• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't see anyone objecting to this. What's being objected to is a wealth tax--that is, a tax on current assets.

And, honestly, I doubt we even need to. Undo the Republican damage and see where things stand, whether we need to go farther.

(And note that the idea of a one-time wealth tax is even more onerous. Such things are never one time.)
There’s no reason a wealth tax should be one time.

Regular Americans pay wealth tax on their homes: ie property tax. For most Americans fortunate enough to own homes, they pay it directly. For those who re t: they pay property tax in their rent, which the owner of the dwelling must pay.

Musk, I believe is supposedly worth over $1Trillion. If he had to pay a wealth tax of 99%, he’d still have over a hundred million dollars worth of wealth. I’m finding it difficult to feel sorry for him. But then I’m not proposing that we tax him or anyone at 99%.

But I am saying that we have really gone off the rails by allowing anyone to accumulate that much personal wealth. At that level of wealth, rules effectively do not apply to them. Even if we applied rules as even handed as possible to everyone, the uber wealthy can afford many teams of lawyers to delay judgements.

A tax deferred is a tax not paid. Same with a judgement or fine. Fines, penalties that would cripple ordinary multimillionaires are effectively meaningless to someone like Musk.
A $100 million dollars is a huge sum for an individual, I agree. But if you are manufacturing cars or rockets that same $100 million becomes almost nothing. With only $100 million capital Musk could not continue with cars or rockets he would be out of business. And that assumes the billionaire (in this case Musk) did not run across state lines to hide everything in another country.

In a previous post you lamented concern for farmers not able to pass their land to their children and I agree with that concern. But how does a wealth tax (which you appear to agree with) destroying an existing and valuable business not do exactly the same thing? Indeed, a wealth tax is exactly the same except reaching the founder of the company (the person who actually produced something valuable to society) instead of his children who did nothing deserving at all.
Wealth taxes need not destroy viable/functioning businesses. Indeed, they usually do not. What I see locally with businesses much smaller but still employing many people is that often, the next generation is not interested in running the family business which is either sold to someone or closes down or is purchased by someone outside of this community—where the profits follow.

I’m not certain why you have such a hard on for poor poor Elon who needs a trillion dollars and all of the government subsidies his endeavors receive.
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
 
I've never met an actual economist quite so hard on the idea of keeping wealth in circulation. Money spent on luxuries is something they normally BEG the public to provide at this time of year. Unmovement, not movement, is the bane of a healthy economic system. To have only 250 households financially solvent enough to spend on the occasional luxury is not a prudent system, it's the prelude to a collapse.
 
Whether Bilby can think of a better strategy is irrelevant. The fact that nobody has proposed a better strategy that can actually stand up to scrutiny means an awful lot.
Nobody anywhere? Or just nobody on this forum, which we have no reason to believe is filled with experts on the subject. And whose “scrutiny” is relevant here? Yours? I disagree it “means an awful lot”.

I admit I have no expertise on the subject so I admit I have no solution that is good. But I don’t think that means there is no good solution. That would be awful arrogant of me don’t you think?
If somebody had a better answer why have they not said something?

If they are friendly to Israel they'll tell Israel and Israel would act on it. If they're hostile to Israel they would tell the world to embarrass Israel.

This is a case where the dog not barking is very meaningful. While you can argue that some might have a motive to keep quiet the idea that all would makes no sense.
 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
I assumed nothing. I suggest there might be less deadly responses that result in similar outcomes.

At least you refrained “Israel will be exterminated “ idiocy.
Consider the "logic" in your response: Your statement reduces to "there may be a better answer, therefore it must be found". This is a variation on assuming your conclusion in your argument.

Hamas has said they intend to kill every Jew. They have crowed about repeating 10/7 again and again. Why do you not believe them?
 
I'm aware. I'm also aware that my biological dad and my grandpa both nearly lost their completely paid off houses because of property taxes. They owned the homes outright, but the property taxes were raised significantly, and the counties threatened to seize their homes because they couldn't pay the taxes on them.

