• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC)


Everyone’s votes do already count.
Some more than others when it comes to electing a President.
Yeah. The votes of the people of Alaska and Wyoming are pretty much meaningless compared with California, Texas or New York or Florida.
They may have less impact, but they are counted more. There are more electoral college votes per capita in the states of Alaska and Wyoming than in California. They can still be ultimately outvoted by the masses in the more populous states but they still get more effective voting power.
 
They may have less impact, but they are counted more. There are more electoral college votes per capita in the states of Alaska and Wyoming than in California. They can still be ultimately outvoted by the masses in the more populous states but they still get more effective voting power.

I don't remember the details a decade later.

But according to NVP the seven least populous states that voted Trump in 2016 had a combined EC delegates total equal to California. Their entire population was about the size of the greater Los Angeles area.
Tom
 

Everyone’s votes do already count.
Some more than others when it comes to electing a President.
Yeah. The votes of the people of Alaska and Wyoming are pretty much meaningless compared with California, Texas or New York or Florida.
They may have less impact, but they are counted more. There are more electoral college votes per capita in the states of Alaska and Wyoming than in California. They can still be ultimately outvoted by the masses in the more populous states but they still get more effective voting power.
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
 
Some more than others when it comes to electing a President.
Yeah. The votes of the people of Alaska and Wyoming are pretty much meaningless compared with California, Texas or New York or Florida.
That is simply not true.
A presidential vote in Wyoming is worth nearly 4 Californian votes for the president.

And not everyone in those states have any say in the presidential election, because they know how their legislatures are going to vote.

Which is all that matters in the current system.
Tom
Really. When has Wyoming played any important part in electing any POTUS?
2000. Wyoming went for Bush; if it had gone for Gore he'd have won.
And if the popular vote was in effect, Wyoming votes wouldn’t have changed the outcome - Gore would have won.
 

Everyone’s votes do already count.
Some more than others when it comes to electing a President.
Yeah. The votes of the people of Alaska and Wyoming are pretty much meaningless compared with California, Texas or New York or Florida.
They may have less impact, but they are counted more. There are more electoral college votes per capita in the states of Alaska and Wyoming than in California. They can still be ultimately outvoted by the masses in the more populous states but they still get more effective voting power.
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
That is because they are so low population. Even when Wyoming citizens get almost four times the voting power than California citizens there just aren’t enough of them.

But they do get counted for more in the current system. That is my point.

You seem to be saying that it is fair for them to get more voting power because otherwise a President wouldn’t need to be responsive to their needs, even though they are still overrepresented in Congress, the government body that actually has the power to address their needs.
 
Should rural voters in California get more say in who is governor of the state than people living in LA or SF? The logic would seem to hold there, right?
 
Should rural voters in California get more say in who is governor of the state than people living in LA or SF? The logic would seem to hold there, right?
Rural voters in California have a better chance of getting their voices heard in California than do the people of Wyoming.
So that’s a “no” to my question? It’s hard to parse you response. Can I assume you meant to say “rural voters have a better chance of getting their voices heard in California than do the people of Wyoming have of getting their voices heard in the Federal government? And that is the basis for why the people of Wyoming should have their votes counted for more than Californians in the electoral college?

I am trying not to put words in your mouth but I am struggling to find direct answers to my questions.
 
Obviously the only fair way to pick a president would be to re-draw State lines to make them all have the same population.
AK and HI would have to include enough of the most proximate pieces of the continental US to give them the required average population, but I’m sure they can work it out.
Alternately we could have a National popular vote.
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
What makes you think the current system is the biggest method of overwhelming voters? Why wouldn't everyone in Wyoming, Alaska, Delaware etc... be "overwhelmed" by the popular vote method?
 
What makes you think the current system is the biggest method of overwhelming voters?
Because the majority of US people have no say in the presidential elections. Even if I were a teapartier my vote in Indiana wouldn't matter because Indiana is so enormously Red that I wouldn't need to vote.

