• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

I have been wondering about the "buy, borrow, die" schemes and taxing wealth could work.
What is the buy borrow die scheme?
I think he means when billionaires buy an expensive mansion and then borrow against it for their cash flow and daily liquidity. That way they never have to touch any of their company assets or pay income tax. Their loan is completely tax deductable:

    • Buy: Acquire appreciating assets such as stocks, real estate, businesses, or art. Unrealized gains generally are not taxed until the asset is sold. [1, 2, 3]
    • Borrow: Use appreciated assets as collateral for loans—such as a securities-backed line of credit (SBLOC), margin loan, or real estate refinance—to access cash. Because loans are debt rather than income, borrowing typically does not trigger capital gains tax or count as taxable income. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Die: Hold assets until death so heirs receive a step-up in basis (under IRC §1014), resetting the cost basis to fair market value at death and wiping out capital gains tax on lifetime appreciation. Outstanding loans remain obligations of the estate and are paid off using estate funds or pledged assets
Yea, income from loans aren’t taxed for anyone. I use our credit card for everything. Eventually loans have to be repaid from income. And then subject to taxes. So it’s a short term cash increase. BTW: sbaloc is a business loan that requires monthly p&l beginning 30 days after loan closing.
Billionaires never ever pay their loans from income, they just borrow more if they run out of cash flow for their first loan. Kind of like the US government does.
Yeah, so they keep cash out of circulation and they make it harder for the regular folks to borrow.
 
Musk turned the company around much more than just advances in batteries! My daughter wrote her MBA on this. He injected substantial working capital into the company, hired a great management team, secured steady bank financing, dramatically ramped up the marketing, and etc. he completely overhauled the supply chain, and etc.
So he did what any good business person with a shit load of money would do.
And if he stuck to being a venture capitalist, he could become Lex Luthor (or maybe a much more wealthy Lex Luthor?).
 
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year - at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill. From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
Taxing wealth is a bad idea. I know, I know, a lot of people think it's somehow horrible for people to have a lot of wealth... but a lot of those people also don't understand the difference between income and wealth, and haven't thought it all the way through.
I'd say the people insisting that a class-blind income tax is a fair system, and deny that generational wealth even exists, are the ones who do not understand the difference between wealth and income. There is no universe in which taxing the wealthy and taxing the poor is functionally the same act.
The problem is that while there is generational wealth it's not anything like the factor you think it is.

The main thing that is passed is expectations in life, not money. But you can't solve that with antidiscrimination laws.
 
That is true. California has high state taxes, but also one that has the ballot initiative system that lets people pass laws directly regardless of consequences. So they have passed a freeze on property taxes which means that people who have lived in their houses for decades contribute very little to the property tax base of a community.
I think fixing issues like that would be far more beneficial to California than gimmicky things like a one-time wealth tax.
But what you did not quote from that article:
Property tax is problematic. Yes, it lets people who have lived in their house for decades not pay much--but it also means retirees won't be taxed out of their houses.

I think perhaps the answer is somewhere in between: compute property tax based on a median of the last 5 years (discard spikes), but anyone without a job can apply for a deferment. The tax is still computed, but it's not delinquent so long as you pay the inflation adjusted amount of the current tax. The excess becomes a lien on the property, redeemed if the property changes hands to someone not already living there.
 
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't see anyone objecting to this. What's being objected to is a wealth tax--that is, a tax on current assets.

And, honestly, I doubt we even need to. Undo the Republican damage and see where things stand, whether we need to go farther.

(And note that the idea of a one-time wealth tax is even more onerous. Such things are never one time.)
 
