So surprising that Biden wants the first state he won to be first.
Yeah. It's pretty on the nose. It would also help his Veep Kamala in either 2024 or 2028.
But it'd be better than Iowa/NH.
Why? Iowa/NH are better suited for retail politics. NH (1M) because it is small, and Iowa (3M) (being bigger than NH but still smaller than either mean (6.6M) or median (4.5M) state population) has the more participatory caucus which reduces the advantage better known and heeled candidates have in a primary system. It is no coincidence Obama and Bernie outdid uninspiring establishment candidate Hillary in the states that had cauci.
The currently proposed schedule Dem leadership does away with this tradition of retail politics, favoring establishment favorites. I do not think either Bill Clinton or Obama would have been nominated using this calendar. There would be even more uninspiring candidates like John Kerry and Hillary.
I think making SC first, and following it up with largeish states like GA and MI is a horrible idea on multiple levels.
I know the selling point of South Carolina is that it has a lot of black people. The idea being that more black people --> better, no matter what, which is just racist nonsense of course. While "only" about 1/4 of South Carolinians are black, more than half of all the Democrats are. That makes SC very lopsided compared to nationwide electorate that any candidate must appeal to in the general election. Democratic electorate is more black than general election electorate, obviously, so a candidate having support among SC primary voters is not telling you that much. Contrast that with Iowa, which is ~5% black, which would put Iowa Democrats at ~10% black or close to that. That is not far off from ~13% black share of US population. So Iowa is much better reflection of the overall electorate than SC.
At least for Democrats. Republicans are the opposite. They should want states with many blacks to go early, because then their early primary voter pool would closer resemble national electorate than if states like Iowa and NH go first. I.e. the wrong party is making this move.
SC is also a very Republican state. Trump carried the state with 55% both times and last time the state was carried by a Dem was 1976. There is also only one Dem in their congressional delegation - Jim Clyburn - for whose support it seems Biden is still making payments.
Another thing - Obama barely winning Iowa and coming very close in NH showed everybody that he is a viable general election candidate and that his race would not be a detriment. If SC went first, I do not think he would have won that state, and even if he did it would not have sent the message it did simply because how vastly different SC Dem electorate is from US demographics at large.