I believe that is why the US electorate is so poorly engaged and so low turnout. Most of us know that our vote in the biggest political horse race in the country won't matter squat.
Tom
 
Why wouldn't everyone in Wyoming, Alaska, Delaware etc... be "overwhelmed" by the popular vote method?
What difference does it make?
What would people in Delaware have serious concerns about that California or Wyoming don't have?
Tom
 
What makes you think the current system is the biggest method of overwhelming voters?
Because the majority of US people have no say in the presidential elections. Even if I were a teapartier my vote in Indiana wouldn't matter because Indiana is so enormously Red that I wouldn't need to vote.

I believe that is why the US electorate is so poorly engaged and so low turnout. Most of us know that our vote in the biggest political horse race in the country won't matter squat.
Tom
That’s true no matter what the process.

Why wouldn't everyone in Wyoming, Alaska, Delaware etc... be "overwhelmed" by the popular vote method?
What difference does it make?
If it makes no difference, then there is no point.
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
I don’t either —except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.

Mostly it dues t matter fir a lot of things but it matters a lot when the federal government ejected by CA, TX, FL and NY decided that your natural resources or historic sites or sacred sites of indigenous peoples are fair to be exploited for ‘the common good.’
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
I don’t either —except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.

Mostly it dues t matter fir a lot of things but it matters a lot when the federal government ejected by CA, TX, FL and NY decided that your natural resources or historic sites or sacred sites of indigenous peoples are fair to be exploited for ‘the common good.’
Don't states own their own mineral rights, except where the Federal Government owns the land?
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
I don’t either —except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.

Mostly it dues t matter fir a lot of things but it matters a lot when the federal government ejected by CA, TX, FL and NY decided that your natural resources or historic sites or sacred sites of indigenous peoples are fair to be exploited for ‘the common good.’
Don't states own their own mineral rights, except where the Federal Government owns the land?
Tell that to Minnesota. Or more accurately: tell Trump.
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
I don’t either —except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.

Mostly it dues t matter fir a lot of things but it matters a lot when the federal government ejected by CA, TX, FL and NY decided that your natural resources or historic sites or sacred sites of indigenous peoples are fair to be exploited for ‘the common good.’
Don't states own their own mineral rights, except where the Federal Government owns the land?
The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW) is just under 1.1 million acres of which 80,000 acres is owned and administered by the State of Minnesota. The rest is under the US Forest Service.
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
I don’t either —except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.

Mostly it dues t matter fir a lot of things but it matters a lot when the federal government ejected by CA, TX, FL and NY decided that your natural resources or historic sites or sacred sites of indigenous peoples are fair to be exploited for ‘the common good.’
Don't states own their own mineral rights, except where the Federal Government owns the land?
The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW) is just under 1.1 million acres of which 80,000 acres is owned and administered by the State of Minnesota. The rest is under the US Forest Service.
Plus Canada.
 
It takes very very little to overwhelm the electoral votes of small population states.
Do you realize that Wyoming has about 350,000 voters while California has about 23,000,000?
I don't see a problem with that many more voters having their say.
I have asked you about what important issues you think that Wyoming people have that Californian people don't. You brought up local stop signs and the pipeline.

The biggest method of overwhelming voters is the current system of winners take all, by state. I live in Indiana and I know my vote for President is utterly inconsequential because this is a Teaparty state.
Something similar is true for the large majority of the US electorate.
Tom
I don’t either —except when the voices of smaller states are overwhelmed to the extent t they may as well be mute.

Mostly it dues t matter fir a lot of things but it matters a lot when the federal government ejected by CA, TX, FL and NY decided that your natural resources or historic sites or sacred sites of indigenous peoples are fair to be exploited for ‘the common good.’
Don't states own their own mineral rights, except where the Federal Government owns the land?
The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW) is just under 1.1 million acres of which 80,000 acres is owned and administered by the State of Minnesota. The rest is under the US Forest Service.
Of course there is the border wall along the southern border which is destroying a lot of important environmental sites and cultural sites.
 
Back
Top Bottom