- Joined
- Oct 22, 2002
- Messages
- 50,894
- Location
- Frozen in Michigan
- Gender
- Old Fart
- Basic Beliefs
- Don't be a dick.
Did she mention the almost five hundred million dollar loan from the government?Musk turned the company around much more than just advances in batteries! My daughter wrote her MBA on this. He injected substantial working capital into the company, hired a great management team, secured steady bank financing, dramatically ramped up the marketing, and etc. he completely overhauled the supply chain, and etc.Doesn't negate what I said.Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.We are all better off because of Musk and many other billionaires. Even if you do not own a Tesla car we are better off because the quality of the air is better and less other people are buying gas so your gas price is lower. The earth is better off because of Musk. We are also better off because Bill Gates gave us computer software and better off for the chips Nvidia produces as well. Yes, there are some bad billionaires like Carl Icahn who did actually pirate their wealth from the backs of others. But for the most part the billionaires have produced many of the best goods all of society enjoys today.TherWho is better off—aside from the billionaires?I can almost completely agree with you Politesse. Except that you leave out one important point. Most billionaires did not actually seize vast pools of existing capital. They either got lucky or they took on extreme risk (that ordinary people shun). Taking Musk or Howard Hughes as easy examples, both of them both bet all of their small fortunes on future visions when normal people would have quit and retired.
Nonsense. No one becomes a billionaire because of individual exchanges of labor for pay. The very idea is nonsensical. Extreme wealth can only be generated by seizing vast pools of existing capital and institutional control over capital investments, monetary production, and the means of exchange and production. Jensen Huang didn't personally make graphics cards. He doesn't even know how. Even his company does not, for the most part. They create and sell technology, as a corporate (communal) entity that contracts with other companies to facilitate production of graphics cards and now other related technologies, drawing investor interest by incorporating them into new spheres. None of this requires Jensen Huang the person, nor any of his labor. He occupied a corporate office, which is now occupied by another. But he gets to keep his billions. Madison Huang will also be a billionaire before she dies. Why? Because she is Jensen Huang's daughter. She is not a skilled manager, engineer, or tradesman. She's Jensen Huang's daughter. A leech, in short. But you're panicking at the thought that she might have to pay taxes on the wealth she inherits? Why? Why does she have any more claim on those billions than anyone else? And what could she possibly need them for, that her present millions cannot provide her?To become a multibillionaire means one of four things. It means people paid you billions of dollars in exchange for you providing them with goods or services they liked better than keeping their billions of dollars.
I note that Huang himself has never minded paying tax on his wealth, and often says as much.
And it was this rare quality of their willingness to extremely expose their then existing (millions) wealth that then formed a basis for the billions they produced.
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
Did the now billionaires engage in fair business practices? Did they fairly compensate contractors, suppliers and employees?
Why should families not be able to pass along wealth? Should a farmer not be able to bequeath the homestead and farmland attached to his designated heirs? Should an ordinary person who works hard, invests wisely and dies with a few million docked away for their own retirement t not be allowed to bequeath that savings to designated heirs if they die before exhausting their funds?
So its OK to be a billionaire like Sam Walton. Sam himself produced something good. And it is OK to leave your small or medium size farm to your kids. But it is not OK for Sam Walton's non productive progeny to enjoy privileges into the distant future until the pyramids fall. That is the kind of billionaires we should be going after IMO.
I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.