• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

The air is not better. I'm glad that we have EV vehicles and hybrids now and hope that more progress is forthcoming. But having hybrids and EV vehicles is not because of Musk. He didn't design them.

I would bet two cents on Musk's ethics or business acumen.
The air is better. I can remember visiting LA back in the 1970's and the smog then was so thick your visibility was less than 1 mile. The air in southern California is much cleaner today.

We would not have any electric cars without Musk. Even when GM was prosperous it tried several times and failed each time. Until Musk arrived, no auto company in the world would touch manufacturing an electric car.
Musk bought into a company that was already building electric cars. You been told this before. And I still see Chevy Volts on the road. What made electric cars more viable was advances in battery technology.
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Technicality. Doesn't change the basic issue. He made electric cars a practical option.
Strange. I still see Chevy Volts on the roads around here. Musk did what, again?
Do you mean Bolt? The Volt is a hybrid not an electric car, and it has been discontinued by Chevy, I believe.
 
Show your evidence she said only billionaires sh You made the claim she said only billionaires should be taxed. Produce the quote or stop misrepresenting her.
You know the quote. Your problem is not finding the quote, but that you only seem capable of surface level reading. At least when it benefits your apologetics. Saying that it is "crazy" that she has to pay taxes (and student loans) because she is not making billions of dollars is implying that only billionaires should be taxed. Just because she did not say verbatim does not mean that it is not a corollary of what she said.
How dare you actually think?! You must not look at the implications!
 
There is evidence that musk overstayed his visa and worked without legal authorization. You can look it up or I can paste it in here but it would be a longer post.
Or since you are making the claim that there is such evidence, perhaps you could provide such evidence.
I think it's adequately established.
And explain why overstaying a student visa to start a business is a worse offense than people who have a felony record and have been deported previously crossing the border illegally (and then being protected by sanctuary cities).
I wouldn't care about the overstay if he wasn't anti-immigrant.

But you do not understand about sanctuary cities. It's not a matter of protecting them, it's a matter of the city operating better when the residents of the city do not fear contact with the authorities.
Again, while Trump's ICE certainly overreached, there is a legitimate concern with illegal immigration that helped Trump get elected both times. And yet, it looks increasingly like Dems want to overreach themselves on this issue, and others.
In 2020 Dem presidential candidates were in a sort of competition over who would be more supportive of illegals. I think it is only COVID that prevented Trump from being reelected in a landslide, because those 2019 debates were embarrassing.
Nope. The Republicans are responsible for the problem, not the Democrats. The thing is the Republicans absolutely refused to permit anything to be done so they could use it as a campaign issue. That makes it their fault.

As for 2020--no, what we saw in 2020 was a lesser version of the blue tsunami from last month. Enough people saw he was bad. And his dismissal of the Covid threat certainly didn't help him.
But I also understand that this is a complicated situation in which federal authorities have harassed non-criminals in certain ways and it is not clear to me that state or municipal law enforcement necessarily need to be required to assist the feds.
You either have local law enforcement assist the feds in apprehending wanted illegals, or ICE itself needs to conduct raids and other operations. Neither solution is perfect, but I think the former is preferable. Unfortunately, it has become anathema among Dem run cities to render any assistance in immigration enforcement.
And it goes even beyond not rendering assistance, and into actively obstructing.
The problem is the former means people who have done nothing illegal (overstay is not actually a crime) fear contact with the authorities. Means they are driving uninsured etc.

I don't think most of us object to the concept of ICE arresting illegals. Where the problem comes is we now have the Gestapo using AI slop to arrest "criminals". And with no regard for acceptable use of force. They're going for the easy ones--the ones who are behaving, many of whom have pending cases that should preclude deportation. The known criminals were caught early on.
So, while I believe that criminals should not be “protected” I also understand the basis for some of rhe decisions by certain cities.
Do you think e.g. San Francisco acted appropriately in the case of García Zárate? He entered US illegally and became involved in heroin trafficking, for which he was convicted and deported repeatedly. And reentering the US after previous deportation is an additional felony.
In 2015 (Obama was president then, mind you) García Zárate was caught crossing the border illegally and placed in federal custody. San Francisco requested him for prosecution on a drug charge, but instead of returning him to the feds, being a sanctuary city, they released him.
That's when he found a gun and killed an innocent woman with it. A SF jury let him get away with murder, but that's another issue. He never should have been released in the first place.
The thing is it's not as clear cut as you think it is.
I think that is the feds operated in professional, good faith manners, which they often have not, especially under the current administration, there would be little to no need for these so-called “sanctuary cities”.
Sanctuary cities existed well before Trump descended that escalator. The failed immigration system and Republicans like ¡Jeb! "illegal immigration is an act of love" Bush are a big part of why Trump was able to win in the first place.
The Republicans caused the failed system.

They've been starving it for ages, that causes a huge backlog. Surprise, there's a huge backlog.
 
At the risk of derailing yet another derail...

My opinion of Jeffries was pretty positive before this thread. What I learned here improved it.
Yesterday I heard an interview with a political writer who is familiar with him. Totally sold me. Jeffries is a solid centrist, level headed leader, and very competent administrator. The biggest concern the writer had was that Jeffries might not be able to corral the Democrats enough to get things done as well as might be.
Sounds good to me.
Tom
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
Who wants to bring down Walmart? I’d like to see Walmart be much more responsible with their labor practices and to lay the hell off demanding tax abatements while demanding access roads and utilities be installed at taxpayer expense. To provide cheap goods and drive local small businesses out of business. But hey—They can go work for Walmart and earn $7.50/hr no benefits, part time hours at employer’s pleasure so don’t go thinking you can fill in the gaps with another part time job. Oh, and you get to come to ‘tread meetings’ where you pledge allegiance to Walmart.

I mean—I would not cry if Walmart disappeared. I don’t shop there. But I know plenty of people who do.

No: I want income to be taxed in a more progressive way. I want tax code to be re-written to close loop holes and with higher tiers of income taxed. I want the cap on SS contributions to be raised significantly. I want it to be impossible for uber wealthy people to get tax write offs for personal and company jets, multiple homes, wardrobe and entertainment, etc. Also charitable contributions.
Walmart starting pay here in my small city in Georgia is 15 bucks an hour, not great, but certainly much better than the minimum wage. Plus the girls who work at the small assisted living facility where I volunteer only make 10 bucks an hour. That bothers me much more as their job is much harder and more stressful than most jobs at Walmart. I know the starting pay at Walmart because the son of a close friend of mine works there. He loves his job and was recently promoted to assistant manager of some type. I'm not saying working for Walmart is great, but at least let's get the pay right. My friend works in a shoe store and only makes 18 bucks an hour. She's been working there for about 10 years. She does have some benefits and pays about 400 bucks a month for health insurance. She likes her job, but I think she deserves much more than she gets. I do agree agree that the minimum wage needs to be raised to about 20 an hour, but I don't think anyone makes less than 10 an hour these days.
Walmart may be paying more now —the pandemic tended to raise wages without places like Walmart going out of business.

I agree that working in a nursing home would be difficult stressful work. I’m grateful for everyone who does this work. To say that $10/hr is inadequate is a grotesque understatement.

But I think you ( and most people) vastly underestimate the stress in working retail —or any food service job. Both physically demanding and tremendously stressful because of dealing with the public constantly.
 
1) We do not have hoarded stockpiles. You're seeing numbers and thinking there's something behind them. No, it's predicted (probably quite wishfully) future value, there's nothing there.
That is a childish view unconnected to economics as it is observed in the real world. I do not know how to convince you that however it is constructed, abstracted, and redistributed, currency is incredibly important to the life of a nation that uses it as its basic medium of exchange.
Which is not remotely relevant to my point.
We do have an example of something akin to hoarded stockpiles being distributed. It was very, very bad for Spain.
You're going to need to spell this out, because I do not see how the word "Spain" demonstrates that wealth distirbution somehow "destroys value".
Are you not aware of what happened to Spain with all the gold looted from the New World?
You are making the standard mistake of thinking money has value.
You are trying to argue that money does not have value, but are also clutching your pearls at the idea of its value being, somehow, destroyed. You have a very absurd position to defend.
Money has value to individuals, but to society it's simply measuring how you slice up the pie. What matters is the balance of money vs what it can buy, adding money does not create more. In this case, you're trying to redistribute future pie to current use. No, you can't eat next year's pie!
At the level of society it does not--taking money doesn't create more for the average person, it just raises the price of what's already there.
The average person actually needs money. And not just in their pockets, but money distributed toward the functioning of critical infrastructure, services, and the maintenance of knowledge. Mr Musk does not need money, beyond whatever he has his money manager extract from his imaginary hoard to fund whatever he thinks he needs in his daily life, an infinitessimally small withdrawal from a largely fictitious bank. But the common person absolutely needs money, and taxation is the means by which any government fulfills its obligations to its citizens. At the level of society.

If you want to call that "taking money", you can, but I'll think you're pretty stupid if you do, because the basic notion of taxation, and why it is not equivalent to thievery, is simple enough for most children to understand, let alone any adult. I am bored to tears with conservatives pretending not to understand the notion of an investment in society, it really is not that complicated.
You are not addressing my point at all.

And you're the one who is trying to kill investment. Specifically, private investment. Governments have a bad track record on investing--sometimes you have to anyway because it's a public resource that would not otherwise be done, but it should never be considered the best approach.
 
Wow. You are defending someone who knowingly, willingly and deliberately violated campaign finance laws at least 34 times.

Who was then found guilty of said charges.

WOW.
34 was throwing the book at him. There was one fundamental act sliced into 34 separate steps.

While he's certainly guilty I think this is the least of the cases. It's just he managed to block the big ones.
 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
He's spending like 1% on elections.
He spent. And I’m certain will do again, perhaps more next ho round.

The capacity to spend $432M on a single midterm cycle is far too much influence and power for any person or entity to have.

Btw, you really made everyone’s point re: the power of immense wealth.
 
What Bezos and Musk have is people who think they will produce value in the future.
In short, imaginary.
Bezos is--Amazon does not make a "profit" because the tax code makes it more favorable to use all your profits buying up companies--grows the future income without creating current income. Musk, agreed.

But that doesn't change the fact that you're trying to spend that future value. It's deficit spending, just hidden.
 
Wow. You are defending someone who knowingly, willingly and deliberately violated campaign finance laws at least 34 times.

Who was then found guilty of said charges.

WOW.
34 was throwing the book at him. There was one fundamental act sliced into 34 separate steps.

While he's certainly guilty I think this is the least of the cases. It's just he managed to block the big ones.
No. It was 34 separate incidents of doing the same crime. Do you believe a shoplifter caught several times should just be charged for one criminal act?
 
It's deficit spending, just hidden.
Were the tax dollars "real" when they stole them from us in the first place? The very specific provocation that Prop 40 was meant as a direct response to? Do the bank accounts of the wealthy magically turn our hard-earned income into their insubstantial and somehow untaxable future earnings once they have looted them?
 
I think that destroying value just so you can stick it to people wealthier than you think they should be allowed to be is an ideology built on envy.
Taxing redistributes value but does not necessarily destroy it. Taxing wealth has advantages and disadvantages. Whether it is a good or bad idea depends on the details and one's values.
All such schemes end up being about tearing down those above. And if you hand out the money to the people you just get inflation, coupled with an unwillingness to invest in new things.
5% of a billionaire's wealth is tearing them down? Stop sucking the wealthie's dicks. They don't give a shit about you.
I do not believe the one time bit. Revenue is highly addictive. They'll be back again. Camel's noses should be shot on sight.
 
I did the math on this a while back, it does not work. You end up paying more in interest than you save in taxes when figured over a generation.
Then why is it such a common practice among the super wealthy? Do you think these people do not have accountants for financial advice? What interest rate and terms did you use to make that calculation? What is your financial educational background?
And why do you assume it is so common??

I'm sure you've got Excel--easy enough to model it.
But there is a related thing that does make sense: they got where they were because their companies were growing rapidly. Anyone whose company is growing like that is better off living on margin loans rather than selling stock.
Or taking a salary that would be subject to a tax rate far higher than any bank loan.

Which is not a rebuttal to my point.

The reality is anyone who has an asset that's appreciating well above the cost of a margin loan is better off living on a margin loan.
 
What Bezos and Musk have is people who think they will produce value in the future.
In short, imaginary.
Bezos is--Amazon does not make a "profit" because the tax code makes it more favorable to use all your profits buying up companies--grows the future income without creating current income. Musk, agreed.

But that doesn't change the fact that you're trying to spend that future value. It's deficit spending, just hidden.
Which is why the tax code needs to be amended.

Uber wealthy persons (and corporations) have the capacity to utilize such maneuvers as you describe that are not available to smaller companies or less wealthy individuals.
 
The super wealthy entities paying tax in proportion to us plebes such that they actually fund the military, police, engineers, and all the other government services that they use is not “eating the rich”.

As for the richest of the individual people. All of their wealth is clearly not tied up in productive business providing goods, service , and employment. Otherwise Musk would not be able to afford to spend 100s of millions on individual elections over and over again.
He's spending like 1% on elections.
One percent of what?
His money. Spending 1% of your money does not mean most of it isn't tied up in something.

There's plenty to hate him for (his messing with Starshield should be considered treason), why do you keep going on about the little stuff? The left always claims to be about building people up, but the actual positions are always about tearing down those above.
 
But you are completely correct that we as a society treat capital much better than we do labor. And I also totally agree with you that extreme wealth should not be passed on future generations. Their should be no such thing as "the Rockefellers" or the "Duponts"..to wit the families born well after the original enterprise was produced. I agree with you they are all leaches and should find their own way just like the rest of us.
But here you get the problem that if you forbid inheritance the money gets spent on luxuries rather than on means of production. Society suffers. Eat the rich comes in a million guises, all of them bad. You think of money sitting there that can be taken--no, it's factories and whatnot. You can't convert that to consumer value without reducing future production. Seed corn is so tasty!
I sort of see where you are going and appreciate a different perspective. But I still fail to see how this would happen in practice. Lets take an easy example. If the government were to suddenly tax the hell out of the Wall Mart heirs how is that going to bring down Wal Mart at this point? Because when those heirs have to sell their stock to pay the government, other investment firms would buy those shares up. Different owners but the same successful business. At this point the Wal Mart heirs aren't doing anything in general to make Wal Mart continue as functioning enterprise.
Who wants to bring down Walmart? I’d like to see Walmart be much more responsible with their labor practices and to lay the hell off demanding tax abatements while demanding access roads and utilities be installed at taxpayer expense. To provide cheap goods and drive local small businesses out of business. But hey—They can go work for Walmart and earn $7.50/hr no benefits, part time hours at employer’s pleasure so don’t go thinking you can fill in the gaps with another part time job. Oh, and you get to come to ‘tread meetings’ where you pledge allegiance to Walmart.

I mean—I would not cry if Walmart disappeared. I don’t shop there. But I know plenty of people who do.

No: I want income to be taxed in a more progressive way. I want tax code to be re-written to close loop holes and with higher tiers of income taxed. I want the cap on SS contributions to be raised significantly. I want it to be impossible for uber wealthy people to get tax write offs for personal and company jets, multiple homes, wardrobe and entertainment, etc. Also charitable contributions.
Walmart starting pay here in my small city in Georgia is 15 bucks an hour, not great, but certainly much better than the minimum wage. Plus the girls who work at the small assisted living facility where I volunteer only make 10 bucks an hour. That bothers me much more as their job is much harder and more stressful than most jobs at Walmart. I know the starting pay at Walmart because the son of a close friend of mine works there. He loves his job and was recently promoted to assistant manager of some type. I'm not saying working for Walmart is great, but at least let's get the pay right. My friend works in a shoe store and only makes 18 bucks an hour. She's been working there for about 10 years. She does have some benefits and pays about 400 bucks a month for health insurance. She likes her job, but I think she deserves much more than she gets. I do agree agree that the minimum wage needs to be raised to about 20 an hour, but I don't think anyone makes less than 10 an hour these days.
Walmart may be paying more now —the pandemic tended to raise wages without places like Walmart going out of business.

I agree that working in a nursing home would be difficult stressful work. I’m grateful for everyone who does this work. To say that $10/hr is inadequate is a grotesque understatement.

But I think you ( and most people) vastly underestimate the stress in working retail —or any food service job. Both physically demanding and tremendously stressful because of dealing with the public constantly.
I know we've gone way off topic, but let me just say that I worked in retail for a few years and it was easy work for me. Working in healthcare was extremely stressful, which is probably why there is a huge shortage of workers in jobs related to nursing.

Still, I think all of these workers deserve far more pay and benefits. Now, let's get back on topic.

Since I don't get to vote on who leads Congress, I don't have any strong opinions. I just hope there will be good leadership, as it's not easy to herd cats. Considering that the Dems are a big tent party consisting of various ideologies, Dems are more like cats, while the Repubs are more like sheep.
 
