Did billionaire money tip the scales?
Zucman blames the corrosive influence of money for Prop 40's failure.
"I am not surprised," Zucman says. Opponents of Prop 40 spent
almost $400 million fighting it, including spending on competing ballot measures, making it one of the most expensive ballot initiative fights in history.
"The money spent by the billionaires was critical," Zucman says. "Anyone who lives in California has been carpet-bombed by a deluge of ads. One can easily see how this could be pivotal in such a closely contested ballot."
But didn't Democrats win plenty of races this cycle despite huge sums spent against them? In Texas, for example, Elon Musk alone poured
more than $150 million into defeating Democrat James Talarico. And Talarico ended up winning his Senate race by
a comfortable margin. Why would money have been so decisive with Prop 40 and not in other races around the nation?
For one, Zucman says, the spending gap was much bigger in the fight over Prop 40. "The billionaires spent more than $300 million on ads versus negligible sums on the other side," Zucman says. "On TV and in their mailboxes, voters were exposed only to the anti-tax arguments. This was very different from the other midterm races: in those races, when spending was high (e.g., Talarico vs. Paxton in Texas) it was high on both sides, even if unevenly. The net difference in spending was considerably larger for Prop 40."