Arctish
Centimillionaire
You provided sources that debunked your claims, as I have shown. Repeatedly.
I must have missed the quotes and links. Please repost them. All I saw was you pointing out that CNN said it was unable to verify the report at the time it published that article, not that the other sources hadn't verified it.
Here's one for starters: The Jerusalem Post, it in their Timeline of 2012 Gaza escalations:
Emphasis added. They do not know either, since, for the millionth time, there never was an independent investigation into this case.
No matter how many newspaper articles you post, they all go back to the same claims by the family and the Hamas.
Btw, one possibility I just thought of. If the doctor (who supposedly treated the kid) is right abut the 2mm holes in the kid's chest, then what could account for it is that he and his friends were building a nail bomb and it exploded accidentally. A small finishing nail would be the right size.
Just because you don't know what happened doesn't mean you can just make shit up.
The CNN article about the same incident you posted earlier said that there was NO EVIDENCE they were killed while playing soccer. Since the stadium was used by Hamas to launch rockets into Israel, much more likely they were a rocket launch team. The dead teenagers, 16-18 years old, are certainly the right age to be Hamas terrorists.Middle East Monitor, among other news outlets, reported the deaths of the boys playing soccer 2 days later: Remembering Israel’s ‘Operation Pillar of Defence
Just because you don't know what happened doesn't mean you can just make shit up.
And just because they were in the same general area, as were the mourners at a funeral, doesn't mean they had anything to do with an attack.
The shelling on the 10th was reportedly in response to a Hamas anti-tank round hitting a Jeep and wounding several Israeli soldiers. So unless Hamas has some guys with freaking incredible aim, that could hit a (moving?) vehicle on the Israeli side of the border from the middle of a stadium, it really isn't plausible to simultaneously claim that hitting the Jeep was intentional and the round came from there. Or to accuse people who happened to be in the area of being complicit.
Besides, MEMO is a pro-Hamas rag.
Ad Hominem. Even if it is a pro-Hamas rag, that doesn't mean the report isn't factual.
I do not claim to know what exactly happened to the kid. I was just showing that we do not know what happened. And I stand by that.There are other reports that back up my statements. Show me the ones that back up yours.
And your posts are standard Hamas apologist boilerplate. I showed the evil doings of Hamas, that were known or should have been known to Ilhan Omar. I also showed that the Hamas claim that Israel is somehow almost starving Gazans is a vicious lie.I'm not even going to bother with the rest of your post. It just looks like standard Zionist apologist boilerplate with a side order of undated, sourceless videos and pictures.
No, you just showed you aren't reading my posts with comprehension and are trying to insert your own claims into them.
Israel wasn't letting the Gazans starve but it was diverting donated aid and not allowing it to be delivered as it arrived. I said I believed Omar was aware of it, and that her personal history probably led her to look very unfavorably on Israel for doing it. .
No, that was the whole tweet. Nothing partial about it.We got off onto this discussion when you claimed Ilhan Omar is anti-Semitic and posted a partial tweet in which she criticized the 'evil doings' of Israel as proof.
You didn't post the whole tweet until after I asked for it. I knew part was missing because I remembered seeing it elsewhere, but I didn't know when she sent it and suspected that the date was important.
And when it was pointed out that the tweet was sent during Operation Pillar of Defense and her personal experiences of war in Somalia and as a refugee in Kenya probably factored into her reaction, you completely ignored that part. All you did was post the same brainless Israel = Jews, therefore criticism of Israeli policy = anti-Semitism dogma we've seen a thousand times.
Nobody said that Israel==Jews. So let's drop that straw man right away.
She is opposing Israel for defending itself, something any country has a right to do.Even so, she's clearly criticizing Israel, not expressing anti-Semitism.
She is only opposing Israel's right to defend itself, which makes it antisemitic.
Antisemites these days like to hide behind claims that they are only "ant-zionist". Do not be deceived by that.
It isn't anti-Semitic unless you are conflating Israel with Jews.
Criticism of a nation's policies isn't the same thing as prejudice against the ethnic identity of it inhabitants. It isn't even related. For example, if I oppose China's takeover of Tibet and criticize the Chinese government for 'evil acts' there, that isn't evidence I am prejudiced against the Chinese. It might be true that I'm anti-Asiatic, but my criticism of China's policy isn't evidence of it, even if I only ever criticize China and not, say, Russia's takeover of Crimea.
I know that the tweet was sent during the Operation Pillar of Defense. I can read dates on tweets. My point is that she calls Israel defending themselves "evil doings" but Hamas shooting 1500 rockets at Israeli civilians, not to mention the long history of Hamas terrorist attacks (like the Sbarro bombing) and the well known genocidal goals of Hamas warrant no condemnation by her. Why such blatant onesidedness?
I do not see why her experiences in Somalia and Kenya should cause her to exaggerate Israel's fault while completely ignoring the truly "evil doings" of Hamas. Other than anti-Semitism of course.
Again, why is she ignoring the EVIL DOINGS OF HAMAS. Why are you, laughing dog and Ilhan Omar so hypnotized by them?
Perhaps it's because the Gazans didn't drive Israelis into refugees camps, isolate and imprison them, divert humanitarian aid to them, and carelessly if not deliberately kill their teenagers. Perhaps it's for some other reason. Perhaps her position is actually quite moral, balanced, and nuanced but the racist Islamophobes on 4chan don't care about that so you never read about it.
And I wouldn't be so sure she doesn't condemn Hamas if I were you:
The Washington Post said:Ilhan Omar, the congresswoman President Trump’s chanting mob would deport to Africa, sat onstage Tuesday with fellow Muslims, before an audience of Muslims, taking questions from Muslims.
And what she said was quintessentially American.
The head of a group called Muslims for Progressive Values rose to say that “it would be really powerful if the two Muslim congresswomen” — Omar (D-Minn.) and Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) — spoke out against the practice of female genital mutilation.
Omar silenced the room by calling the question “appalling.” Noting that she already “put out statements upon statements” on the topic, she said she’s “quite disgusted, to be honest, that as Muslim legislators we are constantly being asked to waste our time speaking to issues that other people are not asked to speak to.” She mockingly asked whether she needs “to be on repeat every five minutes. So, today, I forgot to condemn al-Qaeda, so here’s the al-Qaeda one. Today, I forgot to condemn FGM [female genital mutilation], so here it goes. Today, I forgot to condemn Hamas, so here it goes.” She said the questions imply that, because she’s Muslim, she might support things “so abhorrent, so offensive, so evil, so vile.”
Her all-American outrage vented, Omar concluded: “I would like , not just for you , but for everyone to know that if you want us to speak as politicians, American politicians, then you treat us as such.”
The audience broke into cheers and applause.
<link>
I think you should give her a fair hearing before you declare her guilty of anti-Semitism or being pro-Hamas.
Last edited: