• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

Nigel Farage: if I was an American citizen I wouldn’t vote for Hillary Clinton if you paid me”

I agree with those because they are past tense.

Where I disagree--and with no sense of authority--is on present tense:

Present indicative: If I am who you say I am (which I don't know because of amnesia) I'll turn myself in.

Present subjunctive: If I was who you say I am (which I am not) I would turn myself in.

Present subjunctive would be 'If I be who you say I am...'

Might sound weird but them's the breaks. Though I mostly hear people use a corrupt form, otherwise they'll stick a 'should' in there making 'If I should be who you say I am...'

'I were' is past subjunctive.

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBHZFYpQ6nc[/YOUTUBE]

He is certain he would not vote for Hilary IF he was an American citizen.

Someone should invite him here so he can explain himself :)

The confusion is likely because the Brits don't really use the subjunctive form anymore.

Educated people tend to, out of habit, but they are growing fewer, unfortunately.
 
Back
Top Bottom