Toni
Contributor
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2011
- Messages
- 25,395
- Basic Beliefs
- Peace on Earth, goodwill towards all
Wealth taxes need not destroy viable/functioning businesses. Indeed, they usually do not. What I see locally with businesses much smaller but still employing many people is that often, the next generation is not interested in running the family business which is either sold to someone or closes down or is purchased by someone outside of this community—where the profits follow.A $100 million dollars is a huge sum for an individual, I agree. But if you are manufacturing cars or rockets that same $100 million becomes almost nothing. With only $100 million capital Musk could not continue with cars or rockets he would be out of business. And that assumes the billionaire (in this case Musk) did not run across state lines to hide everything in another country.There’s no reason a wealth tax should be one time.I don't see anyone objecting to this. What's being objected to is a wealth tax--that is, a tax on current assets.Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
And, honestly, I doubt we even need to. Undo the Republican damage and see where things stand, whether we need to go farther.
(And note that the idea of a one-time wealth tax is even more onerous. Such things are never one time.)
Regular Americans pay wealth tax on their homes: ie property tax. For most Americans fortunate enough to own homes, they pay it directly. For those who re t: they pay property tax in their rent, which the owner of the dwelling must pay.
Musk, I believe is supposedly worth over $1Trillion. If he had to pay a wealth tax of 99%, he’d still have over a hundred million dollars worth of wealth. I’m finding it difficult to feel sorry for him. But then I’m not proposing that we tax him or anyone at 99%.
But I am saying that we have really gone off the rails by allowing anyone to accumulate that much personal wealth. At that level of wealth, rules effectively do not apply to them. Even if we applied rules as even handed as possible to everyone, the uber wealthy can afford many teams of lawyers to delay judgements.
A tax deferred is a tax not paid. Same with a judgement or fine. Fines, penalties that would cripple ordinary multimillionaires are effectively meaningless to someone like Musk.
In a previous post you lamented concern for farmers not able to pass their land to their children and I agree with that concern. But how does a wealth tax (which you appear to agree with) destroying an existing and valuable business not do exactly the same thing? Indeed, a wealth tax is exactly the same except reaching the founder of the company (the person who actually produced something valuable to society) instead of his children who did nothing deserving at all.
I’m not certain why you have such a hard on for poor poor Elon who needs a trillion dollars and all of the government subsidies his endeavors receive.