What does this even mean relative to evolution or abiogenesis?

[Underseer]

It's just the same argument from ignorance that lies at the bottom of all teleological arguments. I can't imagine how X came to be, therefore I know how X came to be: a magical being magicked it into existence.

Yep. The same could be said for all chemical and physical processes. How do hydrogen and oxygen know to form water? How do protons and neutrons know how to form a nucleus?

This guy is just another religionist who thinks that cleverness and intelligence are the same thing, likely because he lacks much of the latter. Or perhaps he's just another religious bigot. Who knows?

I don't understand how hydrogen and oxygen combine to form water, therefore I know how it happens: a magical being magicks them together, therefore scientists are lying when they claim this happens as a result of natural processes.

 

[Kharakov]

Thus trial and error will always result in death.

Except when it doesn't? Hey - life always results in death, ergo life cannot exist?

I really don't get what this guy is trying to say.

Ohh, rizdek is talking about errors in trials used to determine whether or not she is a witch.