Even liberal ideological groups contain some fascist thinkers. It's much more rare than it is among conservative groups, but it does happen. Reading that description, you can see how conservative ideologies attract people who think this way and why there would be a much stronger overlap of right wing thinkers with right wing ideology.
I would expect a strong overlap of right wing thinkers with right wing ideology. Just like I would expect a strong overlap of left wing thinkers with left wing ideology. No surprises there.
Thank you. But the point is to illustrate specifically that group ideology begins with individuals. Individuals whose cognitive repertoires lean toward us vs. them, authoritarian, fear-based, conformist, punitive mentality give rise to fascist group ideology. These are also individuals who are perfectly capable of questioning their own thoughts and contributions to the group ideology, but who find that more difficult as their own mentality AND the group ideology itself discourage questioning.
Individuals whose world view is inclusive, open, empathetic, open to change, and respectful of fairness and autonomy tend to form liberal, inclusive group ideologies, and will not likely support any form of fascism.
It seems you agree that fascist group ideology is not optimum for any society of human beings. Am I wrong to assume this? If not, then is it not useful to understand the roots of such ideologies? If my comment was merely stating the obvious, then we agree on the obvious and can we just move on with discussing the mentality that gives rise to fascism?
By "they" do I assume you mean ideologies? If so, sometimes they die, sometimes they don't. Fear and ignorance provide a rich soil for fascist thinking in individuals and therefore support for fascist views and policies. There's tons of research on how brains respond to fear. Fascism thrives on it.
Communism also thrives on fear and ignorance. Fascism is not the only ideology at risk.
You may be right. But I'm not defending communism here or anywhere. Narrowing the goal posts or changing them altogether is not helpful if we are to explore what gives rise to fascist ideologies. Again, that would be individual minds that see the world in us vs. them, authoritarian, fear-based, punitive terms. And again, such a mentality can exist under any ideology, although it is rare among left wing, liberal ideologies.
Education, challenging our own beliefs (as opposed to automatically justifying them) and standing up to authoritarianism are the antidotes to fascism authoritarianism of all stripes.
FIFY
You prefer the word authoritarianism to fascism? I don't see the point, but fine. Makes little difference to me. What does make a difference is understanding the distinction between an
individual fascist mentality and inherently fascist group
ideologies, and the relationship between them.
It's easy to point out authoritarian ideologies that have made history in the disastrous and tragic results they brought to humankind. Anyone can do that.
It is not so easy or intuitive to acknowledge the source of such ideologies in our own heads, and in not acknowledging the fact that we all share the capacity for such thinking, those who cannot or will not question their own world view inadvertently create an environment in which authoritarian ideologies can arise and thrive (until the more humane minds among them rise up and fight to change the system OR enough people suffer and die that the system breaks and its failure cannot be denied).
The left leaning liberal mentality is more open to change. Cultural values play a strong role in fostering or discouraging our responses as well.
I've not noticed in Australia that the left leaning liberal mentality is more open to change. Could you sent some of your water over here?
:laughing-smiley-014
As you damn well know, Tigers, "Liberal" in Australian politics refers to the party of conservatives. Please. You know that when I say "liberal" I am using the general definition in describing a liberal mentality and world view (see description above), which, in Australia, is prevalent among the Labor party politicians and supporters. The Labor party in Australia is a democratic socialist party. How this semantic switcharoo came about in Australia, I don't know, but I'm not at all confused by it. Are you?
I'd like to add that what I see from liberal minded, left wing Australians is stuff like fighting to free refugees from Nauru, and fighting against the authoritarian policies that allow abuse and the continued inhumanity of their captivity.
Challenging our beliefs includes questioning our intrinsic regard for our fellow human beings. Demonization is how fascistauthoritarianism-leaning minds justify their punitive attitudes toward others. Some people are open hearted toward all other humans and not as likely to support punitive or divisive policies toward whole groups of people, and some people don't really have the wherewithal to even consider that all those horrible people on the other side of their pet issues are fully human. It's very easy to whittle away the rights of people you already believe are evil or somehow inferior to your in-group, and when this kind of thinking is encouraged by whoever or whatever you believe to be your authority, you’ll likely go along with all manner of injustice toward others. We humans are capable of a great deal of irrational and inhumane behavior when our in-group encourages it.
FIFY
Again, an irrelevant semantic peeve on your part, unless you'd like to explain further why you want to distance the definition of "authoritarianism" from "fascism."
Looking at history and current events around the world, it seems hit or miss as to whether these antidotes will be effective. Whole nations of people can be caught off guard when war and other violent events happen quickly, or when worn down by stress of continued poverty and hardship. Even those who are fully aware of the danger of fascist leaders and policies and are very conscious of their opposition to it are often helpless to do anything or too afraid of consequences. "Might is right" is the mantra of fascists.
That's quite a large bee in your bonnet about fascism, presumably in the USA. I must play more attention as I have missed the explosive growth of fascism therein.
(Unless of course anyone who disagrees with you is a fascist then your concern becomes understandable.)
Nice try. I suggest you do pay more attention.
I do, however, freely admit that I am as subject to negativity bias as anyone, and my strong distaste for us vs. them, fear-based, authoritarian, conformist ideology probably does serve to exaggerate the problem in my mind.
When faced with the reality of numerous states going broke due to right wing economic policies, women in red states dying and suffering on par with Afghanistan, El Salvador, and South Sudan, hate for gays written into state legislation, states under Republican policy sinking in terms of education and health, etc., yes, I often need to stop and remind myself that the US also includes a great deal of inclusiveness, openness, disinclination to punishment, capacity for questioning, kindness, intelligence, and curiosity in our population.