Why does the Left love to compute income taxes as percentage of wealth and not income. They are called income taxes for a reason.
Because wealth disparity is the problem that income taxes, as currently interpreted, are blatantly and obviously failing to alleviate. There's a cancer at the top of our economic ladder, draining the entire system dry and contributing next to nothing to society for our pains. People die on the streets, just so these forty assholes can watch imaginary numbers get bigger on their money managers' screen every so often. Fuck these people. They wouldn't spit on your grave to put out a fire, don't suck their dick for free. You owe nothing to them and they don't give a shit about you.
To drain something would have to be extracted. That's not happening. You still want to eat future production. It doesn't exist yet--and probably will never exist. It's just numbers on paper that will disappear when the AI bubble pops.
 
Why does the Left love to compute income taxes as percentage of wealth and not income. They are called income taxes for a reason.
Because wealth disparity is the problem that income taxes, as currently interpreted, are blatantly and obviously failing to alleviate. There's a cancer at the top of our economic ladder, draining the entire system dry and contributing next to nothing to society for our pains. People die on the streets, just so these forty assholes can watch imaginary numbers get bigger on their money managers' screen every so often. Fuck these people. They wouldn't spit on your grave to put out a fire, don't suck their dick for free. You owe nothing to them and they don't give a shit about you.
To drain something would have to be extracted. That's not happening. You still want to eat future production. It doesn't exist yet--and probably will never exist. It's just numbers on paper that will disappear when the AI bubble pops.
How does it benefit us to let that imaginary money fuck off to the Caymans when the bubble bursts, instead of funding our critical infrastructure and services?
 
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year - at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill. From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
Taxing wealth is a bad idea. I know, I know, a lot of people think it's somehow horrible for people to have a lot of wealth... but a lot of those people also don't understand the difference between income and wealth, and haven't thought it all the way through.
I'd say the people insisting that a class-blind income tax is a fair system, and deny that generational wealth even exists, are the ones who do not understand the difference between wealth and income. There is no universe in which taxing the wealthy and taxing the poor is functionally the same act.
The problem is that while there is generational wealth it's not anything like the factor you think it is.

The main thing that is passed is expectations in life, not money. But you can't solve that with antidiscrimination laws.
Data?
 
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't see anyone objecting to this. What's being objected to is a wealth tax--that is, a tax on current assets.

And, honestly, I doubt we even need to. Undo the Republican damage and see where things stand, whether we need to go farther.

(And note that the idea of a one-time wealth tax is even more onerous. Such things are never one time.)
There’s no reason a wealth tax should be one time.

Regular Americans pay wealth tax on their homes: ie property tax. For most Americans fortunate enough to own homes, they pay it directly. For those who re t: they pay property tax in their rent, which the owner of the dwelling must pay.

Musk, I believe is supposedly worth over $1Trillion. If he had to pay a wealth tax of 99%, he’d still have over a hundred million dollars worth of wealth. I’m finding it difficult to feel sorry for him. But then I’m not proposing that we tax him or anyone at 99%.

But I am saying that we have really gone off the rails by allowing anyone to accumulate that much personal wealth. At that level of wealth, rules effectively do not apply to them. Even if we applied rules as even handed as possible to everyone, the uber wealthy can afford many teams of lawyers to delay judgements.

A tax deferred is a tax not paid. Same with a judgement or fine. Fines, penalties that would cripple ordinary multimillionaires are effectively meaningless to someone like Musk.
 
And if he stuck to being a venture capitalist, he could become Lex Luthor (or maybe a much more wealthy Lex Luthor?).
Well, he's into car companies, so maybe Lexus Luthor? That's got to be better than his current role as Josef Starlink.
The original Roadster was based on an Elise chassis, so maybe Lotus Luthor instead?
 
Musk’s capital saved Tesla. His genius brought us the cyber truck.

Also the air is cleaner today due to regulation, emissions caps, fuel rules, etc… Not due to an unregulated market. However, setting the rules and letting the market figure out how to make it work made it work. Yeah, emissions controls killed performance for awhile. But competition forced makers to figure out how to meet standards while making speed.

Then there is the dreaded cap and trade that beat back sulfur (with a generous dose of exporting the pollution by moving manufacturing out of our immediate air shed).
 