Everyone takes risks, though. Every one of my students is taking an enormous risk to attend college, and they know it;
In what way do college students take on an "enormous risk"? Btw, what do you teach?
and those risks are a lot more personally serious than anything Elon Musk ever faced. If one of his companies fails, as they often have, he loses some face and a bit of funny money that was never really in his pocket to begin with. He's risking millions, true, when they are only risking thousands.
More like billions. And you are right that he can easily absorb losses from failed ventures now. But back when he first got on board Tesla, had he failed then it would have been far more consequential. More consequential than one of your students flunking out of college even.
But they are going without food for a week to afford a forced subscription to a textbook. He is not.
That's part of tuition and fees. And there are programs to help cover those costs. Scholarships, Pell Grants, student loans, work study.
And if one of my students faces down a terminal illness before the risk they took on tuition manifests as a salaried position, our health system will torture and eventually execute them for the crime of being poor.
That's a tad bit dramatic, don't you think?
These kinds of risk are both real, but if the claim is that billionaires deserve to outearn the average citizen by factor upon factor because their risks are monetarily greater, I don't agree. The fact that they are throwing millions after pet projects is an expression of how little risk they are really in, not how much.
The reason billionaire net worth is as high is because they start companies that grow very large very fast. If they have a substantial stake in the ownership, that stake becomes very valuable. It's not about "deserving" per se, but that it is a logical consequence of owning shares in a business. And a founder or early investor in a startup will usually own a substantial share of the business. I do not see how you can change that without either limiting a company size or somebody's ownership stake in a company.
I'm not asking for the deaths of all the Musks of the world, contrary to what Mr Beave may claim; only that those who control vast sums of wealth should be obliged to support the society that supported them so generously.
And there is nothing wrong with that in principle. There is much wrong with people thinking that billionaires are not taxed already, and with people saying that billionaires should be taxed out of existence.
This legislation wasn't a random act of socialism, but a one time response to a specific looting of the treasury, an imbalance in budgeting that these very people made, by exploiting their unearned position in the legislature to steal the wealth of a nation.
Interesting. Say more.
I know the law was written as a one-time tax (already weird) but I never read about supposed "looting of the [California] treasury" by (mostly Democratic politicians) who exploited "their unearned position in the legislature to steal the wealth of a nation [sic]". Surely that last word was supposed to be "state" or are you already assuming a secession or something?
I'm not surprised that the measure failed, but I don't think professors Galle et al were in the wrong for proposing it. There should be consequences when the wealthy act as though no law should apply to their horde.
There were many problems with this tax proposal. But I do not see how not having a one time state wealth tax means that laws do not apply to "their horde" (surely billionaires are not numerous enough to constitute a horde). Even as far as tax law, billionaires already pay both federal and state taxes.
 
Oh, I’m not a fan of musk, but he bought Tesla when it was weeks from bankruptcy. It completely turned it around.
Doesn't negate what I said.
Technicality. Doesn't change the basic issue. He made electric cars a practical option.
Strange. I still see Chevy Volts on the roads around here. Musk did what, again?
Electric cars had been pretty much a non-thing because lead-acid doesn't have the energy density to make a viable car (although plenty of short range lead-acid vehicles exist.) In making the Tesla he showed that li-ion is viable for a car, opening the door for the rest of the industry to also jump in. Same thing with the Falcon 9--showed the world that recovering the booster was viable. And did what many of us had been saying for ages--big, dumb boosters are effectively better than "good" boosters. Kerolox has a substantial performance penalty compared to hydrolox--but it's so much easier to handle that it's worth it. Once he did it the world woke up and they're trying to copy it.

And, as often happens, the copies end up being better than the original.
 
Wow. You are defending someone who knowingly, willingly and deliberately violated campaign finance laws at least 34 times.

Who was then found guilty of said charges.

WOW.
34 was throwing the book at him. There was one fundamental act sliced into 34 separate steps.

While he's certainly guilty I think this is the least of the cases. It's just he managed to block the big ones.
No. It was 34 separate incidents of doing the same crime. Do you believe a shoplifter caught several times should just be charged for one criminal act?
There was one actual wrongdoing: improper political contribution. This was 34 transactions to repay the improper contribution. They were prosecuted as dirty bookkeeping, but the actual wrong was the payoff, these were just covering the tracks.
 
It's deficit spending, just hidden.
Were the tax dollars "real" when they stole them from us in the first place? The very specific provocation that Prop 40 was meant as a direct response to? Do the bank accounts of the wealthy magically turn our hard-earned income into their insubstantial and somehow untaxable future earnings once they have looted them?
Again, you're showing it's about eat the rich. There was no theft in the first place--they built better mousetraps, people beat a path to their door. And that doesn't change the fact that it's still taking now that which actually exists only in the future.
 
Back
Top Bottom