• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

You really are a broken record.
Not a broken record, but some truths are worth repeating to they will maybe get through some thick skulls.
The trouble is, your ability of persuasion isn't particularly that high. The fact you feel the need to insult people you are trying to persuade is an indication that your attempts of spreading truths will fail, regardless how accurate your claims are.

The truth is, you have zero appreciation for how a 20 to 30 year old sees the Israel/Gaza relationship. People that have only been aware of it for the 2 to 10 years. Instead of young people that are in need of having additional context provided regarding the history and complexity of the situation, you judge them as thick skulled idiots. Worse yet, your approach will galvanize their naive to undereducated positions on the situation. Which will lead to future galvanization and real anti-Semitism becoming more common.

And of course, we also fall to the point where your position on Israel/Gaza is reactionary in its own right and show zero willingness to look at the problem more broadly to understand the human aspect of it.
How people see it doesn't change the facts on the ground.

Iran has done a very good job of making genocide look like a good thing, that doesn't make it a good thing.
 
An attempt had been made to eliminate the Tehran Theocracy which is essential to maintaining IRGC and by extension Hamas and Hezbollah. But a combination of Hegseth's incompetence and TACO Trump's lack of stick-to-itiveness doomed that operation.

What would should have been done to insure a successful operation? Be specific and realistic.
Why should the Jews trust putting themselves in the power to those who have repeatedly claimed and demonstrated genocidal intent towards them? Be specific.
 

You seriously lack imagination.
You also think the "bomb the shit out of everything" strategy was the only option.
:rolleyes:
What strategy do you think would have worked better in the aftermath of 10/7?
Even if bilby cannot think of a better strategy (and I am not saying that he can't) that doesn't mean that the strategy that was undertaken is the best one. This is some kind of logical fallacy that keeps getting raised for some odd reason.
Whether Bilby can think of a better strategy is irrelevant. The fact that nobody has proposed a better strategy that can actually stand up to scrutiny means an awful lot. This is the same mistake as always, demanding perfection where it doesn't exist. Nobody anywhere has succeeded in such a conflict, why should Israel be expected to do something nobody else has managed to accomplish? The insurgency or terror continues until either the attackers win or the funding stops.
 
I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.
Everyone takes risks, though. Every one of my students is taking an enormous risk to attend college, and they know it; and those risks are a lot more personally serious than anything Elon Musk ever faced. If one of his companies fails, as they often have, he loses some face and a bit of funny money that was never really in his pocket to begin with. He's risking millions, true, when they are only risking thousands. But they are going without food for a week to afford a forced subscription to a textbook. He is not. And if one of my students faces down a terminal illness before the risk they took on tuition manifests as a salaried position, our health system will torture and eventually execute them for the crime of being poor. These kinds of risk are both real, but if the claim is that billionaires deserve to outearn the average citizen by factor upon factor because their risks are monetarily greater, I don't agree. The fact that they are throwing millions after pet projects is an expression of how little risk they are really in, not how much.

I'm not asking for the deaths of all the Musks of the world, contrary to what Mr Beave may claim; only that those who control vast sums of wealth should be obliged to support the society that supported them so generously. This legislation wasn't a random act of socialism, but a one time response to a specific looting of the treasury, an imbalance in budgeting that these very people made, by exploiting their unearned position in the legislature to steal the wealth of a nation. I'm not surprised that the measure failed, but I don't think professors Galle et al were in the wrong for proposing it. There should be consequences when the wealthy act as though no law should apply to their horde.
 
Last edited:

To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars.
Nonsense. No one becomes a billionaire because of individual exchanges of labor for pay. The very idea is nonsensical. Extreme wealth can only be generated by seizing vast pools of existing capital and institutional control over capital investments, monetary production, and the means of exchange and production. Jensen Huang didn't personally make graphics cards. He doesn't even know how. Even his company does not, for the most part. They create and sell technology, as a corporate (communal) entity that contracts with other companies to facilitate production of graphics cards and now other related technologies, drawing investor interest by incorporating them into new spheres. None of this requires Jensen Huang the person, nor any of his labor. He occupied a corporate office, which is now occupied by another. But he gets to keep his billions. Madison Huang will also be a billionaire before she dies. Why? Because she is Jensen Huang's daughter. She is not a skilled manager, engineer, or tradesman. She's Jensen Huang's daughter. A leech, in short. But you're panicking at the thought that she might have to pay taxes on the wealth she inherits? Why? Why does she have any more claim on those billions than anyone else? And what could she possibly need them for, that her present millions cannot provide her?

I note that Huang himself has never minded paying tax on his wealth, and often says as much.

I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.

And it was this rare quality of their willingness to extremely expose their then existing (millions) wealth that then formed a basis for the billions they produced.

But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
Who is better off—aside from the billionaires?

Did the now billionaires engage in fair business practices? Did they fairly compensate contractors, suppliers and employees?

Why should families not be able to pass along wealth? Should a farmer not be able to bequeath the homestead and farmland attached to his designated heirs? Should an ordinary person who works hard, invests wisely and dies with a few million docked away for their own retirement t not be allowed to bequeath that savings to designated heirs if they die before exhausting their funds?
 
An attempt had been made to eliminate the Tehran Theocracy which is essential to maintaining IRGC and by extension Hamas and Hezbollah. But a combination of Hegseth's incompetence and TACO Trump's lack of stick-to-itiveness doomed that operation.