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.
I don't see anyone objecting to this. What's being objected to is a wealth tax--that is, a tax on current assets.

And, honestly, I doubt we even need to. Undo the Republican damage and see where things stand, whether we need to go farther.

(And note that the idea of a one-time wealth tax is even more onerous. Such things are never one time.)
There’s no reason a wealth tax should be one time.

Regular Americans pay wealth tax on their homes: ie property tax. For most Americans fortunate enough to own homes, they pay it directly. For those who re t: they pay property tax in their rent, which the owner of the dwelling must pay.

Musk, I believe is supposedly worth over $1Trillion. If he had to pay a wealth tax of 99%, he’d still have over a hundred million dollars worth of wealth. I’m finding it difficult to feel sorry for him. But then I’m not proposing that we tax him or anyone at 99%.

But I am saying that we have really gone off the rails by allowing anyone to accumulate that much personal wealth. At that level of wealth, rules effectively do not apply to them. Even if we applied rules as even handed as possible to everyone, the uber wealthy can afford many teams of lawyers to delay judgements.

A tax deferred is a tax not paid. Same with a judgement or fine. Fines, penalties that would cripple ordinary multimillionaires are effectively meaningless to someone like Musk.
A $100 million dollars is a huge sum for an individual, I agree. But if you are manufacturing cars or rockets that same $100 million becomes almost nothing. With only $100 million capital Musk could not continue with cars or rockets he would be out of business. And that assumes the billionaire (in this case Musk) did not run across state lines to hide everything in another country.

In a previous post you lamented concern for farmers not able to pass their land to their children and I agree with that concern. But how does a wealth tax (which you appear to agree with) destroying an existing and valuable business not do exactly the same thing? Indeed, a wealth tax is exactly the same except reaching the founder of the company (the person who actually produced something valuable to society) instead of his children who did nothing deserving at all.
 
I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.

And it was this rare quality of their willingness to extremely expose their then existing (millions) wealth that then formed a basis for the billions they produced.
Right so far. We see the winners, we don't note the many who tried and lost. We once knew a couple with 9 figures. One property, failed, I don't know what they're worth now but it's no doubt a shadow of what they once had.
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
 
Yeah. I could see how that would be really bad. :rolleyes:
Of course it would be.
How about Jasmine Crockett? I think she'd be great.
What do you think recommends her as Speaker? Jeffries has experience is House leadership as Minority Leader and before that as Chair of the Democratic Caucus. That alone makes him more suitable for the minefield that is Speakership.
I agree that Jeffries should be Speaker. Schumer is getting pretty old.

It bothers me a lot that after putting together the blue tsunami, people are in a hurry to get rid of Schumer and Jeffries. Schumer I can see needs to step aside for a younger person.

I also am a fan of Jasmine Crockett who serves on the Judiciary committee and is in fact ranking member on Oversights in that committee. She's outspoken, and while she is often labeled progressive (imo, ain't nothin wrong with that) she sees herself as more a common sense Democrat and I don't think there is anything wrong with that.

What I absolutely do not want is for the Dems to waste their advantage with a lot of infighting. There are plenty who will encourage division for their own purposes.
Schumer needs to go, not because of his age, but his views DO NOT ALIGN with the current Democratic party.
Well yes, but at this point, I want the Dems actually in charge over the next 2 years to be disposable fossils like Schumer, who can take the hit for being incapable because "too old" rather than because "there too early".

Over the next 2 years, there is going to be a shit show: republicans will keep most of everything locked up, because the democrats didn't get over the filibuster limit or a veto-proof majority.

The Democrats don't have the numbers to break a filibuster and the president will veto their not-veto-proof bills, and then in 2 years, the republicans will attempt to put this "complete failure to do anything" on the shoulders of democratic lawmakers.

To that end, I am glad a younger, less senile person is not having their career put up on that block.

Then, I'm not sure if this is really the reason or just me making excuses to not panic at a potentially disastrous decision.
 

