Learner
Veteran Member
God is a character in a work of fiction. But there's enough material in the work to define his character as monstrous, even before consulting the fan-fic.
Darth Vader is also monstrous. He committed genocide at Alderaan, just as 'God' did on Earth.
Neither the question of what pets Vader had, nor whether Adam and Eve killed animals to make clothes, are addressed in the source work; So speculation on those questions is futile.
I agree with you on the speculation bit with not enough detail in the text i.e. Adam and Eve having clothes made of skin and thats all.
So considering God is monstrous (in regards to your portrayed character ) we (plural) know monstrous and monstrocity and by detesting such monstrocities, we know we are very un-like the character(s) portrayed, God therefore punishes for no reason (hypothetically since you're not a believer).