans and Donald Trump. In June a California man was arrested outside Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s home and charged with attempted murder after the man posted on the social platform Discord that he was going to “stop Roe v. Wade from being overturned.”
Robert Welch, founder of the John Birch Society, claimed that then-President Dwight Eisenhower was involved in this great Communist conspiracy.But the far right has its own, more direct history of conspiracy theories — for instance, Joe McCarthy’s argument that Communists controlled elements of the American government, and the John Birch Society’s insistence that the greatest threat to the United States came from Communists and their dupes inside the White House, the media, religious institutions and higher education.
The difference is that now the Republican Party has taken conspiracy theories into the political mainstream, widening their reach. Once, even hard-line conservatives dismissed such theories: Barry Goldwater, during his 1964 White House run, rejected accusations that the Supreme Court chief justice Earl Warren was a Communist or that enemy agents were in control of recent administrations.
Not so today. Election denialism, the growth of QAnon (Mr. Trump called adherents “people that love our country”), the belief that a conspiracy of global elites is stealing the American people’s wealth act to spur Mr. Trump’s followers and a sizable minority of voters to conclude that dire steps are required. Social media and partisan news outlets have accelerated the spread of these ideas, but they did not create them.