What would should have been done to insure a successful operation? Be specific and realistic.
Why should the Jews trust putting themselves in the power to those who have repeatedly claimed and demonstrated genocidal intent towards them? Be specific.
According to Derec, the attempt to topple the Iranian regime was doomed due to incompetent execution and timidity. I asked for his opinion on the specifics of a successful campaign. None of which suggests putting Israelis under any power (friendly or hostile).

The simple and specific answer to your worryingly bizarre straw man is no.
 
Last edited:
I will not contribute any more to this derail. You were warned yet you continued.
I, for one, would appreciate it being moved to the appropriate thread.
Tom
I will move the posts when I get to my computer.

Please stop the derail because you will be making more work for me.
 

To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars.
Nonsense. No one becomes a billionaire because of individual exchanges of labor for pay. The very idea is nonsensical. Extreme wealth can only be generated by seizing vast pools of existing capital and institutional control over capital investments, monetary production, and the means of exchange and production. Jensen Huang didn't personally make graphics cards. He doesn't even know how. Even his company does not, for the most part. They create and sell technology, as a corporate (communal) entity that contracts with other companies to facilitate production of graphics cards and now other related technologies, drawing investor interest by incorporating them into new spheres. None of this requires Jensen Huang the person, nor any of his labor. He occupied a corporate office, which is now occupied by another. But he gets to keep his billions. Madison Huang will also be a billionaire before she dies. Why? Because she is Jensen Huang's daughter. She is not a skilled manager, engineer, or tradesman. She's Jensen Huang's daughter. A leech, in short. But you're panicking at the thought that she might have to pay taxes on the wealth she inherits? Why? Why does she have any more claim on those billions than anyone else? And what could she possibly need them for, that her present millions cannot provide her?

I note that Huang himself has never minded paying tax on his wealth, and often says as much.

I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.

And it was this rare quality of their willingness to extremely expose their then existing (millions) wealth that then formed a basis for the billions they produced.

But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
Who is better off—aside from the billionaires?

Did the now billionaires engage in fair business practices? Did they fairly compensate contractors, suppliers and employees?

Why should families not be able to pass along wealth? Should a farmer not be able to bequeath the homestead and farmland attached to his designated heirs? Should an ordinary person who works hard, invests wisely and dies with a few million docked away for their own retirement t not be allowed to bequeath that savings to designated heirs if they die before exhausting their funds?
I do agree with Rvonce that we should dramatically increase estate taxes. Yes it’s natural to pass some wealth to our kids. But I think there should be a cap. How big a cap? I don’t know. I feel that Oregon’s estate tax which begins at 1 million is too low. Washington estate tax starts at 10 million. That seems about right to me.
 

You seriously lack imagination.
You also think the "bomb the shit out of everything" strategy was the only option.
:rolleyes:
What strategy do you think would have worked better in the aftermath of 10/7?
Even if bilby cannot think of a better strategy (and I am not saying that he can't) that doesn't mean that the strategy that was undertaken is the best one. This is some kind of logical fallacy that keeps getting raised for some odd reason.
Whether Bilby can think of a better strategy is irrelevant. The fact that nobody has proposed a better strategy that can actually stand up to scrutiny means an awful lot.
Nobody anywhere? Or just nobody on this forum, which we have no reason to believe is filled with experts on the subject. And whose “scrutiny” is relevant here? Yours? I disagree it “means an awful lot”.

I admit I have no expertise on the subject so I admit I have no solution that is good. But I don’t think that means there is no good solution. That would be awful arrogant of me don’t you think?
 
I'm not asking for the deaths of all the Musks of the world, contrary to what Mr Beave may claim;
Where did I say that?
Ah, my apologies for the misattribution, that was Mr Bomb, in fact. Alliteration clearly scrambled what was left of my mind.
OK, apology accepted. Where did Bomb # 20 say that?
When he compared a one-time wealth tax of 5% to the attempted genocide of the entire Jewish people.

The difference between you and the antisemites is that they feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of, whereas you, in contrast, feel the problems of society are caused by a parasitic minority group we should get rid of.
 
This thread was created by someone who loves listening to anti-Semitic white supremacists (Tucker Carlson etc).
I'm not anti-Semitic and neither is Tucker Carlson. Nor is anyone against Israel as a US ally.
Mr Carlson quacks, walks, and looks like an antisemite eeven though he denies he is one.
RVonse said:
What we are against is being Israel's cuckold and Washington being controlled and overrun by foreign influence.

We do not live in a Democracy if a foreign government tells our leaders what to do.
Nonsense. We elect leaders to make decisions. Gov’ts tell others what to do (or request them to do) all the time. Leaders face tradeoffs in decisions and, hopefully, keep the national interests foremost in the decision-making.
 
I'm not asking for the deaths of all the Musks of the world, contrary to what Mr Beave may claim;
Where did I say that?
Ah, my apologies for the misattribution, that was Mr Bomb, in fact. Alliteration clearly scrambled what was left of my mind.
Of course, I didn't say it either, in fact. Of course, you're highly unlikely to apologize to me too, in fact. What scrambled the first part of your mind, in fact?
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
 
I'm not asking for the deaths of all the Musks of the world, contrary to what Mr Beave may claim;
Where did I say that?
Ah, my apologies for the misattribution, that was Mr Bomb, in fact. Alliteration clearly scrambled what was left of my mind.
Of course, I didn't say it either, in fact. Of course, you're highly unlikely to apologize to me too, in fact. What scrambled the first part of your mind, in fact?
I notice you clipped out the part where I quoted you saying exactly that.
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
You are assuming there is no better answer. There’s a false dichotomy here.
 
Back
Top Bottom