My biggest issue with uber wealthy is that effectively, laws don’t apply to them, and indeed they and their corporations are able to skirt tax laws and other regulatory laws that apply to mere mortals.
The laws do apply to them they just buy the politicians who write the laws in a way to maximize their benefit.

When it came to being taxed even 5% in California they were willing to spend $400M in advertisement to avoid it even if that tax money might help all other Californians. I’m not arguing that the billionaire tax was a good proposal as written but to avoid losing 5% of your wealth and keeping 95% in order to help other people in your state have health care is indicative of some kind of mentality that these billionaires have.
So, really—laws do not apply to them because they can buy police, investigators, politicians, judges, etc.

I agree re: mentality. Way back when I was really young and hubby and I had very little, I remember thinking how big a chunk of my paycheck went to SS. I really could have used those dollars for silly things like food. But at the same time, I was proud to pay my SS because my grandfather had recently retired and relied on SS to live.

I still am glad to pay my taxes. Of course I wish they were less. I wish bread cost less. I wish eggs cost less. And gas . And utilities.

I also understand that wealthy people are always being hit up for money. I even understand. Occasionally, I find requests for donations/help to be frustrating and too
much. I can well imagine that wealthy people always feel as though someone has their hand in their pocket.

In general people of modest means tend to be more generous, proportionally, than wealthier people.
 
I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.

And it was this rare quality of their willingness to extremely expose their then existing (millions) wealth that then formed a basis for the billions they produced.
Right so far. We see the winners, we don't note the many who tried and lost. We once knew a couple with 9 figures. One property, failed, I don't know what they're worth now but it's no doubt a shadow of what they once had.
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
Who gets paid for those luxuries? Don’t purchases of consumer goods benefit the economy? Services as well?

Re: your uber wealthy friends. Sure, they may be a mere financial shadow of their former selves but I’ll bet they have substantial wealth and still live a lifestyle far beyond the reach of most middle and upper middle class Americans.
 
Yeah. I could see how that would be really bad. :rolleyes:
Of course it would be.
How about Jasmine Crockett? I think she'd be great.
What do you think recommends her as Speaker? Jeffries has experience is House leadership as Minority Leader and before that as Chair of the Democratic Caucus. That alone makes him more suitable for the minefield that is Speakership.
I agree that Jeffries should be Speaker. Schumer is getting pretty old.

It bothers me a lot that after putting together the blue tsunami, people are in a hurry to get rid of Schumer and Jeffries. Schumer I can see needs to step aside for a younger person.

I also am a fan of Jasmine Crockett who serves on the Judiciary committee and is in fact ranking member on Oversights in that committee. She's outspoken, and while she is often labeled progressive (imo, ain't nothin wrong with that) she sees herself as more a common sense Democrat and I don't think there is anything wrong with that.

What I absolutely do not want is for the Dems to waste their advantage with a lot of infighting. There are plenty who will encourage division for their own purposes.
Schumer needs to go, not because of his age, but his views DO NOT ALIGN with the current Democratic party.
Well yes, but at this point, I want the Dems actually in charge over the next 2 years to be disposable fossils like Schumer, who can take the hit for being incapable because "too old" rather than because "there too early".

Over the next 2 years, there is going to be a shit show: republicans will keep most of everything locked up, because the democrats didn't get over the filibuster limit or a veto-proof majority.

The Democrats don't have the numbers to break a filibuster and the president will veto their not-veto-proof bills, and then in 2 years, the republicans will attempt to put this "complete failure to do anything" on the shoulders of democratic lawmakers.

To that end, I am glad a younger, less senile person is not having their career put up on that block.

Then, I'm not sure if this is really the reason or just me making excuses to not panic at a potentially disastrous decision.
You are likely correct re: difficulty in passing legislation. OTOH, more Republicans are starting to break away from Trump’s sway. Most obviously, those who lost seats ( Thomas Massie) but I am hopeful that Trump fever has broken.
 
Back
Top Bottom