I'm also aware that estate taxes have resulted in people being forced to sell of heirlooms and property in order to pay the taxes, because the value of the estate is based on illiquid estimates of market value rather than actual money.
I've already proposed my answer for property taxes. For estate taxes: not only are there the cases you're talking about, but a family business that keeps being passed down the generations will have to pay a substantial portion of it's profits as estate tax. Thus my proposal, similar to what I suggested for property tax. When estate tax hits intergenerational transfers that which can't readily be divided, or will lose value by being divided (say, the share of the family business) you compute the estate tax, convert it to a percentage and apply it as a lien against the asset in question. In the case of family business entities and the like this also applies to any sale to another beneficiary even if it's not passed by inheritance (4 kids inherit the family business, 3 buy out the 4th, that transaction doesn't trigger the lien.) Should an asset end up with multiple such liens only the highest percentage one is kept. This protection exists only for active businesses, not any sort of holding company (but neither does a holding company preclude applying it to that which is held--it's treated as pass through.)
 
You really are a broken record.
Not a broken record, but some truths are worth repeating to they will maybe get through some thick skulls.
The trouble is, your ability of persuasion isn't particularly that high. The fact you feel the need to insult people you are trying to persuade is an indication that your attempts of spreading truths will fail, regardless how accurate your claims are.

The truth is, you have zero appreciation for how a 20 to 30 year old sees the Israel/Gaza relationship. People that have only been aware of it for the 2 to 10 years. Instead of young people that are in need of having additional context provided regarding the history and complexity of the situation, you judge them as thick skulled idiots. Worse yet, your approach will galvanize their naive to undereducated positions on the situation. Which will lead to future galvanization and real anti-Semitism becoming more common.

And of course, we also fall to the point where your position on Israel/Gaza is reactionary in its own right and show zero willingness to look at the problem more broadly to understand the human aspect of it.
How people see it doesn't change the facts on the ground.
That is the dumbest thing you've ever said. Perception is critical. Perception is impacted by history and knowledge, but mostly the stuff that one has noticed while they are alive. Younger people have a much different perspective on Israel because all they've known is Netanyahu controlled Israel. People who are turning 20 were born years after the wave of suicide bombings.

If you think that isn't important to breaking through the misguided positions younger people are likely to have on Israel, you really should just step away.
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
Who wants to bring down Walmart? I’d like to see Walmart be much more responsible with their labor practices and to lay the hell off demanding tax abatements while demanding access roads and utilities be installed at taxpayer expense. To provide cheap goods and drive local small businesses out of business. But hey—They can go work for Walmart and earn $7.50/hr no benefits, part time hours at employer’s pleasure so don’t go thinking you can fill in the gaps with another part time job. Oh, and you get to come to ‘tread meetings’ where you pledge allegiance to Walmart.

I mean—I would not cry if Walmart disappeared. I don’t shop there. But I know plenty of people who do.

No: I want income to be taxed in a more progressive way. I want tax code to be re-written to close loop holes and with higher tiers of income taxed. I want the cap on SS contributions to be raised significantly. I want it to be impossible for uber wealthy people to get tax write offs for personal and company jets, multiple homes, wardrobe and entertainment, etc. Also charitable contributions.
 
Even if someone suggests a moderation in the killing of civilians, it is met with "Then Israel will be annihilated!". It is hard for them to imagine the same outcome (Hamas drastically damaged but still armed) with 5,000 fewer dead civilians.
And you can imagine a world where the average lifespan is 1,000. Does nothing about making it actually happen.

You are assuming there must be a better answer. That's leftist faith, not reality.
I assumed nothing. I suggest there might be less deadly responses that result in similar outcomes.

At least you refrained “Israel will be exterminated “ idiocy.
Consider the "logic" in your response: Your statement reduces to "there may be a better answer, therefore it must be found". This is a variation on assuming your conclusion in your argument.
Whether or not a better solution is possible or feasible is determined by thought and experiment, not kneejerk denials.
Hamas has said they intend to kill every Jew. They have crowed about repeating 10/7 again and again. Why do you not believe them?
It is not a matter of belief. It is a matter of capability. They are nowhere close to such a capability at this time or the near future. Plenty of time to try to change or moderate their attitude without killing magnitudes of civilians. I realize those civilians are not Israelis, but they are humans, many are children. And before you respond with your automatic "that means genocide of Jews" - it most certainly does not. Nor does it mean no defense.

Besides the only way to completely squash Hamas from achieving their stated goal is to kill all member of Hamas - present and future. In other words, genocide.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
According to New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, estate tax is not a wealth tax; it's a tax on the privilege of transferring your property at death. That's why it isn't a direct unapportioned tax, which would have made it unconstitutional.
 
Back
Top Bottom