bilby
Fair dinkum thinkum
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
- Messages
- 44,401
- Gender
- He/Him
- Basic Beliefs
- Strong Atheist
STATES DON'T HAVE VOICES*.—except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.
Voters do. And there is diversity of opinion about who should be President even in the most polarised of states.
If 190,000 Wyoming voters cast a ballot for the Republican Presidential candidate, and 1,900 Wyoming voters cast a ballot for the Democratic Presidential candidate, why should those 1,900 votes be ignored?
Why is it OK for the voices of Wyoming's Democratic Party voters to be ignored (with regards to who should be the one and only POTUS), but not OK for the voices of Wyoming's Republican Party voters - who are a minuscule fraction of US voters who cast ballots for President, also to be ignored??
Eliminating the EC (or doing an end-run around it by a National Popular Vote Compact) ONLY affects who gets to be President. It has no effect at all on the Senate or Congress; Nor on the internal governments of each state.
* Though they DO have direct (and disproportionate) representation in the Senate.
Last edited: