• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker


To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars.
Nonsense. No one becomes a billionaire because of individual exchanges of labor for pay. The very idea is nonsensical. Extreme wealth can only be generated by seizing vast pools of existing capital and institutional control over capital investments, monetary production, and the means of exchange and production. Jensen Huang didn't personally make graphics cards. He doesn't even know how. Even his company does not, for the most part. They create and sell technology, as a corporate (communal) entity that contracts with other companies to facilitate production of graphics cards and now other related technologies, drawing investor interest by incorporating them into new spheres. None of this requires Jensen Huang the person, nor any of his labor. He occupied a corporate office, which is now occupied by another. But he gets to keep his billions. Madison Huang will also be a billionaire before she dies. Why? Because she is Jensen Huang's daughter. She is not a skilled manager, engineer, or tradesman. She's Jensen Huang's daughter. A leech, in short. But you're panicking at the thought that she might have to pay taxes on the wealth she inherits? Why? Why does she have any more claim on those billions than anyone else? And what could she possibly need them for, that her present millions cannot provide her?

I note that Huang himself has never minded paying tax on his wealth, and often says as much.

I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.

And it was this rare quality of their willingness to extremely expose their then existing (millions) wealth that then formed a basis for the billions they produced.

But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
Who is better off—aside from the billionaires?

Did the now billionaires engage in fair business practices? Did they fairly compensate contractors, suppliers and employees?

Why should families not be able to pass along wealth? Should a farmer not be able to bequeath the homestead and farmland attached to his designated heirs? Should an ordinary person who works hard, invests wisely and dies with a few million docked away for their own retirement t not be allowed to bequeath that savings to designated heirs if they die before exhausting their funds?
We are all better off because of Musk and many other billionaires. Even if you do not own a Tesla car we are better off because the quality of the air is better and less other people are buying gas so your gas price is lower. The earth is better off because of Musk. We are also better off because Bill Gates gave us computer software and better off for the chips Nvidia produces as well. Yes, there are some bad billionaires like Carl Icahn who did actually pirate their wealth from the backs of others. But for the most part the billionaires have produced many of the best goods all of society enjoys today.Ther

So its OK to be a billionaire like Sam Walton. Sam himself produced something good. And it is OK to leave your small or medium size farm to your kids. But it is not OK for Sam Walton's non productive progeny to enjoy privileges into the distant future until the pyramids fall. That is the kind of billionaires we should be going after IMO.
The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.

I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.

We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.
Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Musk turned the company around much more than just advances in batteries! My daughter wrote her MBA on this. He injected substantial working capital into the company, hired a great management team, secured steady bank financing, dramatically ramped up the marketing, and etc. he completely overhauled the supply chain, and etc.
Did she mention the almost five hundred million dollar loan from the government?
 
Very few are prosecuted. Even those who are either avoid prison time or receive much more minor sentences. Trump, for instance, has faced zero penalties despite his 34 felony convictions.
Nobody else would even have been prosecuted for something like this, much less for 34 felonies. And note that this DA, Alvin Bragg, is known for downgrading clear felonies (such as armed robberies) into misdemeanors (like petit theft), but in this case he did the exact opposite - he took a clear misdemeanor and used questionable legal maneuvering to elevate it into 34 felonies.
I don't remember you saying anything when Trump's lawyer was sent to prison for his part in those crimes.

It is funny that the same tactics that are generally rightly criticized by those who want to reform the criminal justice system, tactics like charge stacking, are applauded here, just because of who the target is.
You don't get 34 unanimous jury verdicts for lawfare.

I think this prosecution helped Trump win back the White House. It lent credence to his claim that Democrats are engaging in politically motivated lawfare. And in this case, he was correct.
You're against politics in the law while advocating for politics in the law.
 
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
According to New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, estate tax is not a wealth tax; it's a tax on the privilege of transferring your property at death. That's why it isn't a direct unapportioned tax, which would have made it unconstitutional.
It is a percentage of wealth which logically makes it a tax on wealth.
It is a percentage of the amount transferred which logically makes it a tax on the transfer; the circumstance that the amount transferred was 100% of the owner's assets is incidental. If some heiress blows her entire fortune on cosmetic surgery then the sales tax the state collects is a percentage of her wealth, but that does not logically makes it a tax on wealth.

For what it's worth, Oliver Wendell Holmes disagreed with you, and it was a 9-0 ruling.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
I'm aware. I'm also aware that my biological dad and my grandpa both nearly lost their completely paid off houses because of property taxes. They owned the homes outright, but the property taxes were raised significantly, and the counties threatened to seize their homes because they couldn't pay the taxes on them.
Why didn't they just use the home for collateral on a low interest loan to pay the taxes?

 
I think that destroying value just so you can stick it to people wealthier than you think they should be allowed to be is an ideology built on envy.
Taxing redistributes value but does not necessarily destroy it. Taxing wealth has advantages and disadvantages. Whether it is a good or bad idea depends on the details and one's values.
All such schemes end up being about tearing down those above. And if you hand out the money to the people you just get inflation, coupled with an unwillingness to invest in new things.
 
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year - at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill. From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
Taxing wealth is a bad idea. I know, I know, a lot of people think it's somehow horrible for people to have a lot of wealth... but a lot of those people also don't understand the difference between income and wealth, and haven't thought it all the way through.
I'd say the people insisting that a class-blind income tax is a fair system, and deny that generational wealth even exists, are the ones who do not understand the difference between wealth and income. There is no universe in which taxing the wealthy and taxing the poor is functionally the same act.
I think that destroying value just so you can stick it to people wealthier than you think they should be allowed to be is an ideology built on envy.
Destroying value? How is redistributing wealth from hoarded stockpiles to mobement within the economy in any sense "destroying value"? The value of what?
1) We do not have hoarded stockpiles. You're seeing numbers and thinking there's something behind them. No, it's predicted (probably quite wishfully) future value, there's nothing there.

2) We do have an example of something akin to hoarded stockpiles being distributed. It was very, very bad for Spain.

You are making the standard mistake of thinking money has value. At the level of society it does not--taking money doesn't create more for the average person, it just raises the price of what's already there. And it discourages future investment. Yet another variation on the oh, so tasty seed corn.
 
1) We do not have hoarded stockpiles. You're seeing numbers and thinking there's something behind them. No, it's predicted (probably quite wishfully) future value, there's nothing there.
That is a childish view unconnected to economics as it is observed in the real world. I do not know how to convince you that however it is constructed, abstracted, and redistributed, currency is incredibly important to the life of a nation that uses it as its basic medium of exchange.

We do have an example of something akin to hoarded stockpiles being distributed. It was very, very bad for Spain.
You're going to need to spell this out, because I do not see how the word "Spain" demonstrates that wealth distirbution somehow "destroys value".

You are making the standard mistake of thinking money has value.
You are trying to argue that money does not have value, but are also clutching your pearls at the idea of its value being, somehow, destroyed. You have a very absurd position to defend.

At the level of society it does not--taking money doesn't create more for the average person, it just raises the price of what's already there.
The average person actually needs money. And not just in their pockets, but money distributed toward the functioning of critical infrastructure, services, and the maintenance of knowledge. Mr Musk does not need money, beyond whatever he has his money manager extract from his imaginary hoard to fund whatever he thinks he needs in his daily life, an infinitessimally small withdrawal from a largely fictitious bank. But the common person absolutely needs money, and taxation is the means by which any government fulfills its obligations to its citizens. At the level of society.

If you want to call that "taking money", you can, but I'll think you're pretty stupid if you do, because the basic notion of taxation, and why it is not equivalent to thievery, is simple enough for most children to understand, let alone any adult. I am bored to tears with conservatives pretending not to understand the notion of an investment in society, it really is not that complicated.
 
I have been wondering about the "buy, borrow, die" schemes and taxing wealth could work.
What is the buy borrow die scheme?
I think he means when billionaires buy an expensive mansion and then borrow against it for their cash flow and daily liquidity. That way they never have to touch any of their company assets or pay income tax. Their loan is completely tax deductable:

    • Buy: Acquire appreciating assets such as stocks, real estate, businesses, or art. Unrealized gains generally are not taxed until the asset is sold. [1, 2, 3]
    • Borrow: Use appreciated assets as collateral for loans—such as a securities-backed line of credit (SBLOC), margin loan, or real estate refinance—to access cash. Because loans are debt rather than income, borrowing typically does not trigger capital gains tax or count as taxable income. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Die: Hold assets until death so heirs receive a step-up in basis (under IRC §1014), resetting the cost basis to fair market value at death and wiping out capital gains tax on lifetime appreciation. Outstanding loans remain obligations of the estate and are paid off using estate funds or pledged assets
I did the math on this a while back, it does not work. You end up paying more in interest than you save in taxes when figured over a generation.

But there is a related thing that does make sense: they got where they were because their companies were growing rapidly. Anyone whose company is growing like that is better off living on margin loans rather than selling stock. But that would apply regardless of the estate tax. The estate tax step-up is simply not big enough to offset a generation's worth of interest.
 
M4A is also a very complex policy proposal where the devil is in the details.
It's hard to do so we should not do it. There's that American spirit. (y)
So you don't care if something's possible? You want it so it must be possible?
Good grief. You do know most first world countries already have universal healthcare, right?
So? That doesn't make the M4A numbers work. They're still based on false economics.
The basic problem is the government already forces Medicaid/Medicare to accept lower reimbursement, often below cost. This shifts costs onto private insurance. Decree Medicare for all and you'll find everyone becoming cash only. Same reason we can't simply mandate UHC drug prices in the US.
It's Medicaid that has providers working at a loss. With MFA there would be no need for Medicaid. I also assume Medicare reimbursements would be increased as the plan gets implemented.
And why in the world would you expect that?? Congress keeps cutting Medicare reimbursements, not raising them. Remove competition and there's even less reason to fix the problem until it blows up badly. Just because that's what's needed doesn't mean that's what would happen! You have a very starry-eyed view of what government actually does.
It certainly appears that The Felon actually managed to get one right (although in the past when I though he had pulled off a stopped clock it turned out not to be) in trying to equalize drug prices. And we see what might be a canary: discontinuing a drug in Canada which will leave it only available in the US. Sounds like Canada wasn't willing to pay a fair share.
Many people get their medications from Canada because they cannot afford the equivalent in the US. Trump stopped that and you think it's a good thing?
Read!

That's not what I'm talking about. So far it's only one and they're not saying why--but it certainly looks like Canada wouldn't agree on the price and the drug company decided the best option was to pull out of the market.

Companies pulling out of markets is a red alert. It usually means regulators have made it impossible to make a profit and thus that things are already way out of shape. Look at what's been happening with homeowner's insurance--insurance companies respond to local threats by raising prices in areas exposed to that threat. When the threat is high (hurricane, wildfire) the homeowners scream, the state tends to respond by forcing insurance companies to not properly price risk, but this raises prices for everyone. Then the state starts pressuring them to keep prices down. Eventually they start closing up shop and insurance becomes unavailable.
 
The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.

I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.

We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.
Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Technicality. Doesn't change the basic issue. He made electric cars a practical option.
 
To drain something would have to be extracted. That's not happening. You still want to eat future production. It doesn't exist yet--and probably will never exist. It's just numbers on paper that will disappear when the AI bubble pops.
How does it benefit us to let that imaginary money fuck off to the Caymans when the bubble bursts, instead of funding our critical infrastructure and services?
How does imaginary money do anything?

What Bezos and Musk have is people who think they will produce value in the future. The money does not yet exist, what you're trying to take is the right to collect future earnings, but you imagine that somehow you can use that to do something now.
 
The money does not yet exist, what you're trying to take is the right to collect future earnings, but you imagine that somehow you can use that to do something now.
Yes. Because if they use it to pay their taxes, their useless imaginary hoard - which was real enough when the used it to raid the national treasury to enrich themselves at our expense, pushing the state into a $2 Billion dollar shortfall for no fucking reason - will be used to do useful things instead of useless things.
 
M4A is also a very complex policy proposal where the devil is in the details.
It's hard to do so we should not do it. There's that American spirit. (y)
So you don't care if something's possible? You want it so it must be possible?
Good grief. You do know most first world countries already have universal healthcare, right?
So? That doesn't make the M4A numbers work. They're still based on false economics.
Really? I don't see anyone that has actually published numbers on the plan as of yet. Where are you getting numbers from?

The basic problem is the government already forces Medicaid/Medicare to accept lower reimbursement, often below cost. This shifts costs onto private insurance. Decree Medicare for all and you'll find everyone becoming cash only. Same reason we can't simply mandate UHC drug prices in the US.
It's Medicaid that has providers working at a loss. With MFA there would be no need for Medicaid. I also assume Medicare reimbursements would be increased as the plan gets implemented.
And why in the world would you expect that?? Congress keeps cutting Medicare reimbursements, not raising them. Remove competition and there's even less reason to fix the problem until it blows up badly. Just because that's what's needed doesn't mean that's what would happen! You have a very starry-eyed view of what government actually does.
It certainly appears that The Felon actually managed to get one right (although in the past when I though he had pulled off a stopped clock it turned out not to be) in trying to equalize drug prices. And we see what might be a canary: discontinuing a drug in Canada which will leave it only available in the US. Sounds like Canada wasn't willing to pay a fair share.
Many people get their medications from Canada because they cannot afford the equivalent in the US. Trump stopped that and you think it's a good thing?
Read!

That's not what I'm talking about. So far it's only one and they're not saying why--but it certainly looks like Canada wouldn't agree on the price and the drug company decided the best option was to pull out of the market.
Frankly I have no idea what you are talking about.

All I know is that people all over the country have been stopped from getting needed medications at an affordable price from Canada and cannot afford the US price.

 
There is evidence that musk overstayed his visa and worked without legal authorization. You can look it up or I can paste it in here but it would be a longer post.
Or since you are making the claim that there is such evidence, perhaps you could provide such evidence.

With the assumption that you understand the difference between “evidence” and “proof”, here is evidence that Elon overstayed his visa and worked illegally (Gemini-produced information):

  • Stanford Enrollment: In 1995, Musk was accepted into a graduate program at Stanford University, moved to Palo Alto, and informed the school two days into the semester that he would not attend classes. [1, 2, 3]
  • Building Zip2: Immediately after leaving Stanford in 1995, Musk began building his first company, Global Link Information Network (later renamed Zip2). [1, 2]
  • Investor Ultimatum: According to Zip2 company documents and former CEO Derek Proudian, when venture capital firm Mohr Davidow Ventures invested $3 million in 1996, they discovered neither Elon nor his brother Kimbal had proper legal work authorization. The investors gave the brothers a 45-day deadline to obtain legal work status so the founders would not face deportation or derail the company.[1, 2]
  • Musk's 2005 Email: In a 2005 email sent during a defamation lawsuit—which was entered into court records and obtained by The Washington Post—Musk wrote that he applied to Stanford because he "had no money for a lab and no legal right to stay in the country" otherwise. [1, 2]
  • Kimbal Musk's Admissions: Elon's brother and Zip2 co-founder, Kimbal Musk, has stated on the record in interviews that they were "illegal immigrants" during the early days of Zip2. [1, 2]

As to your next statement:

And explain why overstaying a student visa to start a business is a worse offense than people who have a felony record and have been deported previously crossing the border illegally (and then being protected by sanctuary cities).
I made no such claim so I need not offer an explanation

Edited to add: keep in my mind that we agreed my response was inappropriate relative to what Toni said, so I am only addressing the very narrow scope of whether Elon has committed any crimes. I am presenting evidence of one of them and nothing more. Since my comments are outside the scope of the discussion you were having with Toni about billionaires being “above the law” I will bow out having provided the evidence you asked for, because I felt that you would not look it up on your own and would assume there was no such evidence if I chose not to present it here.
 
Last edited:
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
According to New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, estate tax is not a wealth tax; it's a tax on the privilege of transferring your property at death. That's why it isn't a direct unapportioned tax, which would have made it unconstitutional.
It is a percentage of wealth which logically makes it a tax on wealth.
It is a percentage of the amount transferred which logically makes it a tax on the transfer; the circumstance that the amount transferred was 100% of the owner's assets is incidental. If some heiress blows her entire fortune on cosmetic surgery then the sales tax the state collects is a percentage of her wealth, but that does not logically makes it a tax on wealth.
Basic application of logic indicates it is a tax on transferred wealth.
Bomb#20 said:
For what it's worth, Oliver Wendell Holmes disagreed with you, and it was a 9-0 ruling.
So? Neither Justice Holmes nor the SCOTUS infallible. The mental gyrations required to satisfy law are not binding outside of legal discussions.
 

No. I think those who commit crimes should be charged by the appropriate legal authorities.
Except that we have "legal authorities" that shield illegals, including criminal illegals, from consequences.
But I also understand that this is a complicated situation in which federal authorities have harassed non-criminals in certain ways and it is not clear to me that state or municipal law enforcement necessarily need to be required to assist the feds.
You either have local law enforcement assist the feds in apprehending wanted illegals, or ICE itself needs to conduct raids and other operations. Neither solution is perfect, but I think the former is preferable. Unfortunately, it has become anathema among Dem run cities to render any assistance in immigration enforcement.
And it goes even beyond not rendering assistance, and into actively obstructing.

I, personally, believe that local authorities *should* cooperate with federal authorities as necessary to provide benefit and safety to the community. I think that cooperation between professional law enforcement agencies that are acting in good faith and in accordance with the laws and the Constitution would provide that benefit.

So, while I believe that criminals should not be “protected” I also understand the basis for some of rhe decisions by certain cities.
Do you think e.g. San Francisco acted appropriately in the case of García Zárate? He entered US illegally and became involved in heroin trafficking, for which he was convicted and deported repeatedly. And reentering the US after previous deportation is an additional felony.
In 2015 (Obama was president then, mind you) García Zárate was caught crossing the border illegally and placed in federal custody. San Francisco requested him for prosecution on a drug charge, but instead of returning him to the feds, being a sanctuary city, they released him.
That's when he found a gun and killed an innocent woman with it. A SF jury let him get away with murder, but that's another issue. He never should have been released in the first place.

I am not familiar with this case and I would have to look into it more deeply before commenting on it as I will not assume that you are providing a thorough enough and unbiased summary for me to properly assess.

I think that is the feds operated in professional, good faith manners, which they often have not, especially under the current administration, there would be little to no need for these so-called “sanctuary cities”.
Sanctuary cities existed well before Trump descended that escalator. The failed immigration system and Republicans like ¡Jeb! "illegal immigration is an act of love" Bush are a big part of why Trump was able to win in the first place.
I said *especially* under the current administration. I made no claim that "sanctuary cities" did not exist prior to Trump's administration.
 
Back
Top Bottom